Indo-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement (LBA), 1974 provides for the exchange of enclaves between the two countries and it necessitated the development and integration of Bangladeshi enclaves in India and addressing issues of rehabilitation of returnees from Indian enclaves in Bangladesh. The 100th Constitutional Amendment Act 2015 amended Schedule 1 of the Indian Constitution due to the signing of the Land Boundary Agreement 1974 (LBA). The topic Exchange Of Territories With Bangladesh is an important part of the UPSC/IAS Exam Polity and Governance syllabus which is discussed in this article in detail.

Historical Background

• The land border between India and Bangladesh is roughly 4,096.7 kilometers long.
• The Radcliffe Award of 1947 established the India-East Pakistan land border.
• The Land Boundary Agreement 1974 was a boundary delineation agreement signed on May 16, 1974, shortly after Bangladesh gained independence, to find a solution to the complicated nature of border demarcation.
• Bangladesh ratified the agreement, but India did not because it involved the secession of territory and the marking of these precise areas on the ground.
• There are 71 Bangladeshi enclaves in India and 102 Indian ones in Bangladesh.
• There are also 28 counter-enclaves and one counter-counter-enclave, both named Dahala Khagrabari, inside those enclaves.
• The residents of these enclaves are living miserable lives as a result of this ambiguity. Because of the sliver of foreign land separating them from their own country, they are unable to access fundamental government services. Ever since Bangladesh's founding, this problem has been unresolved.
• The 1972 Indira-Mujib pact contained a vision to address this issue for the first time.
• Consequently, the 1974 signing of the India-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement between the two nations.
• However, because this agreement involved the exchange of territories, it needed to be approved by the parliaments of both nations.
• India and Bangladesh signed a pact on boundary delineation and the exchange of adversely held enclaves in September 2011.

Land Boundary Agreement (LBA)

• A 4,096 km long land border between India and Bangladesh runs through West Bengal, Assam, Tripura, Meghalaya, and Mizoram.
• Among the international borders that India shares with its neighbours, this one is the longest.
• The Radcliffe Award was used to establish the land border between East Pakistan and India. But there were some disagreements regarding this award.
• An agreement was signed between India and Bangladesh on May 16, 1974, and it was decided that the dispute would be resolved.
• Bangladesh approved the agreement, but India held back because it involved a transfer of territory and a constitutional amendment was required.
• The Land Boundary Agreement's implementation has made it possible for significant cross-border investment by Indian investors in Bangladesh and will open up more opportunities for foreign investment from further afield.
• The two nations have stated that an annual India-Bangladesh Energy Dialogue will be established between the energy ministers of the two nations.
• Comprehensive energy sector cooperation will be pursued through the dialogue, including in the areas of coal, natural gas, LNG, supply of petroleum products in the subregion, renewable energy, and oil and gas pipeline.

100th Amendment Act of 2015

• The 119th constitutional amendment bill was approved by the Indian parliament on May 7, 2015, and after receiving the president's approval, it will become the Constitution 100th Amendment Act of 2015.
• To pass, this amendment required a special majority in the legislature.
• According to the 1974 bilateral LBA, the bill proposed amending the first schedule of the constitution to exchange the disputed regions occupied by both nations.
• The LBA proposed a potential transfer of 111 Indian enclaves to Bangladesh in exchange for 51 Indian enclaves.
• The land transferred to India is smaller than the area transferred to Bangladesh by India.
• In terms of area occupancy, India suffers a net loss overall. This remained a major source of controversy in the afflicted states of the northeast and West Bengal.
• Furthermore, because the majority of the territory in question is occupied by tribals from the Northeastern states, the swapping takes away their land rights, making them more vulnerable.

Significance of the Amendment

• It will help to protect the long-stranded border and prevent illegal migration, smuggling, and criminal activity across it.
• It would assist persons who are stateless by awarding them citizenship in their home nations.
• It would aid in the resolution of boundary disputes in Meghalaya, Tripura, Assam, and West Bengal.
• It would boost access to the region's poor states and help to further develop the region's development efforts.
• As part of India's North-Eastern policy, it would help to improve its connection with Southeast Asia.

Conclusion

As a friendly South Asian neighbor, India was the first nation to recognize Bangladesh as a distinct and independent state. India also immediately established diplomatic ties with Bangladesh following its declaration of independence in December 1971. The Teesta water agreement and the LBA are the two major hindrances to further regional cooperation, development, and trade and would be detrimental to India's short- and long-term national and security interests. The identity crisis that former residents of enclaves experienced prior to the LBA have lost importance in the post-LBA era as attention has shifted to problems with poor governance and conflicts of interest between the Center and the state.

FAQs

MCQs

1. What was the key outcome of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) between India and Bangladesh?

A) Exchange of 50,000 acres of land
B) Agreement on water sharing
C) Resolution of all border disputes
D) Joint military operations along the border

2. Which of the following agreements helped in resolving the issue of disputed border enclaves between India and Bangladesh?

A) The Indira-Mujib Agreement
B) The 1996 Ganga Water Agreement
C) The Shimla Agreement
D) The Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) of 2015

3. How many border enclaves were exchanged under the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement between India and Bangladesh?

A) 162
B) 100
C) 200
D) 50

4. What was one of the main benefits of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement for the residents of the exchanged enclaves?

A) Guaranteed citizenship of both countries
B) Provision of basic services and infrastructure
C) International recognition as refugees
D) Access to special privileges

5. How did the exchange of territories improve border security between India and Bangladesh?

A) It facilitated better patrolling and monitoring
B) It led to the creation of a demilitarized zone
C) It resulted in the construction of new border walls
D) It had no impact on border security

GS Mains Questions and Model Answers

Q1: Analyze the impact of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement on India-Bangladesh relations. How did this agreement contribute to regional stability?

Answer: The 2015 Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) marked a significant step in India-Bangladesh relations, resolving decades of territorial disputes over border enclaves. The agreement, which resulted in the exchange of 162 enclaves, helped eliminate statelessness and provided citizenship to the residents of these areas. By resolving a long-standing issue, the agreement helped build trust and fostered a spirit of cooperation between the two nations. It not only improved diplomatic relations but also contributed to regional stability by ensuring better management of the border, enhancing security cooperation, and addressing issues like illegal migration, cross-border terrorism, and smuggling. The successful implementation of the LBA is a model for peaceful border dispute resolution and reflects both countries’ commitment to fostering peace and stability in the South Asian region.

Q2: Discuss the challenges faced in the implementation of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement. How were these challenges addressed?

Answer: The implementation of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) posed several challenges. One of the major difficulties was the resettlement of the populations in the exchanged enclaves. Many of the residents were left without proper identification or citizenship, which created legal and logistical challenges in integrating them into the mainstream population. Another challenge was the administrative complexity of mapping and demarcating the borders accurately to avoid further disputes. Moreover, both countries had to develop infrastructure and provide essential services like education, healthcare, and security in these previously neglected areas. These challenges were addressed through collaborative efforts, including administrative coordination, local government involvement, and support from international agencies. The bilateral political will and active engagement of both countries ensured the successful resolution of these issues.

Q3: Examine the significance of the Land Boundary Agreement in the broader context of India’s foreign policy in South Asia.

Answer: The Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) between India and Bangladesh holds significant importance in the broader context of India’s foreign policy in South Asia. By resolving a long-standing territorial dispute with Bangladesh, India demonstrated its commitment to peaceful negotiations and conflict resolution. This step not only strengthened bilateral ties but also set an example for resolving territorial disputes through diplomatic means, promoting stability in the region. The agreement showcased India’s regional leadership by improving relations with its neighbors and aligning with the broader goals of South Asian cooperation. The resolution of border disputes with Bangladesh contributed to the vision of a more integrated and peaceful South Asia, where countries prioritize dialogue over conflict. The successful resolution of the LBA is a testament to India’s role as a responsible regional power.

Previous Year Questions on Exchange of Territories with Bangladesh

1. UPSC CSE Mains 2020 (GS Paper 2):

Question: "How did the Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) between India and Bangladesh contribute to regional cooperation and stability in South Asia?"

Answer: The Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) resolved a long-standing border dispute between India and Bangladesh, contributing to regional stability by eliminating statelessness and improving border security. The successful implementation of the agreement demonstrated both countries’ willingness to engage in peaceful dialogue, promoting stronger diplomatic ties and regional cooperation. It also helped in addressing cross-border issues like illegal migration, terrorism, and smuggling, fostering greater cooperation between the two countries in terms of security, trade, and cultural exchanges.

2. UPSC CSE Prelims 2019:

Question: The exchange of territories between India and Bangladesh under the Land Boundary Agreement of 2015 led to the elimination of which of the following?

A) Stateless residents
B) Border disputes
C) Illegal immigration
D) Both A and B

Answer: (D)

Explanation: The exchange of territories under the Land Boundary Agreement of 2015 led to the elimination of both stateless residents and border disputes, resulting in better integration of populations and smoother border management between India and Bangladesh.

*email: contactus@prepp.in