Carbon Border Tax - Environment Notes

Carbon Border Tax is an import duty depending on the amount of carbon emissions created during the product's manufacture. It cuts emissions by acting as a carbon tax. As a trade-related metric, it has an effect on exports and output. The strategy is part of the European Green Deal, which seeks to make Europe the first continent to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050. Carbon Border Tax is also known as Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM). This article explains about the Carbon Border Tax which is important for UPSC IAS exam preparation.

Carbon Border Tax

• A Carbon border adjustment tax or Carbon border tax is an import fee depending on the quantity of carbon emissions produced by the goods in question.
• It inhibits emissions by acting as a carbon price. It has an impact on production and exports as a trade-related metric.
• The plan is part of the European Commission's European Green Deal, which aims to make Europe the first continent to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050.
• A carbon border tax is perhaps preferable than a national carbon tax.
• A national carbon tax is a price imposed by the government on any firm in the country that uses fossil fuels.
• The EU proposes to apply this tax in two stages, beginning on October 1, 2023. During the three-year transition period, only carbon emission reporting laws would apply, with no necessity to pay the Carbon Border Tax.
• Following the transition period, a tax on various items would be charged in stages from 2026 to 2034.
• By 2034, all goods and materials imported into the EU will be subject to CBAM regulations.

Reasons for Imposing a Carbon Tax

• The EU and Climate Change Mitigation: The EU has pledged to reduce carbon emissions by at least 55% by 2030 when compared to 1990 levels. These levels have declined by 24% to date.
  • However, emissions from imports, which account for 20% of the EU's CO2 emissions, are rising.
  • A carbon tax would incentivize other nations to cut GHG emissions, reducing the EU's carbon footprint even further.
• Carbon Leakage: The EU's Emissions Trading System makes it costlier for certain enterprises to operate within the zone. The EU authorities are concerned that these companies would decide to migrate to countries with lower or no emission standards. This is referred to as "carbon leakage," and it raises global emissions.

Carbon Tax - Significance

• The carbon border tax is only the tip of the iceberg for a larger agreement that transforms the EU carbon market to reduce emissions by 62% by 2030, up from the previous target of 43%.
• The EU Carbon Market already limits greenhouse gas emissions from over 11,000 power facilities and manufacturing plants, as well as internal EU flights and 500 airlines.
• The concept allows power providers and companies with high energy needs to acquire "free allowances" to offset emissions under the "polluter pays" principle, which can then be exchanged.
• These rules were critical to the EU's goal to become the world's first carbon-neutral continent, and they have gradually gained support from other blocs.
• For example, for more than 24 hours, negotiators from member states and the parliament have been engaged in serious negotiations over expanding the scope of the EU Carbon market.
• Switching to greener technology and establishing quotas to encourage sectors to pollute less is part of the EU's bigger goal of attaining net neutrality in carbon emissions.
• The carbon border tax is an important component of this objective since it encourages businesses to limit their carbon emissions in order to avoid paying the tax.

Carbon Tax and India

• Climate change burden: India has rejected the tendency by affluent nations to shift the responsibility of doing more to combat climate change while avoiding their own obligations.
• Not focusing on a single fuel source: India has recommended phasing out all fossil fuels, not just coal, which Western countries have targeted and on which India is largely reliant.
• A quick transition: Simply switching to greener energy sources does not imply that all nations should pursue the same level of decarbonisation.
• India, for example, must pursue a low-carbon development plan over a long enough time horizon to assure food and energy security, growth, and employment while leaving no one behind.

Carbon Tax - Challenges

• Response of the BASIC Countries: In a joint statement, the BASIC (Brazil, South Africa, India, and China) countries said the EU proposal was "discriminatory" and violated the principles of equity and 'Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities' (CBDR-RC).
  • These principles recognise that wealthy nations must provide financial and technological help to underdeveloped and vulnerable countries in order to combat climate change.
• India's Impact: The European Union is India's third-largest trading partner. This levy would make Indian goods less appealing to purchasers and might reduce demand by raising the prices of Indian-made items in the EU.
  • Companies having a bigger greenhouse gas footprint would face significant short-term hurdles as a result of the tax.
• Non-Consensual with the Rio Declaration: The EU's notion of having a global environmental standard is not supported by the global consensus contained in Article 12 of the Rio Declaration, which states that standards applicable to developed countries cannot be applied to developing countries.
• Changing competitiveness: It will increase the administrative burden of crossing borders for firms and increase trade frictions, particularly for small enterprises. This will obviously decrease customer choice and increase expenses.
• Protectionist Policy: The policy is also a veiled form of protectionism. Protectionism is defined as government policies that restrict foreign commerce in order to benefit the home industry.
  • Such measures are often conducted with the purpose of increasing domestic economic activity.
  • There is a possibility that it may be used as a protectionist tool, safeguarding domestic businesses from international competition in the name of "green protectionism."

Way forward

• The EU's strategy does not target India; rather, it targets Russia, China, and Turkey, which are big carbon emitters and steel and aluminium exporters to the EU.
• India has no motive to remain at the forefront of the resistance. It should instead approach the EU directly and resolve the problem mutually.
• A measure such as the Carbon Border Tax, which charges imported items at the border, may encourage the adoption of greener technology.
• However, if it occurs without enough aid for modern technology and financing, it will be detrimental to underdeveloped countries.
• As far as India is concerned, it must weigh the benefits and drawbacks of the application of this tax and engage in bilateral discussions with the EU.

Conclusion

The carbon border tax, which is part of the EU's larger aim to restructure its carbon market and attain carbon neutrality by 2050, has received both praise and condemnation. While the tax is considered as an important step towards addressing the climate catastrophe, it has also raised worries about its possible impact on trade, as well as the likelihood of protectionist measures and carbon leakage. The EU Parliament and Council have still to formally adopt the agreement before it takes effect in 2026.

FAQs

MCQs

Question: Consider the following statements

1. Green technology is a wide term that refers to the use of science and technology to create ecologically sustainable goods and services.
2. Green Architecture permits buildings to be constructed in such a way that they maximise available natural light while simultaneously providing adequate insulation to minimise energy use.

Which of the above statements is/are correct about Natural gas?

(a) 1 only

(b) 2 only

(c) Both 1 and 2

(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Question: Which of the following statements is/are correct?

1. A carbon border adjustment tax is a duty on imports based on the amount of carbon emissions produced by the product in question.
2. As a carbon tax, it encourages emissions.

Select the correct answer using the code given below:

(a) 1 only

(b) 2 only

(c) Both 1 and 2

(d) Neither 1 nor 2

*email: contactus@prepp.in