Presiding Officers of the State Legislature play a crucial role in the functioning of the state legislature, ensuring that debates are conducted smoothly, rules are followed, and legislative processes are carried out effectively. There are Speaker, Deputy Speaker for the legislative assembly and Chairman and Deputy Chairman for the legislative council. The UPSC Indian Polity and Governance Syllabus includes Presiding Officers of State Legislature which is described in this article.

Constitutional Provisions Regarding Presiding Officers of the State Legislature

Speaker of Legislative Assembly

The speaker is elected by the assembly itself from amongst its members under Article 178 of the Constitution.

Tenure of a Speaker (Article 179)

• Speaker remains in the office during the life of the assembly. However, has to vacate the office in the following cases:

1. If he ceases to be a member of the assembly.
2. If he resigns by writing to the Deputy Speaker.
3. If removed by an effective majority (Majority of all the then membership of the assembly)

• Such a resolution can be moved only after giving 14 days’ advance notice.
• Whenever the Legislative Assembly is dissolved, the speaker does not resign but continues till the newly elected assembly meets.

Powers and Duties of Speaker

• Maintains order and decorum in the assembly for conducting its business and regulating its proceedings.
• Final interpreter of the provisions of the Constitution of India, the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business of the Legislative Assembly and the legislative precedents, within the assembly.
• Can adjourn the House or suspend the meeting in the absence of quorum. (quorum for meeting of the House is one-tenth of the total strength of the House)
• Decides whether a bill is a money bill or not and his decision in this regard is final.
• Exercises casting vote in case of tie to resolve a deadlock.
• Can allow the secret sitting of the House at the request of the Leader of the House.
• Decides matters of disqualification of MLA on the ground of defection under the Tenth schedule. The decision of the speaker in this regard is subject to judicial review.
• Appoint the chairperson of all the committees of the assembly. He/She is the chairperson of the Business Advisory Committee, the Rules Committee, and the General Purpose Committee.

Deputy Speaker of Assembly

• Like the Speaker, Deputy Speaker is also elected by the assembly itself from amongst its members under Article 178 of the Constitution.
• He/She is elected after the election of the Speaker. Speaker remains in the office during the life of the assembly. However, has to vacate the office in the following cases:

1. If he ceases to be a member of the assembly.
2. If he resigns by writing to the Speaker.
3. If removed by an effective majority (Majority of all the then membership of the assembly)

• Such a resolution can be moved only after giving 14 days’ advance notice.
• The Deputy Speaker performs the duties of the Speaker when the Speaker’s Office is vacant. He also presides over the assembly in the absence of the Speaker.
• When he presides over the assembly in the absence of the Speaker, he has the same powers as the Speaker.
• He is directly responsible to the assembly and not subordinate to the speaker.
• The speaker nominates a panel of chairman from among the members of assembly to preside over the assembly in the absence of the Speaker or the Deputy Speaker.

Chairman of the Legislative Council

• Chairman is elected by the council itself from amongst its members under Article 182 of the Constitution.
• Chairman remains in office during the life of the Council. However, has to vacate the office in the following cases:

1. If he ceases to be a member of the council.
2. If he resigns by writing to the Deputy Chairman.
3. If removed by an effective majority (Majority of all the then membership of the council)

• Such a resolution can be moved only after giving 14 days’ advance notice.
• The powers and functions of the Chairman in the council are similar to those of the Speaker in the assembly. However, the Speaker enjoys one special power ie. his decision on money bill is final and beyond judicial review.

Deputy Chairman of the Legislative Council

• Like the Chairman, Deputy Chairman is elected by the council itself from amongst its members under Article 182 of the Constitution.
• Deputy Chairman remains in office during the life of the Council. However, has to vacate the office in the following cases:

1. If he ceases to be a member of the council.
2. If he resigns by writing to the Chairman.
3. If removed by an effective majority (Majority of all the then membership of the council)

• Such a resolution can be moved only after giving 14 days’ advance notice.
• The Deputy Chairman performs the duties of the Chairman when the Chairman’s Office is vacant. He also presides over the council in the absence of the Chairman.
• When he presides over the council in the absence of the Chairman, he has the same powers as the Chairman.
• The Chairman nominates a panel of vice-chairman from among the members of the council to preside over the council in the absence of the Chairman or the Deputy Chairman.
• Under Article 186, the Salaries and allowances of the Speaker and Deputy Speaker and the Chairman and Deputy Chairman are determined by the State Legislature. They are charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State and thus are not subject to the annual vote of the state legislature.

Issues with the office of the Speaker

• Party Affiliation: Speakers are elected from political parties, raising concerns about their impartiality as they may prioritize party interests over parliamentary neutrality.
• Anti-defection Law: Criticisms arise when Speakers disqualify members under anti-defection laws, with allegations of bias towards ruling parties. Eg. Karnataka MLAs disqualification case 2019, Manipur MLA disqualification case 2020.
• Discretionary Powers: Speakers wield significant discretion, such as determining bills as money bills, leading to controversies like the Aadhar bill being passed as a money bill, raising questions about procedural integrity.
• Limited Accountability: Decisions of the Speaker are final and not subject to appeal or review, limiting mechanisms for challenging potentially biased or erroneous rulings.
• Disruptions and Punishments: Frequent disruptions in proceedings lead to accusations of biased allocation of time and harsher punishments against opposition members, undermining the Speaker's perceived impartiality and effectiveness in maintaining order.

Important Judgements Regarding the Office of Speaker

Conclusion

Presiding Officers of State Legislatures hold a crucial position in the functioning of democratic governance. Their role extends beyond merely chairing sessions; they are entrusted with upholding parliamentary rules, ensuring decorum during debates, and facilitating the legislative process. These officers are instrumental in maintaining the sanctity of legislative proceedings, promoting fairness, and fostering consensus-building among diverse political representatives.

FAQs

MCQs

1. Who serves as the presiding officer of the Vidhan Sabha?

A) Governor
B) Chief Minister
C) Speaker
D) Leader of Opposition

2. Which of the following is a primary responsibility of the presiding officer?

A) Formulating laws
B) Maintaining order in the house
C) Representing the executive
D) Appointing ministers

3. How is the Speaker of the Vidhan Sabha chosen?

A) Appointed by the Governor
B) Elected by the members of the Vidhan Sabha
C) Nominated by the Chief Minister
D) Elected through a public vote

4. What power does the presiding officer have during legislative debates?

A) To veto bills
B) To allocate time for discussions
C) To dismiss members
D) To amend the Constitution

5. What is the role of the Chairman of the Vidhan Parishad?

A) To conduct the sessions of the Vidhan Parishad
B) To act as the Chief Minister
C) To represent the legislative assembly
D) To advise the Governor

GS Mains Questions and Model Answers

Q1: Discuss the functions and powers of the presiding officer in a state legislature and their impact on legislative proceedings.

Answer: The presiding officer in a state legislature plays a crucial role in maintaining order and ensuring that legislative proceedings are conducted smoothly. Their primary functions include managing debates, deciding on points of order, and overseeing the legislative agenda. By promoting fairness and impartiality, the presiding officer facilitates discussions that allow diverse viewpoints to be heard. This can significantly impact the quality of legislative debates and the effectiveness of governance. An efficient presiding officer can enhance the overall functionality of the legislature, ensuring that it operates as a vital organ of democracy.

Q2: Analyze the significance of the Speaker and Chairman in the context of state governance.

Answer: The Speaker of the Vidhan Sabha and the Chairman of the Vidhan Parishad hold pivotal positions within the state governance framework. Their roles are significant as they represent the legislative authority of the state and ensure that the legislative process adheres to the principles of democracy. The Speaker, elected by assembly members, has the responsibility to guide discussions, manage legislative business, and maintain decorum. Similarly, the Chairman oversees the workings of the council, ensuring that discussions remain productive and orderly. Their leadership is essential for facilitating effective governance and promoting accountability in the legislative process.

Q3: Evaluate the challenges faced by presiding officers in managing legislative proceedings.

Answer: Presiding officers often face several challenges in managing legislative proceedings, including maintaining impartiality in politically charged environments and addressing conflicts among members. The need to balance differing opinions while ensuring that debates remain constructive can be difficult. Additionally, presiding officers must navigate the complexities of legislative rules and procedures, which may sometimes lead to disputes over points of order. Effective communication and negotiation skills are crucial in overcoming these challenges, enabling presiding officers to uphold the integrity of the legislative process while fostering a collaborative atmosphere.

Previous Year Questions on the Role of Presiding Officers

1. UPSC CSE Prelims 2020:

Question: What is the primary role of the Speaker of the Vidhan Sabha?

A) To appoint ministers
B) To manage the legislative proceedings
C) To advise the Governor
D) To lead the opposition

Answer: (B)

Explanation: The primary role of the Speaker of the Vidhan Sabha is to manage the legislative proceedings, ensuring order and fairness during debates.

2. UPSC CSE Mains 2019 (GS Paper 1):

Question: "Assess the importance of the presiding officers in the state legislative assemblies and councils." Discuss with examples.

Answer: The presiding officers in state legislative assemblies and councils are critical to the functioning of democracy. They ensure that the legislative process is conducted efficiently and transparently. For example, the Speaker's role in facilitating discussions and allowing members to express their views contributes to the overall quality of governance. Moreover, their authority to maintain decorum helps prevent disruptions, allowing the legislature to operate effectively. This is particularly important in times of political contention, where their impartiality can uphold the democratic process.

*email: contactus@prepp.in