The taxation system is the backbone of a country's economy, ensuring that revenue is stable, that economic growth is managed, and that industrial activity is fueled. Article 269 deals with certain taxes that are levied and collected by the central government but are assigned to the state government (generally consumer states).

Taxes Levied and Collected by the Centre but Assigned to the States - Constitutional Provisions

• Apart from those listed in Article 269 A, all taxes on the "sale or purchase of goods" and "taxes on the consignment of goods" are covered by Article 269(1). These taxes are constitutionally allotted to states, however, they are collected and levied by the Indian government.
• The term "taxes on the sale or purchase of products" does not refer to all types of trade; rather, it refers to taxes imposed on the interstate sale or purchase of all items except newspapers.
• The term "taxes on the consignment of goods" refers to the tax imposed on the consignment of goods when it occurs during inter-state trade. It may include:
  • Succession Duty
  • Central Sales Tax
  • Estate Duty
  • Taxes on railway fares and freights
  • Taxes on transactions in Stock Exchanges
• Article 269(2) mentions that the tax is imposed and collected by the federal government, but it is appropriated by the states. The money gathered from inter-state trade is given to the state that consumes it.
• Article 269(3) states that only the parliament has the authority to make legislation governing interstate and international trade, as well as the allocation of shares.
• The tax collected under this article is not included in India's consolidated fund.

Conclusion

• Article 269 lists the various taxes levied and collected by the Union, as well as the manner in which they are distributed and assigned to states.
• This has changed with the introduction of GST and Article 269(A) and has favoured the consumer states more than the state in which the goods originated.

FAQs

MCQs

1. Which Article of the Indian Constitution deals with taxes levied and collected by the Union but assigned to the states?

A) Article 268
B) Article 269
C) Article 270
D) Article 271

2. Which constitutional amendment introduced Article 269A?

A) 100th Amendment
B) 101st Amendment
C) 102nd Amendment
D) 103rd Amendment

3. Under Article 269, who formulates the principles for distributing the net proceeds of taxes among the states?

A) The President
B) The Finance Commission
C) The Parliament
D) The Comptroller and Auditor General

4. Which tax is NOT covered under Article 269 after the implementation of GST?

A) Taxes on inter-state sale of goods
B) Taxes on consignment of goods in inter-state trade
C) Taxes on sale or purchase of newspapers
D) Taxes on inter-state supply of services

5. What is the primary objective of assigning certain Union taxes to states under Article 269?

A) To reduce the fiscal deficit of the Union
B) To promote uniform taxation across the country
C) To ensure states have access to revenue from inter-state trade
D) To centralize tax collection for better compliance

GS Mains Questions and Model Answers

Q1: Discuss the significance of Article 269 in the context of fiscal federalism in India.

Answer: Article 269 plays a pivotal role in India's fiscal federalism by delineating specific taxes that, although levied and collected by the Union government, are assigned to the states. This arrangement ensures that states receive revenue from inter-state trade, addressing their financial needs and promoting balanced economic development. By empowering Parliament to formulate principles for distributing these tax proceeds among states, Article 269 fosters cooperation between the Union and state governments, thereby strengthening the federal structure. The subsequent introduction of Article 269A, which pertains to the levy and collection of GST on inter-state trade, further redefined fiscal relations, ensuring that revenue-sharing mechanisms adapt to the unified tax system. This combination enhances financial resources for states while maintaining coordinated central oversight.

Q2: Explain how the introduction of Article 269A has impacted the distribution of tax revenue between the Union and the states.

Answer: Article 269A, introduced by the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, restructured the way tax revenue from inter-state trade is shared between the Union and states. Under this provision, the Goods and Services Tax (GST) levied on inter-state supplies is collected by the Union but is shared between the central and state governments. This change streamlined tax collection, reducing disputes over state-level taxes on inter-state trade. The amendment ensures an equitable distribution of revenue, improving the financial health of states and fostering cooperation. The GST Council, established as part of this reform, plays a crucial role in defining how the revenue is apportioned, thus enhancing fiscal federalism and collaborative decision-making.

Q3: Evaluate the challenges associated with the implementation of Article 269 and the introduction of GST through Article 269A.

Answer: The implementation of Article 269 initially involved challenges such as ensuring an equitable distribution of tax revenue among states and maintaining efficient collection mechanisms. The introduction of Article 269A and GST addressed some of these issues by creating a unified tax system for inter-state transactions. However, this shift brought new challenges, including the complexity of apportioning GST revenue between the Union and states. The dependence on the GST Council for decision-making sometimes leads to delays and disagreements. Additionally, states have expressed concerns about the adequacy of compensation for potential revenue losses. While Article 269A promotes transparency and coordination, achieving a balance that satisfies both central and state interests remains an ongoing challenge in the context of India's dynamic fiscal landscape.

Previous Year Questions on Article 269 and Related Provisions

1. UPSC CSE Prelims 2021:

Question: Which Article in the Indian Constitution deals with taxes levied by the Union but assigned to the states?

A) Article 268
B) Article 269
C) Article 270
D) Article 271

Answer: (B)

Explanation: Article 269 of the Indian Constitution outlines specific taxes that are levied and collected by the Union but assigned to the states, ensuring that states receive revenue from inter-state trade and commerce.

2. UPSC CSE Mains 2019 (GS Paper 2):

Question: "Analyze the significance of Article 269A and the role of the GST Council in the financial administration of India."

Answer: Article 269A was introduced to facilitate the levy and collection of GST on inter-state supplies, ensuring that revenue is shared between the Union and the states. This provision aimed to resolve issues related to tax overlap and streamline the taxation system. The GST Council, established under Article 279A, plays a crucial role in recommending tax rates, exemptions, and the apportionment of revenue. The Council's decisions ensure that both the Union and states have a voice in financial policies, promoting cooperative federalism. However, the dependence on consensus within the Council can sometimes delay policy decisions, posing challenges to timely financial management. The combination of Article 269A and the GST Council has enhanced coordination and transparency but requires continuous evaluation to meet the evolving economic needs of the country.

*email: contactus@prepp.in