"Sovereignty" implies that India is a sovereign state, not a dependency or dominion of another country. It has no higher authority than itself and is free to manage its own affairs (both internal and external). In this article the term Sovereignty is described in detail, which is important for UPSC Syllabus.

Sovereignty – Meaning, Nature And Definitions

• The word "sovereignty" comes from the Latin word "superanus," which means "highest." It is, in essence, a legal idea. It indicates state supremacy. To grasp the meaning of the term sovereignty, consider some of the meanings offered by political thinkers.
• Jean Bodin: It is the "total and eternal power of commanding in a state." It is unrestricted absolute power over people and subjects.
• Pollock: It is that power that is neither temporary nor delegated nor subject to certain norms that it cannot change, nor answerable to any other power in the world.
• Burgers: Original absolute unrestricted power over the undivided subjects and overall associations of subjects. It is the capacity to command and compel obedience that is underived and independent.
• D.F Russell: It is the strongest force and absolute authority inside a state, unrestricted by law or anything else.
• Laski: It is "legally supreme over any individual or group, possessing supreme coercive authority."
• The foregoing definitions may differ from one another, but one thing is certain, sovereignty has higher authority.

Sovereignty – Example

• Louis XIV of France’s claim as Sovereign authority during the seventeenth century.
• Idea of Public sovereignty given by Jean-Jacques Rousseau reflected in the concept of the General Will.
• The best example of popular sovereignty, as defined by the Constitution, is voting for representatives.

Sovereignty Of India

• The Preamble of the Indian constitution declares India to be a "Sovereign" country, implying that India has its own supreme law and is not subject to the laws of any other state or nation.
• Furthermore, India is free of any external interference in its own affairs.
• India regards itself as a sovereign state. It means that India has complete autonomy in making internal and external decisions.
• It means that India is a supreme power, and no internal or external forces can challenge the Indian government's authority.
• As a sovereign state, India is immune to any form of foreign meddling in its domestic affairs.

Aspects of sovereignty

• Internal sovereignty: Internal sovereignty refers to the sovereign's jurisdiction over individuals and organisations within his or her territory.
• External sovereignty: External sovereignty refers to the sovereign's ability to interact with other states and international organisations as an autonomous entity free of foreign rule or influence.

Sovereignty – Significance

• On the basis of the attribute of sovereignty, the modern state asserts supremacy in internal matters and freedom from external government interference.
• From a legal standpoint, sovereignty is absolute.
• Sovereignty is indestructible. It lasts for as long as he says it will. Changes in government do not result in the loss of sovereignty; rather, they simply transfer it to the next bearer.
• The state's sovereignty is universal. It encompasses everything within its jurisdiction.
• Sovereignty is an unalienable right. The state's sovereignty cannot be given away without the state's destruction.
• Sovereignty cannot be divided or shared by a group of people. 'If sovereignty is not absolute, no state exists; if sovereignty is divided, more than one state exists; however with the rise of the concept of federalism, Tocqueville, Wheaton, and Halleck introduced the idea of dual sovereignty.'
• Sovereignty is a monopoly. Only the state possesses the sovereign authority and legitimate capacity to compel citizens to follow its orders.
• It's worth repeating that all of these aspects of sovereignty are unique to the legal concept of sovereignty.

Sovereignty – Limitations

• We've already established that sovereignty is the state's supreme power, unrestricted by the law. However, there are various limits that may or should limit the exercise of its powers in practice.

Moral Limitations

• Many early thinkers contended that divine law, natural law, or moral law constrained sovereignty. They largely agreed on religious, moral, and legal values, all of which have an impact on the exercise of sovereignty. However, a human agency must interpret the law of gods and nature.

Constitutional Limitations

• Some writers have contended that the state's constitution limits sovereignty. They distinguish between fundamental or constitutional law and ordinary government laws, claiming the former to be the higher law and the latter lawful only if it is consistent with the former.

International Limitations

• Many contemporary writers believe that a state's sovereignty is constrained by international law and the treaties and conventions it signs with other countries. These constraints are not legally obligatory, according to the strict juristic doctrine of sovereignty. They are self-imposed restrictions that a state may legitimately reject, and there is no legal authority to enforce them.

Recent News

• The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (UNCHR), recently filed an application in the Supreme Court of India seeking to intervene as an amicus curiae in a petition challenging the constitutionality of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 (CAA).
• In a strong reaction, the Indian government stated that the CAA is an internal matter involving Parliament's sovereign right to make laws, and that no foreign body had locus standi (the right or capacity to bring an action or appear in court) on issues concerning India's sovereignty.
• In this context, this case offers an opportunity for India to gain clarity on issues of sovereignty in relation to international law, which may intervene in domestic proceedings.

Conclusion

The concept of sovereignty in the Indian Constitution is a cornerstone that ensures the nation's independence and self-governance. Embodying the principles of democratic governance, the Constitution vests power in the people and establishes a delicate balance between the state and its citizens.

FAQs

MCQs

1. What does external sovereignty mean?

A. The ability of a state to influence other countries
B. The state's authority to govern within its borders
C. The ability to engage in international relations independently
D. The state's power over local governments

2. Which part of the Constitution declares India’s sovereignty?

A. Fundamental Rights
B. Preamble
C. Directive Principles
D. Part IV

3. What does internal sovereignty encompass?

A. Control over foreign policy
B. Governance over international organizations
C. Authority to make and enforce laws within the state
D. Power over the judiciary

4. Which concept prevents sovereignty from being shared?

A. Indivisibility
B. Federalism
C. Judicial Review
D. Division of Power

5. Who holds sovereignty in a democratic republic?

A. The government
B. The judiciary
C. The people
D. The parliament

GS Mains Questions and Model Answers

Q1: Analyze the significance of sovereignty as declared in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution.

Answer: Sovereignty, as mentioned in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution, signifies India’s independence and authority to govern its own affairs without external interference. This concept is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the state and ensuring that decisions regarding governance, law, and foreign policy are made autonomously. The inclusion of sovereignty highlights the people's power and the nation's autonomy in international relations, reflecting democratic ideals.

Q2: Discuss the difference between internal and external sovereignty in the context of the Indian state.

Answer: Internal sovereignty refers to the state's control over its domestic affairs, including law enforcement, governance, and decision-making within its borders. External sovereignty deals with the state's ability to engage in international diplomacy, treaties, and foreign relations without external control. Both forms of sovereignty are essential for ensuring that India remains independent and capable of self-governance, maintaining its national identity and autonomy in the global sphere.

Q3: Evaluate the limitations of sovereignty in the modern globalized world.

Answer: In today’s globalized world, the concept of sovereignty faces limitations due to international treaties, trade agreements, and global institutions like the United Nations. While states maintain the authority to govern within their borders, their external sovereignty is often influenced by international laws and conventions. For instance, countries may adopt policies that align with global standards to ensure cooperation, affecting their sovereign decisions. Despite these limitations, sovereignty remains a fundamental principle for ensuring a state’s autonomy.

Previous Year Questions on Sovereignty

1. UPSC CSE Prelims 2021

Question: Which term in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution reflects the country’s authority over its internal and external matters?
A. Secular
B. Socialist
C. Sovereign
D. Republic

Answer: C

Explanation: The term "Sovereign" in the Preamble of the Indian Constitution signifies that India has complete authority to govern its internal and external matters without external interference.

2. UPSC CSE Mains 2020 (GS Paper 2)

Question: "Sovereignty in the modern world faces both legal and practical challenges." Discuss in light of India's sovereign status in a globalized environment.

Answer: Sovereignty allows India to maintain control over its governance and decision-making. However, in a globalized world, practical challenges such as economic treaties, international laws, and global institutions sometimes limit the exercise of absolute sovereignty. For instance, India must balance its national interests with international agreements in areas like trade and climate change. Despite these challenges, India's status as a sovereign nation remains essential for preserving its autonomy and independent policy-making.

*email: contactus@prepp.in