Freedom of movement means a citizen can freely move within the country. Article 19(1)(d) explains Right to move freely throughout the territory of India. As a result, it forms an important aspect of the Constitution's Fundamental Rights. A citizen of India is free to travel around the country, as well as the ability to leave any country and return to one where you are a citizen. However, this privilege may be curtailed for reasons of security, public order, or to preserve the interests of Scheduled Tribes. Here we will discuss the Right to Freedom of Movement which is important for UPSC General Studies preparation.

Freedom of Movement

• Freedom of Movement permits any citizen to freely migrate around the country's territory. They can easily travel from one state to another or from one location within a state to another.
• This right emphasises the concept that India is one unit in terms of citizens. Thus, the goal is to develop national sentiment rather than parochialism.
• The reasons for establishing reasonable constraints on this freedom are two: the general public's interests and the preservation of the interests of any designated tribe.
• Outsiders are not permitted to enter tribal territories in order to conserve the particular culture, language, customs, and manners of scheduled tribes, as well as to protect their traditional occupation and properties from exploitation.
• The freedom of movement has two dimensions: internal (the right to travel inside the nation) and external (the right to leave the country and return).
  • Article 19 solely covers the first dimension.
  • Article 21 (right to life and personal liberty) addresses the second dimension.

Freedom of Movement - Constitutional Provisions

• Article 19(1)(d) of Part III of the Indian Constitution, addresses the basic right to free movement.
• It grants Indian nationals the freedom to roam freely across India's territory.
• This right coincides with Article 19(1)(e), which mentions the freedom to reside in any region of the country.
• The phrase "freely" means "without any ultimate constraint."
• This right, however, is subject to reasonable limitations imposed by law, as stated in Article 19(5).
• Article 19(5) stipulates that states may place limits on people's freedom of movement in the interest of the general public or to preserve the rights of scheduled tribes.

The Right to Reside and Settle in any part of India's Territories

• Every Indian citizen has the right "to stay and settle in any part of the territory of India," according to Article 19(1)(e) of the Constitution.
• The clause's goal is to break down internal barriers in India or any of its sections.
• This right is likewise subject to the reasonable limitations set forth in Article 19, clause (5).
• The right to reside and the freedom to freely migrate about the country are complementary and frequently go hand in hand.

Freedom of Movement - Restrictions

• Restrictions on the freedom of Movement can only be imposed on two grounds, both of which are listed in Article 19(5) of the constitution, namely the general public's interests and the protection of scheduled tribes' interests.
• Among the current laws, the Official Secrets Act of 1923 is an example of a limitation on free movement enacted in the public's interest.
• People in banned regions are denied entrance under this Act. This is justifiable since it is in the best interests and security of the people.
• The Supreme Court ruled that the freedom of movement of prostitutes can be regulated in the interest of public health and morality.
• Another reason for the limitations is to preserve the rights of the scheduled tribes. Scheduled Tribes are aboriginal tribes with different cultures, customs, and languages that are spread across the country but primarily concentrated in the North East.
• It is seen as necessary to safeguard their interests by excluding others from living in certain places, resulting in fewer conflicts of interest and less negative consequences on these tribal people.

Significance of Freedom of Movement

• Every citizen of India has the right under Article 19(1)(d) and (e) of the Indian Constitution to move freely across India's territory and to reside and settle in any part of it.
• This right is subject to reasonable limitations set by law in the public interest or for the protection of any Scheduled Tribes' interests.
• Foreigners do not have the same freedom of movement and residence as Indian residents.
• Article 19(1)(e) of the Constitution does not grant a foreigner the right to reside and settle in the country. The Indian government has the authority to deport foreigners from the country.
• The free movement of citizens leads to higher employment and lower unemployment rates, as well as to higher productivity and income, and has a positive impact on taxes and social contributions.
• The right to reside and the freedom to freely migrate about the country are complementary and frequently go hand in hand.

Freedom of Movement - Important Judgements

There has long been dispute over whether the deprivation of personal liberty through detention constitutes a violation of rights under Article 21 alone or under Article 19(1)(d) as well.

Conclusion

Freedom of movement is a cornerstone of individual liberty and personal autonomy, allowing individuals to travel, reside, and work freely within their country. This right is essential for the exercise of other fundamental rights, fostering economic development, social integration, and cultural exchange. Upholding freedom of movement is crucial for the preservation of a democratic society where individuals can pursue their aspirations and contribute to the nation's progress without undue hindrance.

FAQs

MCQs

1. Under which Article is the Freedom of Movement provided?

A) Article 15
B) Article 19
C) Article 21
D) Article 22

2. Freedom of Movement in India is restricted under which condition?

A) During a festival
B) For environmental protection
C) National security concerns
D) Economic reasons

3. Which right complements Freedom of Movement for residence purposes?

A) Right to Privacy
B) Right to Equality
C) Right to Property
D) Right to Reside

4. Can Freedom of Movement be restricted in tribal areas?

A) No
B) Yes
C) Only for foreigners
D) Only for non-residents

5. Which document restricts foreigners' movement within India?

A) Citizenship Act
B) Visa regulations
C) Foreigners Act
D) Passport Act

GS Mains Questions and Model Answers

Q1: Analyze the constitutional provisions related to Freedom of Movement in India. How does it impact national integration?

Answer: Freedom of Movement under Article 19(1)(d) enables citizens to move freely within India, fostering national integration and economic growth by supporting inter-state employment and cultural exchange. However, restrictions for security or tribal protections may limit this freedom in certain regions.

Q2: Explain the grounds on which Freedom of Movement can be restricted. What is the role of Article 19(5) in this context?

Answer: Freedom of Movement can be restricted on grounds like public order, national security, and protection of indigenous rights. Article 19(5) authorizes the state to impose such reasonable restrictions, balancing individual freedom with public welfare and security.

Q3: How does Freedom of Movement facilitate economic development in India? Discuss its significance for migrant labor and education sectors.

Answer: Freedom of Movement allows citizens to migrate for better employment and educational opportunities, essential for labor market flexibility and human capital development. It supports rural-to-urban migration, essential for growth in sectors like construction and services.

Previous Year Questions on Freedom of Movement

1. UPSC CSE Prelims 2021:

Question: Under which Article of the Indian Constitution is Freedom of Movement granted to citizens?

A) Article 14
B) Article 19
C) Article 21
D) Article 23

Answer: (B)

Explanation: Article 19(1)(d) provides citizens the right to move freely across India, a fundamental right integral to liberty and democratic freedom.

2. UPSC CSE Mains 2022 (GS Paper 2):

Question: "Discuss the significance of Freedom of Movement in promoting socio-economic development in India." Evaluate its impact on national unity.

Answer: Freedom of Movement supports socio-economic growth by enabling inter-state labor migration and access to diverse educational opportunities. It enhances unity by fostering cultural exchange, essential for a cohesive and integrated national identity.

*email: contactus@prepp.in