All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

18 skilled workers can complete a task in 12 days while 24 semi-skilled workers need 15 days to complete the same task. 12 skilled workers started the task but 3 of them left after a few days. How many semi-skilled workers should replace the 3 skilled ones who left so that the task can be completed in stipulated time?

This question was previously asked in
RRB NTPC 2019 CBT 1 Question Paper (8-Mar-2021) (Shift 2)
The correct answer is
5

This problem involves calculating the work rates of skilled and semi-skilled workers to determine how many semi-skilled workers are needed to replace skilled workers and maintain the task completion timeline.

1. Calculate Worker Rates

First, let's establish the total amount of work and the relative rates of skilled and semi-skilled workers.

  • Let the total work required be $W$.
  • 18 skilled workers complete the task in 12 days. The total work can be represented as $W = 18 \text{ skilled workers} \times 12 \text{ days} = 216$ units (where a unit is the work done by one skilled worker in one day).
  • Let $R_S$ be the rate of one skilled worker. We set $R_S = 1$ unit/day.
  • 24 semi-skilled workers complete the same task in 15 days. So, $W = 24 \text{ semi-skilled workers} \times 15 \text{ days} = 360$ units (where a unit is the work done by one semi-skilled worker in one day).
  • Let $R_{SS}$ be the rate of one semi-skilled worker.
  • To compare rates, we equate the total work: $216 \times R_S = 360 \times R_{SS}$.
  • Finding the ratio of their rates: $ \frac{R_S}{R_{SS}} = \frac{360}{216} = \frac{5}{3} $.
  • This means one skilled worker works $5/3$ times faster than one semi-skilled worker.
  • If we use the skilled worker rate ($R_S = 1$ unit/day), the rate of a semi-skilled worker is $R_{SS} = \frac{3}{5} R_S = \frac{3}{5}$ units/day.

2. Determine Stipulated Time and Required Rate

The question implies maintaining a specific completion time. Let's determine this time based on the initial workforce mentioned.

  • 12 skilled workers started the task.
  • If these 12 skilled workers continued without interruption, the time to complete the total work (216 units) would be: $T = \frac{216 \text{ units}}{12 \text{ workers} \times 1 \text{ unit/day/worker}} = 18$ days.
  • This 18-day duration is the likely "stipulated time".
  • To complete the task in 18 days, the required average work rate is: $\text{Required Rate} = \frac{216 \text{ units}}{18 \text{ days}} = 12$ units/day.

3. Calculate Rate After Workforce Change

Analyze the workforce composition and rate after some workers leave.

  • The initial group had 12 skilled workers, whose combined rate was $12 \times R_S = 12 \times 1 = 12$ units/day. This matches the required rate.
  • 3 skilled workers leave, leaving $12 - 3 = 9$ skilled workers.
  • The rate of these 9 skilled workers is $9 \times R_S = 9 \times 1 = 9$ units/day.

4. Calculate Required Semi-Skilled Workers

Determine how many semi-skilled workers are needed to bring the work rate back to the required level.

  • Let 'x' be the number of semi-skilled workers needed to replace the 3 skilled workers.
  • The new workforce consists of 9 skilled workers and 'x' semi-skilled workers.
  • The new combined rate is $(9 \times R_S) + (x \times R_{SS})$.
  • Substituting the rates: $\text{New Rate} = (9 \times 1) + (x \times \frac{3}{5}) = 9 + \frac{3x}{5}$ units/day.
  • To meet the stipulated time (18 days), this new rate must equal the required rate of 12 units/day.
  • Set up the equation: $9 + \frac{3x}{5} = 12$.
  • Solve for x: $ \frac{3x}{5} = 12 - 9 $ $ \frac{3x}{5} = 3 $ $ 3x = 15 $ $ x = \frac{15}{3} $ $ x = 5 $

Therefore, 5 semi-skilled workers should replace the 3 skilled workers.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. John, Johnny and Janardan can finish a task in a field in 6, 12, and 24 days, respectively. In how many days will they finish the task working together?
  2. Narendra finishes a job in 10 days. Amit completes the same job in 12 days. How many days will it take for both of them to finish the job while working together?
  3. Sita can clean a hotel in 20 days. Rita can clean the same hotel in 30 days. How many days will they take to clean the hotel together?
  4. A, B and C can complete a task in 36, 54 and 72 days respectively. Together they started the task but A left 8 days before the completion of the task while B left 12 days before the completion. The number of days for which C worked is:
  5. A alone can complete $\frac{2}{5}$ of a task in 12 days, while B alone can complete $\frac{3}{4}$ of the same task in 25 days. In how many days can they complete the task if they work together?
  6. If A, B and C can complete a task alone in 15 days, 20 days and 25 days, respectively, then in how many days can they complete the same task if they work together?
  7. A and B working alone can finish a task in 12 and 16 days respectively. In how many days can the task be finished if they work for one day each alternatively, and A begins the work?
  8. Reena and Jaya can complete a piece of work in 6 days and Jaya alone can complete it in 8 days. In how many days can Reena alone complete it?
  9. 12 people can sweep the floor in 4 days with 12 brooms. In how many days can 8 people sweep the floor with 8 brooms?
  10. X can work as fast as Y and Z together. X and Y together can finish the same task 3 times as fast as Z. If all three working together can finish the task in 15 days, how many days, will Z take to finish the task?

Important Questions from Time and Work

  1. Mohan can do a piece of work in 10 days and Sohan in 15 days. They started working together, but after 3 days Mohan left the work . What time will Sohan take to finish the work?

  2. A tank is filled in 8 hours by three taps A, B and C. The tap C is thrice as fast as B and B is twice as fast as A. How much time will pipe B alone take to fill the tank?

  3. Had been one menless, then the number of days required to do a piece of work would have been one more. If the number of Man. Days required to complete the work is 56, how many workers were there?

  4. A can do a piece of work in 16 hours, B and C can do it in 8 hours while A and C can do it 12 hours. How long will B alone take to do it?

  5. lf 12 men can do a work in 20 days, in how many days will the work be done by 15 men-
Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB JE
October 27, 2026
RRB ALP
November 03, 2026
Test Series
RRB NTPC img
Railways
RRB NTPC Under Graduate 2026 New Mock Test Series
1612 Tests 1 Tests Free
687 Attempts
4.3(510)
English, Hindi, Telugu +7 More
More Questions from RRB NTPC

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App