An Unfolding Economic Tragedy

Primary Source: The Hindu

Click here for Daily Current Affairs

Relevance: GS3, India's GDP growth, Challenges faced by the Indian economy, GDP as a measure of economic welfare, GDP Growth Rate Figures, Economic Indicators, Government Policies and Programs, Free grain program, Corporate tax cuts, PLI schemes, Indirect taxes

Prepp Prelims Booster: GDP Growth Rate Figures, Economic Indicators, Government Policies and Programs

Prepp Mains Booster: Indian Economy, Issues relating to Planning, Mobilization of Resources, Growth, DevelopmentandEmployment

Why in the news?

• This article presents a critical analysis of India's reported economic growth, especially in terms of GDP, and challenges the notion that high GDP growth equates to economic success. It argues that GDP is a flawed measure of economic welfare because it fails to account for inequality, job scarcity, poor public services, and environmental damage.
• India's growth, often celebrated as the fastest among major economies, is not a significant achievement given its status as one of the poorest of the major economies.

What is Gross Domestic Product (GDP)?

• Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is a monetary measure that represents the market value of all final goods and services produced within a country during a specific period, typically a year or a quarter.
• It is widely used as an indicator of the economic performance of a country.
• GDP can be calculated using three different approaches:
  • Production (or Output or Value Added) Approach: This method calculates the value of output produced by industries within the country.
  • Income Approach: This method sums up all the incomes earned by individuals and businesses in the production of goods and services. The main components of income approach are wages, rents, interest, and profits.
  • Expenditure Approach: Often considered the most common approach, this method calculates the total expenditure incurred by all entities on goods and services within a country's boundary.
    • The major components of the expenditure approach are consumption (C), investment (I), government spending (G), and net exports (exports minus imports, or X - M).
• GDP is a critical economic metric but, as discussed, it does not encompass all aspects of the well-being of a society or the sustainability of economic progress.
• Therefore, it is often used in conjunction with other indicators to provide a more complete picture of economic health and societal progress.

GDP as a Misleading Metric

GDP, or Gross Domestic Product, is the total monetary value of all finished goods and services produced within a country's borders in a specific time period. It is widely used as an indicator of economic performance. However, its role as a metric for national welfare and economic health can be misleading for several reasons:

• Does Not Account for Inequality: GDP measures total output without considering how it's distributed among the population. A high GDP growth rate can coexist with increasing income inequality, where most wealth accrues to a small segment of society while the majority sees little benefit.
• Ignores Non-Market Transactions: GDP does not include non-market transactions like household labor and volunteer work, which can be substantial and contribute to overall welfare.
• Neglects Quality of Life: GDP does not capture the quality of life or happiness of citizens. Factors like job security, work-life balance, environmental quality, and leisure time are not reflected in GDP figures.
• Overlooks Environmental Costs: GDP can increase in the short term through activities that harm the environment. It doesn’t subtract the cost of environmental degradation or the depletion of natural resources, which can lead to long-term economic and social costs.
• Not a Measure of Sustainability: GDP does not indicate whether the current rate of growth is sustainable in the long term. An economy might be growing due to resource depletion or overconsumption, which are not sustainable practices.
• Ignores Social and Health Costs: Societal issues such as health epidemics, drug addiction, and crime might actually increase GDP because of related healthcare and security services, even though they represent a decrease in societal wellbeing.
• Expenditure versus Production: If GDP is calculated based on production and not actual expenditure, it might not accurately reflect the economy's health.
• Focus on Quantity Over Quality: GDP focuses on the quantity of goods and services produced, not the quality. Improvements in quality of life that don't increase output (like better product durability or free digital services) may not be reflected in GDP.

Pre-COVID Economic Trends vs Post-COVID Economic Fluctuations – A Comparison

Why is India’s Growth Not a Significant Achievement?

• Catch-Up Effect: Economies that start from a lower base have a greater potential for rapid growth—a phenomenon known as the catch-up effect. Since India is starting from a point of lower absolute wealth, it naturally has more room to grow quickly compared to advanced economies that are already operating at a higher baseline.
• Demographics: India has a large, young population entering the workforce, which should theoretically drive higher growth rates simply through increased production and consumption. Thus, high growth rates are expected just to absorb the new workers and maintain employment levels, not necessarily indicating an improvement in overall economic conditions.
• Structural Reforms and Investment: Fast growth in developing countries is often driven by structural reforms, industrialization, and investment in infrastructure. These investments can yield high returns when starting from a low base, but they do not automatically translate into widespread prosperity.
• Purchasing Power Parity and Inequality: High GDP growth rates do not necessarily equate to high per capita income growth or improvements in the average living standards. India’s per capita income remains low compared to developed economies, and its benefits are often unevenly distributed, exacerbating inequality.
• Sustainability of Growth: The quality and sustainability of growth are crucial. If growth is driven by debt-fueled consumption or exploitation of natural resources without regard for the environment, it may not be sustainable in the long term.
• Comparative Advantage: As a developing economy, India has a comparative advantage in labour-intensive industries, which can drive exports and growth. However, this does not reflect the overall technological or productivity advancement required for sustained economic improvement.
• Unemployment and Underemployment: High GDP growth must be accompanied by the creation of jobs that offer decent wages and conditions. In many cases, fast-growing economies like India face challenges of underemployment and job scarcity, indicating that the economy is not growing fast enough to provide high-quality jobs for its population.
• Human Development Indicators: Economic growth should lead to improvements in healthcare, education, and life expectancy, among other human development indicators. India's growth has not always correlated with commensurate improvements in these areas.

Why Do We Need to Bolster Demand?

• Underemployment and Job Scarcity: High levels of GDP growth can mask the underlying issues of job scarcity and underemployment. If people don't have jobs or are underemployed, they lack the income necessary to purchase goods and services, which in turn stifles economic growth.
• Inequality: GDP growth often does not reflect how wealth and income are distributed across a society. If the majority of the population lacks the financial means, the demand will be constrained, and economic growth will not benefit the population at large.
• Sustainable Investment: When private corporate investment is declining, it's often a sign that businesses anticipate weak demand. Without confidence in future demand, businesses are less likely to invest in new projects or expand operations, leading to a cycle of reduced economic activity.
• Consumer Spending and Savings: Households have reduced their savings rate and are increasingly incurring debt, indicating that they are struggling to maintain consumption. If this trend continues, it could lead to a further reduction in demand and possibly trigger a financial crisis among consumers.
• Export Limitations: With limited growth in world trade and an overvalued currency, there is a cap on how much exports can contribute to demand. Therefore, domestic demand becomes even more crucial for sustaining economic growth.
• Fiscal Policy Impact: Reliance on indirect taxes, which disproportionately affect lower-income individuals, can reduce disposable income and thus further constrain demand.

Way Forward

Addressing the issue of weak demand in the Indian economy requires a multi-faceted approach that focuses on both short-term reliefs to stimulate demand and long-term structural reforms to ensure sustainable growth.

Short-term Measures to Stimulate Demand

• Direct Cash Transfers: Implementing targeted cash transfer programs to the poorest households can quickly increase purchasing power and stimulate demand.
• Public Employment Schemes: Expanding public employment programs can provide immediate job opportunities and income support, increasing spending and demand.
• Reduction in Indirect Taxes: Temporarily lowering GST rates on essential goods and services can boost consumption by making items more affordable.
• Credit Access: Easing credit for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and lower-income groups can help boost spending and entrepreneurial activity.
• Social Safety Nets: Strengthening social safety nets, including food security, health insurance, and unemployment benefits, can provide a cushion for the vulnerable population, ensuring that they can still participate in the economy.

Long-term Structural Reforms

• Job Creation: Focusing on sectors with high employment elasticity, like manufacturing, construction, and services, can create more jobs and thus, increase income and demand.
• Skill Development: Investing in education and vocational training can improve the employability of the workforce, leading to better job opportunities and higher incomes.
• Infrastructure Development: Improving urban infrastructure and connectivity can lead to more efficient cities and unlock economic potential across regions.
• Agricultural Reforms: Modernizing the agricultural sector through better infrastructure, market access, and technology can increase farmers' incomes and rural demand.
• Judicial and Administrative Reforms: Streamlining the judicial system and cutting red tape can improve the ease of doing business, attracting more investment and stimulating economic activity.
• Environmental Sustainability: Focusing on green technologies and sustainable practices can create new industries and jobs, while also ensuring long-term ecological balance.
• Healthcare Investment: Strengthening the healthcare system can reduce the economic burden of poor health on families and increase their spending capacity.
• Income Redistribution Policies: Implementing progressive taxation and increasing public spending on welfare programs can help redistribute income more equitably and increase overall demand.
• Innovation and Research: Encouraging innovation and research through subsidies and grants can create high-value industries and jobs.
• Market Diversification: Expanding trade agreements and finding new markets for exports can reduce dependence on slow-growing global trade.
• Strengthening Financial Systems: Ensuring robust financial oversight and support for responsible lending can help maintain consumer credit without risking high levels of default.

Conclusion

The celebrated GDP growth narrative is flawed, not addressing deeper economic challenges. Realistic GDP growth forecast stands at 3%-4% in the medium term. Persistent mismatch between the high-growth narrative and actual economic conditions risks potential tragedy.

(*Click this link to read prelims specific weekly current affairs articles)

FAQs

MCQs

Question: Consider the following statements: (UPSC 2023)

Statement-I: In the post-pandemic recent past, many Central Banks worldwide had carried out interest rate hikes.

Statement-II: Central Banks generally assume that they have the ability to counteract the rising consumer prices via monetary policy means.

Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?

(a) Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct and Statement-II is the correct explanation for Statement-I

(b) Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct and Statement-II is not the correct explanation for Statement-I

(c) Statement-I is correct but Statement-II is· incorrect

(d) Statement-I is incorrect but Statement-II is correct

Question: Increase in absolute and per capita real GNP do not connote a higher level of economic development, if (UPSC 2018)

(a) industrial output fails to keep pace with agricultural output.

(b) agricultural output fails to keep pace with industrial output.

(c) poverty and unemployment increase.

(d) imports grow faster than exports.

Question: Consider the following statements: (UPSC 2017)

(1) Tax revenue as a percent of GDP of India has steadily increased in the last decade.

(2) Fiscal deficit as a percent of GDP of India has steadily increased in the last decade.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

(a) 1 only

(b) 2 only

(c) Both 1 and 2

(d) Neither 1 nor 2

Question: What does a high Gini coefficient indicate about a country's economic condition?

(a) Low levels of inflation

(b) Equitable distribution of income

(c) High levels of income inequality

(d) Steady GDP growth