The creation of a Federal court in India was advocated by which of the following Acts/Commissions?
The Government of India Act, 1935
Creation of Federal Court in India
The question asks about the legislative act or commission that advocated for the establishment of a Federal court in India. Understanding the historical context of constitutional developments in British India is key to answering this.
Analyzing the Government of India Act, 1935
The Government of India Act, 1935 was a landmark legislation enacted by the British Parliament. It proposed several significant changes to the governance of India, including the creation of an All India Federation and the establishment of a federal judiciary.
- One of the key provisions of the 1935 Act was the provision for setting up a Federal Court.
- This court was intended to interpret the Act and decide disputes between the federal units (provinces and princely states) and the federal government, as well as disputes between the units themselves.
- Appeals from the High Courts in the provinces could also be taken to the Federal Court.
- The Federal Court of India was subsequently established on October 1, 1937, in Delhi.
Therefore, the creation of the Federal court in India was directly advocated and provisioned by the Government of India Act, 1935.
Reviewing Other Options
Let's briefly look at the other options to understand why they are not the correct answer in the context of the Federal court:
- The Government of India Act, 1919: This Act, also known as the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, introduced Dyarchy in the provinces and made some changes to the central government structure. While it was an important step in constitutional reform, it did not advocate for the creation of a Federal court.
- The Lee Commission, 1923: This commission, formally known as the Royal Commission on the Superior Civil Services in India, was primarily concerned with the organization and recruitment of public services in India. It had no role in the establishment of a Federal court.
- The Indian Councils Act, 1909: Also known as the Morley-Minto Reforms, this Act introduced separate electorates for Muslims and increased the size and functions of the legislative councils. It did not propose the creation of a Federal court.
Based on the historical development of the Indian judiciary and constitutional framework, the Government of India Act, 1935, is the correct answer as it explicitly provided for the establishment of the Federal Court.
Key Provisions of the Government of India Act, 1935
The 1935 Act was extensive and complex. Some of its main features included:
- Proposal for an All India Federation.
- Division of powers between the Centre and units into Federal, Provincial, and Concurrent lists.
- Introduction of provincial autonomy.
- Establishment of a Federal Court.
- Provision for a Reserve Bank of India.
- Introduction of Dyarchy at the Centre.
The establishment of the Federal Court was a crucial step towards creating a structured judicial system that could handle constitutional matters and inter-unit disputes in a future federal setup.
Role and Function of the Federal Court
The Federal Court established under the 1935 Act had specific jurisdictions:
- Original Jurisdiction: To decide disputes between the Centre and provinces, and between provinces.
- Appellate Jurisdiction: To hear appeals from the High Courts in constitutional matters and interpret the Government of India Act, 1935.
- Advisory Jurisdiction: To provide advisory opinions to the Governor-General.
The decisions of the Federal Court could be appealed to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London.
| Act/Commission | Key Focus | Advocated for Federal Court? |
|---|---|---|
| Government of India Act, 1919 | Dyarchy in provinces, Central legislature changes | No |
| Lee Commission, 1923 | Public Services | No |
| Government of India Act, 1935 | All India Federation, Provincial Autonomy, Division of Powers, Federal Court | Yes |
| Indian Councils Act, 1909 | Legislative Councils, Separate Electorates | No |
In conclusion, the historical evidence clearly indicates that the proposal and legal basis for creating a Federal court in India came from the Government of India Act, 1935.
Revision Table: Government of India Act, 1935 and Federal Court
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Act Name | The Government of India Act, 1935 |
| Key Provision related to Judiciary | Establishment of a Federal Court |
| Date of Federal Court Establishment | October 1, 1937 |
| Location of Federal Court | Delhi |
| Federal Court's Jurisdiction | Original (Centre vs Units, Units vs Units), Appellate (Constitutional matters), Advisory |
| Higher Appeal Body | Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (London) |
Additional Information: Evolution of Judiciary in India
The Federal Court established under the Government of India Act, 1935, served as a crucial precursor to the Supreme Court of India. After India gained independence and adopted its Constitution in 1950, the Supreme Court of India was established, succeeding the Federal Court. The Supreme Court inherited some of the functions of the Federal Court and also gained enhanced powers and jurisdiction, becoming the highest judicial authority in the Republic of India.
The structure and powers outlined in the 1935 Act for the Federal Court laid important groundwork for the independent judiciary envisioned in the Constitution of India.
Similar Questions
In 1943, young leaders in which one of the following districts of Maharashtra set up parallel Government (Prati sarkar) with volunteer corps (Seva dals) and village units (tufan dals)?
Match List-I wish List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists:
List-I (Act/ Event)
List-II (Year)
A. Rowlatt Act
1922
B. Salt March
1931
C. Chauri Chaura Incident
1930
D. Second Round Table Conference
1919
In the elections to the provincial legislatures in 1937 in British India:
1. Only about 10 to 12 percent of the population had the right to vote
2. The untouchables had no right to vote
3. The Congress won an absolute majority in five out of eleven provinces
4. The Muslim League won more than 80 percent of the seats reserved for Muslims
Select the correct answer using the code given below:On 31st December 1929, in which of the following Congress Sessions was the proclamation of Purna Swaraj made?
Which one among the following was India's first trade union in the proper sense of the term?
Who among the following formed the National Liberation Federation (Liberal Party)?
Directions: The following five (5) items consist of two statements, Statement I and Statement II. Examine these two statements carefully and select the correct answer using the code given below.
Statement I: The Communists left the All India Trade Union Congress in 1931.
Statement II: By 1928, the Communists were no longer working with the mainstream national movement.
Consider the following statements about the Salt March:
1. The Salt March was deliberately ignored by the European media.
2. The Salt March was widely covered by the American and European press.
3. The Salt March was the first nationalist activity in which women participated in large numbers.
4. The Salt March impressed upon the British the urgent need to devolve more power to Indians.
Which of the statements given above are correct?The call for ‘renunciation of (all) voluntary associations with the (British) Government’ was given during
Who among the following gave evidence before the Joint Select Committee on the Government of India Bill,1919 in favour of female franchise?
1. Mrs. Annie Basant
2. Mrs Sarojini Naidu
3. Mrs Hira bai Tata
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
Important Questions from National movement (1919 - 1939)
Chauri Chaura incident occurred in which year ______.
In which year did Motilal Nehru (Chairman) and eight other Congress leaders draft a constitution for India?
C. Rajagopalachari led the Salt Satyagraha in which of the following states?
Who among the following was one of the founders of the Hindustan Republic Association?
Match the following events of 1920 with their dates before the Non- Co-operation Movement.
a. Political Conference of Raipur i. April 1920 b. Anti Rowlatt Act Black
Day in Bilaspurii. September 1920 c. First Labour Movement started
in Rajnandgaoniii. 17 March 1920 d. Meeting of leaders of Dhamtari
in Kandel Villageiv. 20 March 1920
