All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

The following question consists of six sentences of a passage. The first and the sixth sentences are given in the beginning as S1 and S6. The middle four sentences in each have been jumbled up and labelled P, Q, R and S. You are required to find the proper sequence of the four sentences and mark your response accordingly.

S1: History is a subject that is so little valued today that it is almost impossible to win world fame as a historian, yet that is exactly what Toynbee was able to.

S6: Among the civilizations that he studied was that of India.

P: We usually think of history as a chronological account of the development of various states and empires under the ruler.

Q: Toynbee’s view of history was different.

R: He tries to find the pattern behind the birth, growth and decay of civilization.

S: Though he used the recorded history of mankind, he was interested not merely in the chronology of single states or group but in the rise and fall of whole civilizations.

The correct sequence should be

This question was previously asked in
CDS I 2017 General Knowledge Previous Year Paper (05-Feb-2017)
The correct answer is

P Q S R

Analyzing Jumbled Sentences: Finding the Correct Sequence

The question asks us to arrange the four jumbled sentences (P, Q, R, S) in a logical sequence between the given first sentence (S1) and the last sentence (S6) of a passage. Let's first read all the sentences carefully to understand the topic and identify potential connections.

S1: History is a subject that is so little valued today that it is almost impossible to win world fame as a historian, yet that is exactly what Toynbee was able to.

S6: Among the civilizations that he studied was that of India.

P: We usually think of history as a chronological account of the development of various states and empires under the ruler.

Q: Toynbee’s view of history was different.

R: He tries to find the pattern behind the birth, growth and decay of civilization.

S: Though he used the recorded history of mankind, he was interested not merely in the chronology of single states or group but in the rise and fall of whole civilizations.

Identifying the Flow and Connections

The passage starts by introducing Arnold Toynbee, a famous historian (S1). S6 provides a specific detail about his work (studying India). The middle sentences (P, Q, R, S) must describe Toynbee's approach to history, connecting S1 to S6.

  • S1 introduces Toynbee and mentions his work as a historian.
  • Sentence P describes the common perception of history – a chronological account of states/empires. This sets up a contrast.
  • Sentence Q explicitly states that Toynbee's view was "different". This difference is likely from the common view mentioned in P. So, Q should follow P.
  • Sentence S explains *how* Toynbee's view was different. It clarifies that he focused on the "rise and fall of whole civilizations" rather than just chronology of states/groups, even though he used recorded history. This expands on the statement in Q. So, S should follow Q.
  • Sentence R describes *what* Toynbee was trying to find – the "pattern behind the birth, growth and decay of civilization". This objective aligns perfectly with the focus on "whole civilizations" mentioned in S. So, R should follow S.
  • The sequence P → Q → S → R establishes a logical flow: from the common view of history (P), to stating Toynbee's view was different (Q), explaining the difference by his focus on civilizations (S), and finally stating his goal of finding patterns in civilizations (R).
  • This sequence PQSR fits well between S1 (Introducing Toynbee) and S6 (Giving an example of a civilization he studied).

Analyzing the Sequence PQSR

  • S1: Introduces Toynbee.
  • P: Describes the usual view of history.
  • Q: States Toynbee's view was different from the usual view.
  • S: Explains the difference - focus on civilizations, not just states.
  • R: Describes what he sought in studying civilizations - patterns.
  • S6: Gives an example of a civilization he studied.

This order creates a coherent and logical passage.

Conclusion

Based on the logical connections and flow of ideas between the sentences, the correct sequence of the jumbled sentences P, Q, R, and S is P Q S R.

Revision Table: Understanding Sentence Order

Sentence Content Focus Connection/Clue
S1 Introduction to Toynbee Sets the stage, mentions the historian.
P Standard view of history Provides a baseline for comparison.
Q Toynbee's view is different Direct contrast to the view in P.
S Detailing Toynbee's different view Explains the difference mentioned in Q (focus on civilizations).
R Purpose of Toynbee's study Explains the goal of studying civilizations as described in S.
S6 Example of study Specific detail following the general description of his work (R).

Additional Information: Arnold Toynbee and History

Arnold Toynbee (1889-1975) was a highly influential British historian known for his twelve-volume work, A Study of History. Unlike many historians who focused on the history of individual nations or periods, Toynbee took a much broader approach, examining the rise, growth, and disintegration of major world civilizations across vast spans of time. His work attempted to find overarching patterns and laws governing the development of these civilizations, often using a "challenge and response" model to explain their growth and decline. His focus on comparative history and civilizations was indeed a departure from the more common chronological narratives of specific states or empires, as described in the passage.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    near villages or herder camps (P) / shangdongs are traditional (Q) / stonewalls, usually built (R) / trapping pits with inverted funnel-shaped (S)

  2. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    present existential perils (P) / all over the world (Q) / the extremes (R) / of climate change (S)

  3. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    several antiquities from other (P) / nations over the years (Q) / India has (R) / brought back (S)

  4. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1), (2), (3) and (4) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    India has become (P) / with time (Q) / accounting for 25 per cent of the total available water (R) / the world's largest extractor of groundwater (S)

  5. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    the Aravalli hill ranges (P) / of the Yamuna river and  (Q) / are spread out over the natural landscapes (R) / the biodiversity parks (S)

  6. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    the family found out (P) /  their mother's friends were going to   (Q) /  that some of  (R) / Poland in a car (S)

  7. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    earth may seem immense (P) /  from the perspective of humans (Q) / and almost limitless (R) / living on its surface (S)

  8. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    emerge at last into a (P) /  those who passed through  (Q) /  country of unearthly beauty  (R) / that valley of darkness (S)

  9. Direction: The following item in this section consists of a sentence, chunks of which have been jumbled up. These chunks have been labelled as P, Q, R and S. Each sentence is followed by four sequences, namely (1 ), (2 ), (3 ) and (4 ) indicating the rearrangement of the chunks. You are required to select the most appropriate option.

    in terms of trading volumes, (P) / have grown substantially (Q) / market capitalization and  turnover (R) / the Indian financial markets (S)

  10. In the following question, there is a sentence of which some parts have been jumbled up. You are required to rearrange these parts which are labelled P, Q, R and S to produce the correct sentence. Choose the proper sequence and mark the corresponding option.

    he was a tiny man (P) with a sprightly walk (Q) tall (R) barely five feet (S)

    The correct sequence should be


Important Questions from Sentence Jumbles

  1. Rearrange the following jumbled sentences to make a meaningful one

    P : weather conditions across a vast geographic

    Q : the climate of India

    R : scale and varied topography

    S : comprises a wide range of

    The proper sequence should be :

  2. In the following question, parts of a sentence have been jumbled and labelled as P, Q, R, and S. You are required to rearrange the jumbled parts of the sentence and mark your response accordingly by selecting the correct option:

    P. baffling even seasoned experts

    Q. remained elusive,

    R. Despite strenuous efforts by the investigative agency,

    S. key details of the intricate financial fraud

  3. Rearrange the jumbled words to form a meaningful sentence:

    A. displacements from

    B. farmers fear

    C. large scale

    D. special

    E. economic zones

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

  4. Rearrange the given phrases to form a sentence with superlative degree of comparison:

    of all the metals | Iron | is the | most useful. 

  5. Rearrange the phrases to make a meaningful sentence:

    A. type of ray that could

    B. in 1895, Wilhelm Rontgen

    C. penetrate objects, including human tissue

    D. discovered a new

    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
NDA
September 13, 2026
CDS
September 13, 2026
Test Series
CDS img
Defence
UPSC CDS 2026 Mock Test Series
540 Tests 4 Tests Free
1119 Attempts
4.3(168)
English, Hindi
More Questions from CDS

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App