Statement I: The United Provinces during Non-Cooperation became one of the strongest bases of Congress. Statement II: The literary outcrop of Non-Cooperation in Bengal was quite meager compared to the days of the Swadeshi agitation.
Analyzing Statements on Non-Cooperation Movement: United Provinces and Bengal
Let's carefully examine each statement related to the Non-Cooperation Movement to determine its accuracy and the relationship between them.
Statement I: The United Provinces during Non-Cooperation became one of the strongest bases of Congress.
This statement talks about the role of the United Provinces (UP) during the Non-Cooperation Movement (1920-1922). The Non-Cooperation Movement saw widespread participation across India. In UP, particularly in the Awadh region, a strong peasant movement was already underway, primarily against Taluqdars (landlords). Leaders like Baba Ramchandra were prominent in organizing peasants.
- Congress leaders, including Jawaharlal Nehru, made efforts to integrate this peasant unrest into the broader Non-Cooperation Movement.
- The issues of high rents, illegal cesses (abwabs), and forced labour (begar) resonated deeply with the rural population in UP, making them receptive to the calls for non-cooperation.
- Incidents like the Eka Movement in northern Awadh and the disturbances in Chauri Chaura (Gorakhpur district, UP) highlight the intense activity and strong base the movement had in the region.
Given the widespread peasant mobilization and Congress's engagement, the United Provinces did indeed emerge as a significant and strong base for the Non-Cooperation Movement.
Thus, Statement I is true.
Statement II: The literary outcrop of Non-Cooperation in Bengal was quite meager compared to the days of the Swadeshi agitation.
This statement compares the literary output during the Non-Cooperation Movement in Bengal with that during the Swadeshi Agitation (1905-1908).
- The Swadeshi movement in Bengal was not just a political movement but also involved a significant cultural and literary revival. It inspired a surge in patriotic songs, poems, plays, and prose literature, reflecting nationalist sentiments and a sense of Bengali identity. Figures like Rabindranath Tagore, Kazi Nazrul Islam (though his major works came slightly later, the spirit was linked), and many others contributed significantly to this cultural awakening.
- The Non-Cooperation Movement, while having cultural elements like the boycott of foreign goods and promotion of national education, had a primary focus on mass political action and boycotts of government institutions (legislatures, courts, schools).
- While literary activities did continue during the Non-Cooperation period, the intensity and sheer volume of overtly patriotic or nationalist literary works specifically tied to the movement's themes are often considered less pronounced when directly compared to the explosive creative energy witnessed during the peak of the Swadeshi agitation in Bengal. The nature of the movements was slightly different in terms of their immediate impact on cultural production.
Based on historical accounts comparing the cultural phases of these two significant movements in Bengal, it is generally accepted that the literary output directly inspired by or linked to the Non-Cooperation Movement was less extensive and vibrant compared to the cultural renaissance associated with the Swadeshi period.
Thus, Statement II is true.
Relationship Between Statement I and Statement II
Statement I discusses the political base of the Non-Cooperation Movement in the United Provinces, focusing on its strength there due to factors like peasant mobilization.
Statement II discusses the comparative level of literary output in Bengal during Non-Cooperation versus Swadeshi Agitation.
These two statements address different aspects (political strength vs. literary activity) in different regions (United Provinces vs. Bengal) during different but related periods (Non-Cooperation vs. Swadeshi). There is no logical or causal connection where the literary output in Bengal during Non-Cooperation would explain the strength of the movement's base in the United Provinces.
Therefore, Statement II is not the correct explanation of Statement I.
Conclusion
Both Statement I and Statement II are individually true, but Statement II does not explain Statement I. This aligns with Option 2.
| Statement | Assessment | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Statement I: UP was a strong base of Congress during Non-Cooperation. | True | Widespread peasant movement and Congress integration made UP a key area for Non-Cooperation. |
| Statement II: Literary output in Bengal during Non-Cooperation was meager compared to Swadeshi. | True | Swadeshi saw a greater cultural-literary renaissance compared to the focus of Non-Cooperation. |
| Relationship | No explanation | Discuss different regions and aspects of national movement; no causal link. |
Revision Table: Key Aspects of National Movements
| Movement/Region | Period | Key Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Swadeshi Agitation (Bengal) | 1905-1908 (Approx) | Anti-partition movement, boycott of foreign goods, promotion of indigenous industries, significant cultural and literary revival, national education. |
| Non-Cooperation Movement | 1920-1922 | Led by Gandhi, boycott of government schools, colleges, courts, councils, foreign goods; promotion of Khadi and national education institutions; Hindu-Muslim unity (Khilafat issue); mass participation. |
| United Provinces (UP) during Non-Cooperation | 1920-1922 | Strong peasant movement integrated by Congress, anti-landlord struggles, significant rural support for Non-Cooperation. |
| Bengal during Non-Cooperation | 1920-1922 | Participation in boycotts (schools, councils), but comparative literary output lower than Swadeshi era. |
Additional Information on Non-Cooperation Movement
The Non-Cooperation Movement was a pivotal phase in India's struggle for independence, marking Gandhi's first large-scale mass movement.
- Causes: Included the Rowlatt Act, the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, and the Khilafat issue.
- Methods: Non-violent protest, boycott of British institutions (schools, courts, legislature, foreign goods, titles, honours), promotion of Swadeshi (especially Khadi), establishment of national schools and colleges (like Jamia Millia Islamia, Kashi Vidyapeeth, Gujarat Vidyapeeth).
- Participation: Involved various sections of society - urban middle class, peasants, workers, students, women.
- Withdrawal: The movement was abruptly called off by Gandhi in February 1922 following the violent Chauri Chaura incident, where protestors attacked a police station.
- Impact: Demonstrated the potential for mass mobilization, spread the nationalist message to remote parts of India, fostered Hindu-Muslim unity (initially), and significantly boosted the Congress Party's base among common people. It shifted the focus of the freedom struggle to mass action rather than just constitutional methods.
Similar Questions
Statement I: Non-cooperation began in Punjab with the student movement inspired by Lala Lajpat Rai in January 1921.
Statement II: The Sikh dominated central Punjab countryside was stirred by the powerful Akali upsurge.
- Which of the following is/are the correct components of the "Lion Capital" at Sarnath?
1. The shaft (stambha-yashti) or the tall tapering column
2. An elliptical top part – the abacus, devoid of any carvings
3. Overflowing inverted petals below the abacus
Select the answer using the code given below : Which of the following statements is/are correct?
1. Shivaji sent an ambassador to Bombay to negotiate an agreement with the English.
2. His chief motive was to secure English aid against the Siddis of Danda - Rajpuri.
3. He wanted a supply of grenades, mortars and other ammunition.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:Who was the editor of the journal Indian Social Reformer that was started in 1890?
Which member of the Servants of India Society founded the Seva Samiti at Allahabad in 1914?
Who was the author of the book, Plagues and Peoples?
In 1921, during which one of the following tours, Gandhiji shaved his head and began wearing loincloth in order to identify with the poor?
Which politician in British India had opposed to a Pakistan that would mean “Muslim Raj here and Hindu Raj elsewhere”?
Which one of the following British officials was elevated to the position of Governor General after the Regulating Act of 1773 ?
Which of the following ideas was preached by the Kherwar or Sapha Har movement of the 1870s ?
Important Questions from Modern India (National Movement )
Match the following (Leaders of Chhattisgarh imprisoned during Quit India Movement of 1942 and places)
List - I
(Leaders)
List - II
(Places)
A. Tretanath Tiwari 1. Malkapur B. Raghunandan Pd. Singhrol 2. Raipur C. Amar Singh Sahgal 3. Bilaspur D. Pt. Ravishankar Shukla 4. Durg Which of the following personalities of this state was pioneer in the field of emancipation of untouchables ?
Tipu Sultan and British East India Company signed the Treaty of Mangalore in the year _______.
When was the Battle of Waterloo fought ?
Who among the following is also known as the 'Birdman of India'?
