Parts of the following sentence are given as options. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error. Scarcely had the train stopped at the platform than the passengers started pushing each other to enter the train.
Understanding the Grammatical Error
The question asks us to identify the segment of the given sentence that contains a grammatical error. Let's look at the sentence:
"Scarcely had the train stopped at the platform than the passengers started pushing each other to enter the train."
This sentence uses the correlative conjunction structure involving "Scarcely had". Correlative conjunctions are pairs of conjunctions used to connect two balanced clauses, phrases, or words.
Analyzing the Sentence Structure: Scarcely/Hardly
When using structures like "Scarcely had" or "Hardly had", the correct conjunction to introduce the second part of the sentence (the event that happened immediately after the first) is typically "when" or "before", not "than". The structure is:
- Scarcely had + Subject + Verb (past participle) + ... + when / before + Subject + Verb (simple past) + ...
- Hardly had + Subject + Verb (past participle) + ... + when / before + Subject + Verb (simple past) + ...
In the given sentence, the structure used is "Scarcely had the train stopped... than the passengers started...". This deviates from the correct structure.
Evaluating Each Option for Grammatical Correctness
Let's examine each option provided:
- to enter the train: This is an infinitive phrase acting adverbially, explaining the purpose of pushing. This part is grammatically correct in context.
- than the passengers: This segment contains the conjunction "than" which is incorrectly used with "Scarcely had". The correct conjunction should be "when" or "before". Therefore, this segment contains the grammatical error.
- started pushing each other: This is the verb phrase in the second clause, correctly using the simple past tense "started". "Each other" is also used correctly here as a reciprocal pronoun. This part is grammatically sound.
- stopped at the platform: This is the past participle form "stopped" used correctly after "had" in the first clause, indicating a past perfect structure in the inverted form "Scarcely had the train stopped". The prepositional phrase "at the platform" is also correct. This part is grammatically correct.
Identifying the Incorrect Segment
Based on the analysis of the "Scarcely had... when/before" rule, the segment containing the error is "than the passengers", specifically because of the incorrect use of "than". The sentence should correctly be:
"Scarcely had the train stopped at the platform when the passengers started pushing each other to enter the train."
or
"Scarcely had the train stopped at the platform before the passengers started pushing each other to enter the train."
The error lies in replacing "when" or "before" with "than".
Conclusion on the Grammatical Error
The segment than the passengers contains the grammatical error due to the incorrect conjunction used with "Scarcely had".
| Sentence Segment | Grammatical Analysis | Error? |
|---|---|---|
| Scarcely had the train stopped at the platform | Correct use of 'Scarcely had' structure start. 'stopped' is correct past participle. 'at the platform' is correct. | No |
| than the passengers | Incorrect conjunction 'than' used with 'Scarcely had'. Should be 'when' or 'before'. | Yes |
| started pushing each other | Correct simple past tense verb 'started'. Correct use of 'each other'. | No |
| to enter the train | Correct infinitive phrase. | No |
Revision Table: Correlative Conjunctions
| Correlative Conjunction Pair | Usage Example |
|---|---|
| Scarcely/Hardly... when/before | Scarcely had I finished eating when the doorbell rang. |
| No sooner... than | No sooner had he arrived than it started raining. |
| Either... or | You can either stay or leave. |
| Neither... nor | He is neither rich nor famous. |
| Both... and | She is both intelligent and beautiful. |
| Not only... but also | He is not only a doctor but also a writer. |
Additional Information: Identifying Sentence Errors
Identifying sentence errors often involves checking for:
- Subject-Verb Agreement: The verb must agree in number with its subject.
- Tense Consistency: Ensure verb tenses are consistent unless a change in time is indicated.
- Pronoun Agreement: Pronouns must agree in number and gender with their antecedents.
- Correct Use of Conjunctions: Using the correct conjunctions, especially correlative pairs.
- Parallel Structure: Ensure items in a list or paired elements have the same grammatical form.
- Modifier Placement: Modifiers should be placed close to the words they modify.
- Correct Idioms and Phrases: Using standard English idioms and fixed phrases.
In this specific question, the error is related to the correct usage of a correlative conjunction pair ("Scarcely had" and "when/before").
Similar Questions
Identify the segment in the sentence which contains a grammatical error.
I didn’t knew you had gone to Goa for a vacation.
The following sentence has been divided into parts. One of them contains an error. Select the part that contains the error from the given options.
No sooner did Priya / get her report card / when she started jumping / with joy.
The following sentence has been divided into parts. One of them contains an error. Select the part that contains the error from the given options.
Lalitha will go / to sister’s house / in Mumbai / this summer.
The following sentence has been split into four segments. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error.
You should/ have respond / to my query / sooner.
The following sentence has been split into four segments. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error.
Athens was / a most luminous / of all city-states / of ancient Greece.
The following sentence has been divided into parts. One of them contains an error. Select the part that contains the error from the given options.
Four of earliest civilisations / of the world / were located / on the banks of or near large rivers.
The following sentence has been divided into parts. One of them contains an error. Select the part that contains the error from the given options.
The recruiters / were pleased / to John’s / domain knowledge and personality.
The following sentence has been divided into parts. One of them may contain an error. Select the part that contains the error from the given options. If you don’t find any error, mark ‘No error’ as your answer.
It has been / raining intermittently / since two days.
The following sentence has been split into four segments. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error.
The manager said, "Could you please / confirm me whether you / have received all the items / that you had ordered?"
Parts of the following sentence are given as options. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error.
A large number of student have participated in this music video.
Important Questions from Error Spotting
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
It is identification with the audience(a)that makes one come home from the play so much more(b)satisfied than one ever is after merely passive enjoyment of the show.(c) No error.(d)
The following question has a sentence with four parts labelled (a), (b), (c), and (d). Read each sentence to find out whether there is an error in any part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
CV Raman was one of the greatest sons of India (a) who has earned everlasting fame (b) for scientific researches. (c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
This box(a)is heavy than(b) the other one.(c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
Thewriter does not have the freedom (a) to choose his own themes, (b) society thrusts them on him (c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is an error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
No one knows (a) why he did it, (b) or who was behind his doing it.(c) No error. (d)
