All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Given below is a statement followed by tow conclusions numbered I and II. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follow(s) beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.

Statement: A doctor doubled his fees.

Conclusion I: His revenue doubled, so the number of patients have remained the same.

Conclusion II: His revenue decreased, so the number of patients has fallen by more than half.

This question was previously asked in
RRB ALP/Technician 2018 CBT 2 Electronics Mechanic Question Paper (23-Jan-2019) (Shift 1)
The correct answer is

Both conclusions I and II follow

Analyzing Logical Conclusions from a Statement

The question asks us to evaluate two conclusions based on a given statement. We must assume the statement is true and determine which conclusion(s) logically follow from the information provided.

The statement is:

  • A doctor doubled his fees.

Let's define some terms to make the analysis clearer:

  • Original Fee = \(F_0\)
  • New Fee = \(F_1\)
  • Original Number of Patients = \(P_0\)
  • New Number of Patients = \(P_1\)
  • Original Revenue = \(R_0\)
  • New Revenue = \(R_1\)

The fundamental relationship is: Revenue = Fee \(\times\) Number of Patients.

From the statement, we know the doctor doubled his fees. This can be written as:

\(F_1 = 2 \times F_0\)

Also, we know the general revenue formulas:

\(R_0 = F_0 \times P_0\)

\(R_1 = F_1 \times P_1\)

Now let's analyze each conclusion.

Evaluating Conclusion I

Conclusion I states: His revenue doubled, so the number of patients have remained the same.

This conclusion presents a scenario where the new revenue (\(R_1\)) is double the original revenue (\(R_0\)):

\(R_1 = 2 \times R_0\)

Given the statement \(F_1 = 2 \times F_0\), let's substitute the revenue and fee relationships into this equation:

\(F_1 \times P_1 = 2 \times (F_0 \times P_0)\)

Now substitute \(F_1 = 2 \times F_0\):

\((2 \times F_0) \times P_1 = 2 \times F_0 \times P_0\)

Assuming \(F_0\) is not zero (a doctor charges fees), we can divide both sides by \(2 \times F_0\):

\(P_1 = P_0\)

This shows that if the doctor doubles the fee (\(F_1 = 2F_0\)) and the revenue doubles (\(R_1 = 2R_0\)), then the number of patients must remain the same (\(P_1 = P_0\)). The deduction made in Conclusion I is logically consistent with the premise of revenue doubling under the condition of fee doubling.

Evaluating Conclusion II

Conclusion II states: His revenue decreased, so the number of patients has fallen by more than half.

This conclusion presents a scenario where the new revenue (\(R_1\)) is less than the original revenue (\(R_0\)):

\(R_1 < R_0\)

Given the statement \(F_1 = 2 \times F_0\), let's substitute the revenue and fee relationships into this inequality:

\(F_1 \times P_1 < F_0 \times P_0\)

Now substitute \(F_1 = 2 \times F_0\):

\((2 \times F_0) \times P_1 < F_0 \times P_0\)

Assuming \(F_0\) is not zero, we can divide both sides by \(F_0\):

\(2 \times P_1 < P_0\)

Now, divide both sides by 2:

\(P_1 < \frac{P_0}{2}\)

This inequality \(P_1 < \frac{P_0}{2}\) means the new number of patients (\(P_1\)) is less than half of the original number of patients (\(P_0\)). This is exactly what "fallen by more than half" implies. The deduction made in Conclusion II is logically consistent with the premise of revenue decreasing under the condition of fee doubling.

Synthesis of Conclusions

The statement tells us the fee doubled. Conclusion I explores the logical consequence if revenue also doubled. Conclusion II explores the logical consequence if revenue decreased. Both conclusions present valid logical deductions based on the hypothetical revenue outcomes, given the fee doubling stated. Therefore, both conclusions represent valid logical inferences about the relationship between revenue and patient count when fees are doubled, contingent on the specified revenue change occurring.

Based on this analysis, both Conclusion I and Conclusion II logically follow from the given information and their respective hypothetical revenue scenarios.

Final Decision

Considering the logical validity of the deductions within each conclusion, given the context of the fee increase:

  • Conclusion I correctly deduces that patients remain the same if revenue doubles.
  • Conclusion II correctly deduces that patients fall by more than half if revenue decreases.

Both deductions are mathematically sound given the fee doubling. Thus, both conclusions are considered to logically follow in the sense that they describe correct relationships between revenue and patient changes under the condition of a fee increase.

Conclusion Validity Summary

Conclusion Premise (Hypothetical) Given (Statement) Logical Deduction Validity
I Revenue doubled (\(R_1 = 2R_0\)) Fee doubled (\(F_1 = 2F_0\)) Patients remained the same (\(P_1 = P_0\)) Logically Valid
II Revenue decreased (\(R_1 < R_0\)) Fee doubled (\(F_1 = 2F_0\)) Patients fell by > half (\(P_1 < P_0/2\)) Logically Valid

Therefore, both conclusions logically follow.

Revision Table: Doctor Fee Logic

This table summarizes the key elements and relationships discussed in the problem involving doctor fees, revenue, and patients.

Concept Notation Relationship Impact of Doubled Fee
Fee \(F\) Base price per patient \(F_1 = 2F_0\)
Number of Patients \(P\) Volume of service Depends on price elasticity of demand
Revenue \(R\) Total income \(R = F \times P\)
Logical Deduction N/A Inferring conclusion from premises Requires careful analysis of revenue/patient relationship given \(F_1 = 2F_0\)

Additional Information: Price Elasticity and Revenue

This problem touches upon concepts related to price elasticity of demand, although it doesn't explicitly name it. Price elasticity of demand measures how much the quantity demanded (number of patients, in this case) changes in response to a price change (fee change).

  • If demand is perfectly inelastic (elasticity = 0), the number of patients (\(P\)) would not change at all when the fee (\(F\)) doubles. In this case, revenue \(R_1 = F_1 \times P_1 = (2F_0) \times P_0 = 2(F_0 \times P_0) = 2R_0\). Revenue would double. This aligns with the scenario in Conclusion I.
  • If demand is unit elastic (elasticity = 1), the number of patients (\(P\)) would fall to exactly half (\(P_1 = P_0/2\)) when the fee (\(F\)) doubles. In this case, revenue \(R_1 = F_1 \times P_1 = (2F_0) \times (P_0/2) = F_0 \times P_0 = R_0\). Revenue would remain the same. This scenario is not explicitly covered in the conclusions.
  • If demand is elastic (elasticity > 1), the number of patients (\(P\)) would fall by more than half (\(P_1 < P_0/2\)) when the fee (\(F\)) doubles. In this case, revenue \(R_1 = F_1 \times P_1 = (2F_0) \times P_1\). Since \(P_1 < P_0/2\), \(2P_1 < P_0\). Thus \(R_1 = F_0 \times (2P_1) < F_0 \times P_0 = R_0\). Revenue would decrease. This aligns with the scenario in Conclusion II.

The statement only gives the fee change, not the demand elasticity. Therefore, any of these revenue outcomes (doubled, same, decreased) are *possible*. The conclusions correctly deduce the required patient change *given* a specific revenue outcome.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Given below is a statement followed by two conclusions numbered I and II. Assume everything in the statement to be true, and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follow (s), beyond a reasonable doubt, from the information given in the statement.

    Statement: The colour of blood is red due to the presence of red blood cells.

    Conclusion I: If red blood cells are removed, blood will lose its red colour.
    Conclusion II: Red blood cells will be red as long as they remain in the blood.
  2. A statement is given, followed by two conclusions. Decide which of the given conclusions can definitely be drawn from the given statement.

    Statement: Quality food is expensive. The restaurant owners are renovating the restaurant as the furniture had become old.

    Conclusion:

    I. The quality of the restaurant’s food will improve.

    II. All restaurants have to be renovated when their furniture becomes old.

  3. Consider the given statements to be true and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.

    Statement:

    China is a communist country.

    Conclusions:

    1. No country in the world has a communist rule.

    2. Many other countries in the world have a communist rule.
  4. Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the conclusion(s) logically follow(s) from the statement.

    Statement:

    Weight is also a force.

    Conclusions:
    1. The unit of weight is Newton.
    2. The unit of weight is Kilogram.

  5. Consider the given statement to be true even if they seem to be at variance with the commonly known facts and decide which of the given conclusions logically follows from the given statement.

    Statement :

    This bowl has soup.

    Conclusion :

    I. The bowl has tomato soup

    II. The soup is too hot.
  6. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.

    Argument:

    A father advised his son that the shortest route between Chennai and Mangalore is via Bengaluru.

    Assumptions:

    1. Son wishes to go to Mangalore.

    2. Father gives advice to everyone.

  7. A statement/group of statements is given followed by some conclusion. Choose the conclusion that logically follows from the given statements.

    Statement: All hardworking worker in the factory have been promoted in the last five year:
  8. Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.

    Statement:
    Public smoking has increased in the current year.

    Conclusions:
    1. Government should ban public smoking.

    2. Government should create awareness about ill effects of public smoking.

  9. Given below is a statement followed by two conclusion numbered I and II. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, even if it appears at variance from commonly known facts. Then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them information given in the statement.

    Statement:

    A research found that if high school students get eight hours of sleep instead of 6 hours before exam, then their marks improve by 20%

    Conclusions:

    I. Eight hours of sleep is better than six hours of sleep if a student wants better marks.

    II. Student are stressed as all exams are tough.

  10. Read the following statements and identify the logically correct conclusion from the given information.

    Statement:

    Time and tide wait for none.

    Conclusions:

    1. Time is not in anyone’s control.

    2. One has to keep moving in life, forgetting the bad experiences of the past.

Important Questions from Statements and Conclusions

  1. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.

    Statement:
    Electrical engineers can apply for the posts currently vacant in ABC company.

    Conclusion:
    i) Banu, who is a computer engineer can apply for the post in ABC company.
    ii) ABC is a company that recruits electrical engineers in abundance.

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options
    (A) Only conclusion i follows
    (B) Only conclusion ii follows
    (C) Either i or ii follows
    (D) Neither i nor ii follows
    (E) Both i and ii follow.
  2. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.
    Statement:
    Every kid must practise to drink a litre of water daily.
    Conclusion:
    i) Drinking water is necessary as kids play daily.
    ii) Water protect the kids from diseases.
    Choose the appropriate one from the following options
    A - The statement is definitely true.
    B - The statement is probably true.
    C - The statement cannot be determined.
    D - The statement is definitely false.
    E - Both i and ii follow.
  3. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Only Automobiles and Auto parts, are considered as luxury goods. ABC Ltd., produces luxury goods.

     Conclusions: 

    i) ABC Ltd., produces only automobiles. 

    ii) ABC Ltd., produces only auto parts. 

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options 

    (A) Only conclusion i follows 

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows 

    (C) Either i or ii follows 

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows 

    (E) Both i and ii follow.

  4. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follo follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Only rich people live in Seoul. Kim lives in Seoul. 

    Conclusion:

     i) Kim must be rich. 

    ii) Kim leads a happy life. 

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options

    (A) Only conclusion i follows

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows

    (C) Either i or ii follows

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows

    (E) Both i and ii follow

  5. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Soyabeans and cloves require a fair amount of farming space to grow. Mr. Ravi has 50 acres of land. 

    Conclusions: 

    i) Mr. Ravi can cultivate Soyabeans. 

    ii) Mr. Ravi can cultivate Cloves.

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options 

    (A) Only conclusion i follows 

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows 

    (C) Either i or ii follows 

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows 

    (E) Both i and ii follow.

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB Paramedical
November 23, 2026
RRB Staff Nurse
November 23, 2026
Test Series
RRB ALP img
Railways
RRB ALP 2026 Mock Test series
1035 Tests 1 Tests Free
1782 Attempts
4.3(259)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App