Which one of the following statements about the Cripps Mission is not correct ?
It proposed ‘that the Constitution of India was to be framed by an elected Constituent Assembly of the Indian people.
Understanding the Cripps Mission Proposals
The Cripps Mission was sent to India by the British Government in March 1942. This mission, led by Stafford Cripps, aimed to secure India's cooperation and support in World War II. It proposed several measures regarding India's future constitutional status after the war. We need to evaluate which of the given statements about these proposals is not accurate.
Analyzing Each Statement about the Cripps Mission
Let's examine each statement based on the historical facts of the Cripps Mission:
-
Statement 1: It was sent to India by the British Government in March 1942.
This statement is historically correct. The Cripps Mission arrived in India in March 1942, during World War II, to discuss constitutional reforms and seek Indian political parties' support for the war effort.
-
Statement 2: It proposed ‘that the Constitution of India was to be framed by an elected Constituent Assembly of the Indian people.
This statement contains a subtle inaccuracy. While the Cripps Mission *did* propose the formation of a Constituent Assembly to frame the future constitution, the composition was not intended to be solely based on direct election by 'the Indian people' in the broadest sense. The proposal suggested that the Constituent Assembly would be composed of members elected by the provincial legislative assemblies (representing British Indian provinces through indirect election) and representatives nominated by the rulers of the princely states. Therefore, calling it an assembly 'elected... of the Indian people' without qualification regarding the representation of princely states and the indirect election process for British Indian representatives makes this statement not entirely correct or precise in describing the *specific* proposed composition.
-
Statement 3: Any province which was not prepared to accept the Constitution would be free to retain its constitutional provisions existing at that time.
This statement is correct. A key feature of the Cripps proposals was the provision for any province (or princely state) to opt-out of the proposed Indian Union and either retain its existing constitutional position or negotiate a separate status. This 'opt-out clause' was a point of contention.
-
Statement 4: The British Government could enter into a separate constitutional arrangement with any of the acceding provinces.
This statement is also correct and directly related to the 'opt-out' clause mentioned in Statement 3. If a province chose not to join the main union, the Cripps proposal implicitly allowed for separate negotiations and arrangements between such non-acceding entities and the British Government.
Identifying the Incorrect Statement
Based on the analysis, Statements 1, 3, and 4 accurately reflect proposals or aspects of the Cripps Mission. Statement 2, while mentioning the idea of a Constituent Assembly, is not entirely accurate regarding its proposed composition, which involved indirect election and nomination, not a direct election by all 'the Indian people'.
Therefore, the statement that is NOT correct about the Cripps Mission is Statement 2.
Revision Table: Key Aspects of Cripps Mission
| Aspect | Details of Cripps Proposals (1942) |
|---|---|
| Timing | March 1942 (during World War II) |
| Purpose | Gain Indian support for the war; propose constitutional reforms after the war. |
| Future Status | Dominion Status for India after the war. |
| Constitution Making Body | A Constituent Assembly to be formed after the war. |
| Assembly Composition | Elected members from British Indian provinces (elected by provincial assemblies) + Nominated members from Princely States. |
| Provincial Option | Provinces/States could opt-out of the proposed Union and retain existing status or negotiate separately. |
| Interim Arrangements | More Indian representation in the Viceroy's Executive Council (not full transfer of power). |
Additional Information: Context and Failure of Cripps Mission
The Cripps Mission ultimately failed because its proposals did not satisfy the major Indian political parties. The Indian National Congress demanded immediate transfer of power and rejected the idea of Dominion status and the 'opt-out' clause, which they saw as encouraging partition. The Muslim League welcomed the 'opt-out' clause as it hinted at the possibility of Pakistan but rejected the proposals because they did not explicitly guarantee the creation of Pakistan. Other groups also had reservations. The failure of the Cripps Mission highlighted the significant gap between British intentions and Indian aspirations during this critical period.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following is not correct about the Indian Independence Act, 1947 ?
Which one of the following is not a change brought about by the Indian Independence Act of 1947?
Who among the following socialist activists persuaded Gandhijinot torestrict the salt march protest to men alone?
With whom did Subhas Chandra Bose form an alliance to destroy the Holwell Monument in Calcutta during 1939-40?
Who among the following moved the motion of Secret Sitting Session of the Assembly ( 1942)?
Subhas Chandra Bose started the ‘Azad Hind Radio’ in which of the following countries?
Which political party formally accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan on 6 th June, 1946, which had rejected the demand for a sovereign Pakistan?
Consider the following statements :
After forming the Indian National Army, Subhas Chandra Bose
1. Recruited a large number of soldiers from the Indian Prisoners of War in Japanese camp
2. Introduced a women’s detachment named after the Rani of Jhansi
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
The Sylhet Referendum was held in?
Important Questions from Freedom to Partition (1939-1947)
The princely states that were unwilling to join the Indian Union until July 1947 included:
a. Baroda
b. Travancore
c. Bikaner
d. Bhopal
The first major nation wide Satyagraha launched by Mahatma Gandhi was against:
Who was the Chairman of the Partition Council?
With reference to 8th August, 1942 in Indian history, which one of the following statements is correct?
- Arrange the following significant events in the history of India's independence struggle in chronological order, from earliest to latest:
1. Cripps Mission
2. Wavell Plan
3. Quit India Movement
4. Cabinet Mission
5. August Offer
6. Royal Indian Navy Mutiny
Which of the following sequences is correct?
