Which one of the following is not correct about the Indian Independence Act, 1947 ?
Act of 1947 laid down the basic framework of the Indian Constitution.
Understanding the Indian Independence Act 1947
The question asks us to identify the statement that is not correct regarding the Indian Independence Act, 1947. Let's examine each statement to determine its accuracy in relation to this significant historical Act.
Analyzing the Provisions of the Indian Independence Act
We will go through each provided option and assess its correctness concerning the Indian Independence Act, 1947.
-
Statement 1: The Bill for the Indian Independence Act was introduced in Parliament on July 4 and received the Royal Assent on July 18, 1947.
This statement is historically accurate. The Indian Independence Bill was indeed introduced in the British Parliament on July 4, 1947, and it received the Royal Assent on July 18, 1947, thereby becoming the Indian Independence Act, 1947. This timeline is a well-documented fact about the passage of the Act.
-
Statement 2: Act of 1947 laid down the basic framework of the Indian Constitution.
This statement is incorrect. The Indian Independence Act, 1947, primarily dealt with granting independence to India and Pakistan, defining their territories, providing for the partition, ending British paramountcy, and making transitional provisions for governance. The basic framework of the Indian Constitution was not laid down by this Act. Instead, the Constitution of India was drafted by the Constituent Assembly of India over a period of several years, drawing upon various sources, including aspects of the Government of India Act, 1935, debates, and discussions within the Assembly. The Constituent Assembly was empowered by the 1947 Act, but the Act itself did not provide the constitutional framework.
-
Statement 3: The Act provided for the establishment of two independent Dominions to be known as India and Pakistan.
This statement is correct. One of the most fundamental provisions of the Indian Independence Act, 1947, was the partition of British India and the creation of two separate, independent Dominions: India and Pakistan, from August 15, 1947. This provision was central to the Act's purpose.
-
Statement 4: The Act empowered the Constituent Assembly of each Dominion to have unlimited power to frame and adopt any constitution.
This statement is correct. The Indian Independence Act, 1947, declared that the Constituent Assembly of each Dominion (India and Pakistan) would have full legislative sovereignty. This meant they could frame and adopt any constitution they wished, and the British Parliament would have no power to amend or repeal any law made by them. The power of the British Crown to disallow legislation or reserve laws for the Crown's pleasure was abolished.
Identifying the Incorrect Statement
Based on our analysis:
- Statement 1 is correct.
- Statement 2 is incorrect.
- Statement 3 is correct.
- Statement 4 is correct.
The question asks for the statement that is not correct about the Indian Independence Act, 1947. Therefore, the incorrect statement is Option 2.
| Statement | Correctness regarding Act | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Bill introduced July 4, Royal Assent July 18, 1947 | Correct | Historical fact about the Act's passage |
| Laid down basic framework of Indian Constitution | Incorrect | Constitution framework was by Constituent Assembly, not the Act |
| Provided for two independent Dominions (India & Pakistan) | Correct | Key provision of the Act (Partition) |
| Empowered Constituent Assembly with unlimited power | Correct | Act granted full sovereignty to Constituent Assemblies |
Revision Table: Key Points of Indian Independence Act, 1947
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| End of British Rule | Ended British rule in India from August 15, 1947. |
| Partition of India | Created two independent Dominions: India and Pakistan. |
| Transfer of Power | Provided for the transfer of power to the Constituent Assemblies of the new Dominions. |
| Sovereignty of Assemblies | Conferred full legislative power on the Constituent Assemblies, abolishing British Parliament's authority over laws made by them. |
| End of Paramountcy | Ended British paramountcy over the Indian princely states, giving them freedom to join either Dominion or remain independent (though practically, they joined India or Pakistan). |
| Governor General | Provided for a Governor-General for each Dominion, appointed by the King, who was to act on the advice of the Dominion cabinet. |
Additional Information: Making of the Indian Constitution
The making of the Indian Constitution was a separate process from the Indian Independence Act, 1947. The Constituent Assembly of India, formed in 1946, was responsible for drafting the Constitution. This process involved extensive debates, discussions, and the formation of various committees. Key aspects included:
- Adoption of Objectives Resolution (laying down the guiding principles).
- Work of the Drafting Committee, chaired by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar.
- Borrowing features from various constitutions around the world.
- In-depth discussions on fundamental rights, directive principles, governmental structure, etc.
The Constitution was finally adopted by the Constituent Assembly on November 26, 1949, and came into effect on January 26, 1950. While the Indian Independence Act, 1947, enabled the Constituent Assembly to function as a fully sovereign body, it did not provide the content or framework of the Constitution itself.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following statements about the Cripps Mission is not correct ?
Which one of the following is not a change brought about by the Indian Independence Act of 1947?
Who among the following socialist activists persuaded Gandhijinot torestrict the salt march protest to men alone?
With whom did Subhas Chandra Bose form an alliance to destroy the Holwell Monument in Calcutta during 1939-40?
Who among the following moved the motion of Secret Sitting Session of the Assembly ( 1942)?
Subhas Chandra Bose started the ‘Azad Hind Radio’ in which of the following countries?
Which political party formally accepted the Cabinet Mission Plan on 6 th June, 1946, which had rejected the demand for a sovereign Pakistan?
Consider the following statements :
After forming the Indian National Army, Subhas Chandra Bose
1. Recruited a large number of soldiers from the Indian Prisoners of War in Japanese camp
2. Introduced a women’s detachment named after the Rani of Jhansi
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
The Sylhet Referendum was held in?
Important Questions from Freedom to Partition (1939-1947)
The princely states that were unwilling to join the Indian Union until July 1947 included:
a. Baroda
b. Travancore
c. Bikaner
d. Bhopal
The first major nation wide Satyagraha launched by Mahatma Gandhi was against:
Who was the Chairman of the Partition Council?
With reference to 8th August, 1942 in Indian history, which one of the following statements is correct?
- Arrange the following significant events in the history of India's independence struggle in chronological order, from earliest to latest:
1. Cripps Mission
2. Wavell Plan
3. Quit India Movement
4. Cabinet Mission
5. August Offer
6. Royal Indian Navy Mutiny
Which of the following sequences is correct?
