The Economic historian, who has used the data collected by Buchanan-Hamilton to support the thesis of deindustrialization in the 19 th century India, is ________.
Amiya Kumar Bagchi
Economic Historians and Deindustrialization in 19th Century India
The question asks to identify the economic historian who extensively used the data collected by Francis Buchanan-Hamilton to support the theory of deindustrialization in India during the 19th century. Deindustrialization refers to the decline of artisanal and traditional industries in a region, often associated with colonial rule and the influx of manufactured goods from the colonizing power.
Understanding Buchanan-Hamilton's Data
Francis Buchanan-Hamilton was a Scottish physician, zoologist, and botanist who conducted extensive surveys in British India in the early 19th century, particularly in areas like Bengal and Bihar. His surveys collected detailed information on various aspects of society and economy, including agriculture, trade, and manufacturing. This data provides valuable insights into the economic conditions of India before and during the early stages of British colonial rule.
The Deindustrialization Debate
The theory of deindustrialization in 19th-century India is a significant topic of debate among economic historians. Some scholars argue that British colonial policies led to the ruin of traditional Indian industries, while others contend that the decline was not uniform, or that new industries emerged, or that the scale of decline has been exaggerated. Proponents of the deindustrialization thesis often point to the decline of textile production, shipbuilding, and other crafts.
Amiya Kumar Bagchi's Contribution
Amiya Kumar Bagchi is a prominent Indian economic historian known for his work on the economic history of India, particularly under British rule. Bagchi extensively researched the impact of colonial policies on Indian industries. He is specifically recognized for his detailed use of primary sources, including the survey data collected by Buchanan-Hamilton, to argue forcefully for the thesis of deindustrialization. His analysis often focused on quantifying the decline in employment and output in various sectors based on such historical data.
Analyzing the Options
- Tirthankar Roy: Tirthankar Roy is a noted economic historian who has written extensively on Indian economic history, including industries. However, his work often takes a different perspective on the deindustrialization debate compared to Bagchi, sometimes emphasizing adaptation and resilience or questioning the extent of decline. While he uses various historical sources, he is not primarily known for using Buchanan-Hamilton's data to *support* the deindustrialization thesis in the same way Bagchi is.
- Amiya Kumar Bagchi: As discussed above, Amiya Kumar Bagchi is the historian most strongly associated with using Buchanan-Hamilton's detailed survey data as a key source to build the argument for severe deindustrialization in 19th-century India. His seminal works on the subject draw heavily on this type of evidence to demonstrate the scale of industrial decline.
- Sabyasachi Bhattacharya: Sabyasachi Bhattacharya is a distinguished historian who has worked on various aspects of Indian history, including economic and social history. While he is a prominent figure in the field, he is not primarily known for basing his core argument for deindustrialization specifically on Buchanan-Hamilton's data.
- Irfan Habib: Irfan Habib is a renowned historian, particularly known for his work on the Mughal period and the agrarian history of India. While he has written on colonial economic history and is a critic of colonial rule, his primary research focus and the specific use of Buchanan-Hamilton's data to support the deindustrialization thesis are not as central as they are for Amiya Kumar Bagchi.
Based on the prominent use of Buchanan-Hamilton's surveys to support the deindustrialization thesis, Amiya Kumar Bagchi is the economic historian who fits the description.
| Historian | Primary Association with Deindustrialization Debate & Buchanan-Hamilton Data |
|---|---|
| Tirthankar Roy | Contributes to the debate, often with differing perspectives; not primarily known for using Buchanan-Hamilton data to strongly support classic deindustrialization thesis. |
| Amiya Kumar Bagchi | Key proponent of deindustrialization thesis; widely known for using Buchanan-Hamilton's surveys to provide empirical evidence for industrial decline. |
| Sabyasachi Bhattacharya | Significant historian of India; while contributing to economic history, not primarily focused on using Buchanan-Hamilton data for the deindustrialization argument. |
| Irfan Habib | Renowned for Mughal/agrarian history; contributes to colonial critiques, but specific use of Buchanan-Hamilton for deindustrialization is not his primary focus. |
Conclusion
Amiya Kumar Bagchi stands out among the options as the economic historian who notably utilized the detailed data collected by Francis Buchanan-Hamilton in the early 19th century to empirically argue in favor of the deindustrialization thesis, documenting the decline of traditional industries under colonial rule.
Revision Table: Economic Historians and Indian Deindustrialization
Review the key figures and their positions/methods regarding the deindustrialization debate in 19th-century India.
- Deindustrialization Thesis: Argument that Indian traditional industries declined under British rule.
- Buchanan-Hamilton Surveys: Early 19th-century data source used by historians.
- Amiya Kumar Bagchi: Used Buchanan-Hamilton data to support deindustrialization.
- Tirthankar Roy: Engaged in the debate, sometimes presenting alternative views.
Additional Information: Deindustrialization in Colonial India
The deindustrialization debate is complex and involves various factors:
- Colonial Policy: Tariffs, trade regulations, and infrastructure development (like railways) are debated for their impact on Indian industries.
- Competition: Influx of cheaper, mass-produced goods from Britain.
- Loss of Royal Patronage: Decline of princely states which supported artisans.
- Data Limitations: Historians grapple with the availability and reliability of historical data for this period.
Understanding this debate is crucial for grasping the economic impact of British rule on India.
Similar Questions
Which Greek philosopher coined the term "Geography" in the 3 rd century B.C.E.?
Tea growing in India in the 19 th century was made possible by ________.
Who among the following geographers is related to ‘primate city’ concept?
Which one of the following political parties was launched by Irom Sharmila in Manipur?
Consider the following statement:
“If you feel you are trapped in a black hole, don’t give up. There is a way out.
”Who among the following made the above statement?
Paul Allen, who died in October 2018, was the co-founder of ________.
Chronologically arrange the following Indian-origin astronauts on the basis of their flying into space starting with the first :
1. Sunita Williams
2. Rakesh Sharma
3. Sirisha Bandla
4. Kalpana Chawla
Select the correct answer using the code given below :
Consider the following statement: “A sound body means one which bends itself to the spirit and is always a ready instrument at its service”. The above statement is attributed to
Match List - I with List - II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists:
List - I
(Political idea)List - II
(Thinker)A.
Human beings, unlike all other objects, possess dignity
1.
Aung San Suu Kyi
B.
It is Swaraj when we learn to rule ourselves
2.
Subhas Chandra Bose
C.
Freedom implies not only emancipation from political bondage but also equal distribution of wealth
3.
Immanuel Kant
D.
For me real freedom is freedom from fear
4.
Mahatma Gandhi
Symbol of element was introduced by ________.
Important Questions from Famous People
Who was the world’s first woman amputee to climb Mount Vinson?
Who is the fastest Asian to traverse the globe riding a bicycle?
What is the name of India’s first test tube baby?
The immortal poet Kalidasa belonged to the town of _______
The Indian who acted as the President of General Assembly of UNO is
