He is (P)/ a mason who (Q)/ built my house. (R)/ No error (S)
Q
Sentence Structure Analysis
This question requires identifying a grammatical error within a given sentence, which is divided into four parts: P, Q, R, and S (No error). The sentence is: "He is (P)/ a mason who (Q)/ built my house. (R)/ No error (S)". We need to examine each part to find the mistake.
- Part (P): "He is" - This is a standard subject-verb combination and appears correct.
- Part (Q): "a mason who" - This part introduces the profession and uses a relative pronoun. The potential error might be with the article 'a' or the pronoun 'who'.
- Part (R): "built my house." - This uses the simple past tense verb 'built', indicating a completed action. This verb tense seems appropriate in this context.
- Part (S): "No error" - This is the choice if all other parts are grammatically sound.
Error Identification in Part Q
The analysis suggests that Part (Q) contains the error. The specific issue is the use of the indefinite article 'a' before 'mason'. The sentence structure is "He is a mason who built my house." The relative clause "who built my house" serves to identify a specific mason – the one who performed the action of building the speaker's house. When a relative clause specifies or identifies a particular noun, the definite article 'the' is generally preferred over the indefinite article 'a'.
Using 'a mason' implies he is one of possibly many masons, but the clause "who built my house" points to a specific one. This creates an awkward or slightly incorrect construction. A more natural and grammatically standard phrasing would use 'the' to indicate this specific identification.
For example:
- The sentence "He is the mason who built my house" clearly identifies him as the specific mason associated with building the house.
- The sentence "He, a mason, built my house" is also correct, using "a mason" as an appositive phrase providing extra information.
Therefore, the phrase "a mason who" in Part (Q) is problematic because the context requires a definite article.
Explanation of Article Usage
Articles ('a', 'an', 'the') are crucial for specifying nouns. 'A' and 'an' are indefinite articles used for general or non-specific mentions, while 'the' is the definite article used for specific, unique, or previously mentioned nouns.
In this sentence, the clause "who built my house" makes the identity of the mason specific. It answers the question, "Which mason?". Because the clause specifies *which* mason we are talking about (the one who built *my* house), the definite article 'the' is the standard choice.
Using 'a' here is less precise and sounds unnatural in standard English when such specific identification is intended.
Conclusion on Sentence Correctness
The grammatical error resides in the use of the indefinite article 'a' in Part (Q) where the definite article 'the' would be appropriate for specificity.
Similar Questions
- In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
The angry man walked hurriedly (P)/into the crowded room (Q)/and shouted loud at the guest. (R)/ No error (S) - In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
What you will think (P)/ if school boys make (Q)/ fun of you? (R)/ No error (S) In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
The Minister’s speech (P)/ has been reported (Q)/ to the newspaper. (R)/ No error (S)
- In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
Such an act of cruelty (P)/ had never be (Q)/ committed before. (R)/ No error (S) - In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
No one but (P)/ he knew who was set(Q)/ the question paper. (R)/ No error (S) - In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
A box (P)/of apples (Q)/ are in the car. (R)/ No error (S) - In the following question, each sentence has four parts marked P, Q, R and S. Choose the part of the sentence with the error and mark as your answer. If there is no error, mark 'No error (S)' as your answer.
The house (P)/ was built (Q)/very attractively. (R)/ No error (S) Read each of the following sentences to find out whether there is an error in any part. No sentence has more than one error. If you feel there is no error in a sentence, signify a ‘No error’ response.
Looking forward (P)/ to meet (Q)/ you soon. (R)/ No error (S)
Identify the segment in the sentence that contains a grammatical error.
Let me know / if you need / a further information / about the programme/ that is going to be held
Identify the segment in the sentence that contains a grammatical error.
By the linking of the rivers / it is proposed to provide / a continuous supplies of water / to those parts of India / where there is a shortage.
Important Questions from Error Spotting
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
It is identification with the audience(a)that makes one come home from the play so much more(b)satisfied than one ever is after merely passive enjoyment of the show.(c) No error.(d)
The following question has a sentence with four parts labelled (a), (b), (c), and (d). Read each sentence to find out whether there is an error in any part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
CV Raman was one of the greatest sons of India (a) who has earned everlasting fame (b) for scientific researches. (c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
This box(a)is heavy than(b) the other one.(c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is any error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
Thewriter does not have the freedom (a) to choose his own themes, (b) society thrusts them on him (c) No error. (d)
The following question has a sentence with three underlined parts labelled (a), (b) and (c). Read each sentence to find out whether there is an error in any underlined part and indicate your response against the corresponding letter i.e., (a) or (b) or (c). If you find no error, your response should be indicated as (d).
No one knows (a) why he did it, (b) or who was behind his doing it.(c) No error. (d)
