Directions: The following two (2) items consist of two statements, Statement I and Statement II. Examine these two statements carefully and select the correct answer using the code given below. Statement I: The Poona Pact provided for 151 reserved seats for the scheduled castes to be elected by a joint, not separate, electorate. Statement II: Dr. B. R. Ambedkar withdrew from active politics for almost a decade when the Communal Award was revoked.
Statement I is true but Statement II is false
Analyzing Statements on Poona Pact and Communal Award
The question asks us to evaluate two statements related to significant historical events in India, specifically concerning the rights and representation of Scheduled Castes during the pre-independence period.
Analyzing Statement I: Poona Pact Reserved Seats
Statement I claims: The Poona Pact provided for 151 reserved seats for the scheduled castes to be elected by a joint, not separate, electorate.
Let's break down this statement:
- Poona Pact: This agreement was signed in 1932 between Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, emerging from Gandhi's fast unto death against the Communal Award.
- Reserved Seats: The pact did indeed provide for reserving seats for Scheduled Castes in legislative bodies. This was a key outcome, replacing the separate electorates proposed by the Communal Award.
- Number of Seats (151): The Poona Pact significantly increased the number of reserved seats compared to the Communal Award. While the exact number can vary slightly based on the source and provinces included (often cited around 147 to 151 seats in provincial legislatures), the principle of a substantially increased number of reserved seats was central to the pact. The figure 151 is within the range commonly associated with the provincial legislatures.
- Joint Electorate: Crucially, the Poona Pact mandated a joint electorate. This meant that all voters, including Scheduled Castes and others, would vote together for candidates from reserved seats, rather than Scheduled Castes voting separately for their representatives. This directly contradicted the 'separate electorate' system proposed by the Communal Award.
Based on historical facts, the Poona Pact did establish reserved seats for Scheduled Castes within a joint electorate. The number 151 is representative of the increased number of seats in provincial legislatures. Therefore, Statement I is true.
Analyzing Statement II: Dr. Ambedkar's Political Activity
Statement II claims: Dr. B. R. Ambedkar withdrew from active politics for almost a decade when the Communal Award was revoked.
Let's examine this claim:
- Communal Award and its Revocation: The Communal Award was announced in August 1932 and was superseded by the Poona Pact in September 1932. So, the "revocation" refers to its replacement by the Poona Pact's provisions for Scheduled Castes.
- Dr. B. R. Ambedkar's Role: Dr. Ambedkar was a central figure in the negotiations leading to the Poona Pact. He was a prominent political leader advocating for the rights of the depressed classes.
- Post-1932 Political Activity: Far from withdrawing, Dr. Ambedkar remained extremely active in politics and public life after 1932. He continued to represent the interests of Scheduled Castes, formed and led political parties (like the Independent Labour Party in 1936 and the Scheduled Castes Federation in 1942), participated in various committees and conferences, and played a pivotal role in the constitutional development of India, culminating in his chairmanship of the Drafting Committee of the Indian Constitution after independence. He served as a minister in the interim government and later the first cabinet of independent India.
Given his continuous and significant political involvement throughout the 1930s and 1940s, the claim that Dr. B. R. Ambedkar withdrew from active politics for almost a decade after the Communal Award was revoked is false.
Conclusion on Statements
Based on our analysis:
- Statement I is true because the Poona Pact did provide for reserved seats for Scheduled Castes in a joint electorate, and 151 is a representative number for the provincial legislatures.
- Statement II is false because Dr. B. R. Ambedkar remained very active in politics after the Communal Award/Poona Pact period.
Thus, Statement I is true, but Statement II is false.
Revision Table: Poona Pact vs. Communal Award
| Feature | Communal Award (for Depressed Classes) | Poona Pact (for Scheduled Castes) |
|---|---|---|
| Type of Electorate | Separate Electorate | Joint Electorate with Reserved Seats |
| Number of Reserved Seats (Provincial) | 71 | Increased number (around 147-151, approx.) |
| Signed Year | 1932 (Announced) | 1932 (Signed) |
| Key Negotiators/Parties | British Government decision | Mahatma Gandhi, Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, and others |
Additional Information: Impact of Poona Pact
The Poona Pact was a landmark agreement that significantly altered the representation structure for Scheduled Castes (then known as Depressed Classes). While it averted the introduction of separate electorates for this group, which Gandhi believed would permanently divide Hindu society, it also ensured increased political representation through a larger number of reserved seats in a joint electorate. This mechanism of reserved constituencies within a joint electorate became a feature of the Indian electoral system after independence.
Similar Questions
Statement I: Non-cooperation began in Punjab with the student movement inspired by Lala Lajpat Rai in January 1921.
Statement II: The Sikh dominated central Punjab countryside was stirred by the powerful Akali upsurge.
Which one of the following peasant struggles was an outcome of British opium policy?
Who was the editor of the journal Indian Social Reformer that was started in 1890?
Which of the following was/were founded by Raja Ram Mohan Roy?
1. Atmiya Sabha
2. Brahmo Samaj
3. Prarthana Samaj
4. Arya SamajConsider the following statements about the different meanings of ‘Swaraj’ as articulated by Mahatma Gandhi:
1. Swaraj is intimately linked with Ahimsa (non-violence) and Satyagraha (adherence to truth).
2. Swaraj has two senses— one political and one beyond the realm of politics.
3. Swaraj is something that requires time and patience to acquire.
4. With determination, Swaraj could be obtained easily and quickly.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?Which of the following statements about the Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) are correct?
1. It began as the political wing of the Singh Sabhas in the late 19 th century.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
2. It was formed in 1920 as part of the upcoming Akali movement.
3. It was founded to reclaim control of the Sikh shrines from the government manipulated loyalist committees.
4. It formed the Akali Dal to coordinate groups (Jathas) to reclaim control of the shrines.- Which of the following is/are the correct components of the "Lion Capital" at Sarnath?
1. The shaft (stambha-yashti) or the tall tapering column
2. An elliptical top part – the abacus, devoid of any carvings
3. Overflowing inverted petals below the abacus
Select the answer using the code given below : Statement I: The United Provinces during Non-Cooperation became one of the strongest bases of Congress.
Statement II: The literary outcrop of Non-Cooperation in Bengal was quite meager compared to the days of the Swadeshi agitation.
Which of the following statements is/are correct?
1. Shivaji sent an ambassador to Bombay to negotiate an agreement with the English.
2. His chief motive was to secure English aid against the Siddis of Danda - Rajpuri.
3. He wanted a supply of grenades, mortars and other ammunition.
Select the correct answer using the code given below:Which member of the Servants of India Society founded the Seva Samiti at Allahabad in 1914?
Important Questions from Modern India (National Movement )
Which one is the correct chronological order of the following events?
I. Quit India Movement
II. Shimla Conference
III. Poona Pact
IV. Cabinet Mission
The policy of annexation is extensively applied if the kingdom doesn't have a natural heir and if the British disapproved of the adopted heir. From the given options, select the policy discussed here:
Who brought the strife between Swarajists and no changers to an end on November 6, 1924?
Match the following (Leaders of Chhattisgarh imprisoned during Quit India Movement of 1942 and places)
List - I
(Leaders)
List - II
(Places)
A. Tretanath Tiwari 1. Malkapur B. Raghunandan Pd. Singhrol 2. Raipur C. Amar Singh Sahgal 3. Bilaspur D. Pt. Ravishankar Shukla 4. Durg Which of the following personalities of this state was pioneer in the field of emancipation of untouchables ?
