Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit. Argument: The Supreme Court has decided that all rapists will be hanged till death. Assumption: 1. Women will get protection.
Only assumption 2 is implicit
When analyzing an argument, it's important to identify the implicit assumptions — statements that are not explicitly stated but are taken for granted by the person making the argument. These assumptions form the foundation upon which the argument rests.
Let's break down the given argument and assumptions:
Now, we need to evaluate which of these assumptions is/are implicit in the Supreme Court's decision (as stated in the argument).
The argument states a severe punishment for convicted rapists. This is a measure taken after a crime has occurred and a conviction has been made. While some might hope that punishing offenders harshly could indirectly lead to a safer environment over time, the punishment itself does not directly or implicitly guarantee protection for women. Protection involves preventative measures, law enforcement presence, societal changes, etc., which are not the immediate outcome or implied purpose of this specific punitive legal decision. Therefore, the assumption that women will get protection is not necessarily implicit in the decision to impose capital punishment.
Severe punishments, such as capital punishment, are often implemented with the underlying belief that they will serve as a strong deterrent. The purpose of deterring crime is to prevent future occurrences, thereby reducing the overall number of such cases. A court enacting such a severe penalty implicitly assumes that this punishment is capable of influencing behavior and potentially leading to a decrease in the incidence of rape cases. This possibility of reduction is a common rationale behind implementing harsh punishments for heinous crimes. Therefore, the assumption that the number of rape cases can be reduced is implicit in the decision.
Based on the analysis:
Thus, only Assumption 2 is implicit in the given argument.
| Assumption | Implicit in Argument? | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Women will get protection. | No | Punishment addresses crime post-facto; doesn't guarantee prior protection. |
| 2. The number of rapes cases can be reduced. | Yes | Severe punishment aims to deter future crimes, implying potential reduction in cases. |
Reviewing the core concepts related to arguments and assumptions helps solidify understanding.
| Term | Definition | Relevance to Question |
|---|---|---|
| Argument | A set of statements where one (the conclusion) is claimed to follow from the others (the premises). | The provided text contains an argument (Supreme Court decision). |
| Assumption | A premise or belief that is taken for granted, without proof. | We are identifying unstated beliefs implicit in the argument. |
| Implicit | Implied though not plainly expressed. | We are looking for assumptions that are suggested by the argument but not explicitly stated. |
Understanding the difference between implicit and explicit statements is crucial in logical reasoning and critical thinking.
In argument analysis, identifying implicit assumptions requires careful reading between the lines to uncover the underlying beliefs that make the argument cohere or make sense from the arguer's perspective. These implicit assumptions are often the weak points of an argument if they are not valid or are questionable.
In this specific question, the argument explicitly states the punishment. The assumptions about protection or reduction in cases are not stated but are potential reasons or expected outcomes implicitly linked to the decision to impose such a severe punishment.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
In City X, people prefer to buy Honda bikes instead of Bajaj, as Honda Company brings in Japanese technology.
Assumptions:
1. If Bajaj used Japanese technology, then its sales also would be on a par with Honda Company.
2. Bikes with Japanese technology are preferred to other bikes in City X.
Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit.
Statement:
A leading school in Mumbai will increase its fees by 150% from the next academic year.
Assumptions:
1. Students may change school due to more fees.
2. The school may still have the same demand among the students.
Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
Company X announced that in their company, 10 clerical jobs will be filled, with the minimum eligibility criteria being bachelor's degree pass.
Assumptions:
1. Those who have passed the bachelor's degree can apply.
2. Masters can also apply.
Consider the given statement true and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Statement:
A teacher tells a student, “if you don’t finish your homework, you will not be allowed into the class”.
Assumptions:
1. Discipline is a way to create effective learning.
2. The teacher will be happy not to have a student who is not punctual in his work.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
“A visit of school students to botanical garden to widen their knowledge of natural resources has been arranged” - a message on the notice board in the school.
Assumptions:
1. Botanical gardens are full of natural resources.
2. School students are likely to understand more through interaction with the new environment.
Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumption is/are implicit.
Argument:
Akbar said to his queen, “Birbal is the wisest man in my kingdom.”
Assumption:
1. Akbar is not as wise as Birbal.
2. Akbar wants Birbal to become the next king.Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumption is/are implicit.
Argument:
The highway authority had announced that it will be undertaking a major road repair work for three days beginning Friday between Bangalore and Tumkur.
Assumption:
1. People need to plan accordingly for their trip between Bangalore and Tumkur.
2. The authority is troubling citizens with unnecessary repair work.Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumption/s is/are implicit.
Statement:
Serials/soaps are a reason for developing negative tendencies in women.
Assumptions:
I: Newspapers highlight the negative aspects first and then, the positive aspects.
II: The attention given to the negative aspects is much higher than that given to the positive aspects.Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.
Argument:
If you’re a classical dancer, we have an exciting job for you.
Assumptions:
1. We need a classical dancer.
2. You are a classical dancer.Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.
Argument:
Alexander the Great was mortal.
Assumption:
1. Alexander the Great was human.
2. Alexander the Great was Greek.Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
An advertisement states that XYZ paints should be used to decorate houses.
Assumptions:
1. People want to decorate their house.
2. Only XYZ paints can make houses decorative.