All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.

Argument:

Alexander the Great was mortal.

Assumption:

1. Alexander the Great was human.

2. Alexander the Great was Greek.

This question was previously asked in
RRB ALP/Technician 2018 CBT 2 Electronics Mechanic Question Paper (23-Jan-2019) (Shift 1)
The correct answer is

Only assumption 1 is implicit

Understanding Arguments and Implicit Assumptions

When analyzing an argument, it's important to identify not only what is explicitly stated but also what is implicitly assumed. An assumption is something that is taken for granted or believed to be true, even if it is not directly mentioned in the argument. An implicit assumption is an unstated belief that is necessary for the argument to make sense or be considered valid.

The given argument is: "Alexander the Great was mortal."

We need to evaluate the two provided assumptions and decide if either or both are implicit, meaning they are unstated but required for the argument to hold true in its intended context.

Analyzing Assumption 1: Alexander the Great was human

Let's consider the statement "Alexander the Great was mortal". What does it mean to be mortal? Mortality is the state of being subject to death. This characteristic is fundamentally linked to living organisms, particularly humans in the context of historical figures like Alexander the Great.

  • If Alexander the Great was not human (for example, if the statement was metaphorically applied to a god, a concept, or an inanimate object), saying he was "mortal" would likely change the meaning or context of the statement significantly.
  • In the standard understanding of a historical figure being mortal, it implies that they are subject to the natural biological processes that lead to death, which is a characteristic of being human.
  • Therefore, for the statement "Alexander the Great was mortal" to be understood in its most common and direct sense concerning a historical person, the assumption that Alexander the Great was human is necessary. Without this assumption, the concept of his mortality as a historical figure becomes questionable or requires a different interpretation.

Thus, the assumption "Alexander the Great was human" is implicit in the argument.

Analyzing Assumption 2: Alexander the Great was Greek

Now let's consider the second assumption: "Alexander the Great was Greek". The argument states that Alexander the Great was mortal.

  • Mortality is a biological characteristic; it means being subject to death.
  • Whether a person is Greek, Persian, Egyptian, or any other nationality or ethnicity has no bearing on their biological state of being mortal. All humans, regardless of their nationality, are mortal.
  • The fact that Alexander the Great was Greek is a historical fact about his identity, but it is not required for the statement about his mortality to be true. His mortality is independent of his nationality.

Therefore, the assumption "Alexander the Great was Greek" is not implicit in the argument "Alexander the Great was mortal". The argument about his mortality can be true whether he was Greek or not.

Conclusion on Implicit Assumptions

Based on the analysis:

  • Assumption 1 ("Alexander the Great was human") is implicit because being human is essential to the standard meaning of mortality in this context.
  • Assumption 2 ("Alexander the Great was Greek") is not implicit because nationality is irrelevant to mortality.

Therefore, only assumption 1 is implicit in the argument.

Assumption Is it necessary for the argument "Alexander the Great was mortal"? Is it Implicit?
1. Alexander the Great was human Yes, mortality implies being subject to death, a characteristic of humans in this context. Yes
2. Alexander the Great was Greek No, mortality is independent of nationality. No

Revision Table: Argument and Assumptions Analysis

Argument Assumptions Implicit? Reasoning
Alexander the Great was mortal. 1. Alexander the Great was human. Yes Mortality, in the context of a historical person, presupposes being human.
2. Alexander the Great was Greek. No Nationality (Greek) is not required for a person to be mortal.

Additional Information: Understanding Arguments and Logic

In logic and critical reasoning, an argument consists of one or more premises and a conclusion. Implicit assumptions can often be thought of as unstated premises that link the stated premises to the conclusion.

  • Premise: A statement accepted as true or fact. In this case, the argument itself acts somewhat like a premise we are analyzing for underlying assumptions.
  • Conclusion: The statement that follows from the premise(s). There is no explicit conclusion drawn from "Alexander the Great was mortal" here; we are just analyzing the statement itself for its assumptions.
  • Implicit Assumption: An unstated premise that is necessary for the argument to be valid or meaningful in its intended context. Identifying implicit assumptions is crucial for evaluating the soundness of an argument. If a necessary assumption is false, the argument may be flawed.

For example, consider the argument: "The ground is wet, therefore it rained." An implicit assumption is that wet ground is caused by rain (and not sprinklers, spilled water, etc.).

In the case of "Alexander the Great was mortal," the statement is a simple declarative sentence. The analysis focuses on what fundamental characteristic (like being human) must be true about Alexander for the concept of his "mortality" to apply in the standard historical/biological sense, versus characteristics (like nationality) that are irrelevant to the concept of mortality itself.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.

    Argument:

    In City X, people prefer to buy Honda bikes instead of Bajaj, as Honda Company brings in Japanese technology.

    Assumptions:

    1. If Bajaj used Japanese technology, then its sales also would be on a par with Honda Company.

    2. Bikes with Japanese technology are preferred to other bikes in City X.

  2. Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit.

    Statement:

    A leading school in Mumbai will increase its fees by 150% from the next academic year.

    Assumptions:

    1. Students may change school due to more fees.

    2. The school may still have the same demand among the students.

  3. Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.

    Statement:

    Company X announced that in their company, 10 clerical jobs will be filled, with the minimum eligibility criteria being bachelor's degree pass.

    Assumptions:

    1. Those who have passed the bachelor's degree can apply.

    2. Masters can also apply.

  4. Consider the given statement true and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.

    Statement:

    A teacher tells a student, “if you don’t finish your homework, you will not be allowed into the class”.

    Assumptions:

    1. Discipline is a way to create effective learning.

    2. The teacher will be happy not to have a student who is not punctual in his work.

  5. Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.

    Argument:

    “A visit of school students to botanical garden to widen their knowledge of natural resources has been arranged” - a message on the notice board in the school.

    Assumptions:

    1. Botanical gardens are full of natural resources.

    2. School students are likely to understand more through interaction with the new environment.

  6. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumption is/are implicit.

    Argument:

    Akbar said to his queen, “Birbal is the wisest man in my kingdom.”

    Assumption:

    1. Akbar is not as wise as Birbal.

    2. Akbar wants Birbal to become the next king.
  7. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumption is/are implicit.

    Argument:

    The highway authority had announced that it will be undertaking a major road repair work for three days beginning Friday between Bangalore and Tumkur.

    Assumption:

    1. People need to plan accordingly for their trip between Bangalore and Tumkur.

    2. The authority is troubling citizens with unnecessary repair work.
  8. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.

    Argument:

    The Supreme Court has decided that all rapists will be hanged till death.

    Assumption:

    1. Women will get protection.

    2. The number of rapes cases can be reduced.
  9. Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumption/s is/are implicit.

    Statement:

    Serials/soaps are a reason for developing negative tendencies in women.

    Assumptions:

    I: Newspapers highlight the negative aspects first and then, the positive aspects.

    II: The attention given to the negative aspects is much higher than that given to the positive aspects.
  10. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.

    Argument:

    If you’re a classical dancer, we have an exciting job for you.

    Assumptions:

    1. We need a classical dancer.

    2. You are a classical dancer.

Important Questions from Statements and Assumptions

  1. Which of the following are true about tragic stories, according to Northrop Frye?
    A. Tragic stories, when they apply to divine beings, may be called Dionysiac.
    B. In tragic stories, the hero must be excluded from the society.
    C. In tragic stories, the god is inferior to nature.
    D. Tragic stories are the stories of dying gods.
    E. God's death in tragic stories is associated with autumn or sunset which necessarily means
    that he is a god of "Vegetation" or "Sunset".
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  2. Which of the following are true about representational media?
    A. Linear narrative
    B. Aesthetic illusion
    C. Story telling
    D. Photography
    E. Recipiont's attention
    Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
  3. According to the passage, how does Aristotle differentiate among the primary literary forms?
  4. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India's (IRDAI) June 2025 advisory on the Air India AI-171 crash was issued to which of the following stakeholders?
  5. Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    An advertisement states that XYZ paints should be used to decorate houses. 

    Assumptions: 

    1. People want to decorate their house. 

    2. Only XYZ paints can make houses decorative.

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB Staff Nurse
November 23, 2026
RRB Paramedical
November 23, 2026
Test Series
RRB ALP img
Railways
RRB ALP 2026 Mock Test series
1035 Tests 1 Tests Free
1782 Attempts
4.3(259)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App