Which one of the following issues was included in the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement of 2007?
India has 'advance right to reprocess' US-origin safeguarded spent fuel.
Understanding the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement of 2007
The Indo-US Nuclear Agreement, also known as the 123 Agreement, was a landmark accord signed in 2007 that enabled civil nuclear cooperation between India and the United States. This agreement aimed to integrate India into the global nuclear non-proliferation regime while allowing it access to civilian nuclear technology and fuel.
Let's analyze the given options regarding the issues included in this important agreement.
Analysis of Indo-US Nuclear Agreement Issues
We will examine each statement to determine which one accurately reflects a key issue or provision included in the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement of 2007.
Option 1: India has 'advance right to reprocess' US-origin safeguarded spent fuel.
- This statement refers to India's ability to process spent nuclear fuel from reactors using US-origin material, provided these reactors are under international safeguards.
- The "advance right to reprocess" was a crucial point for India during the negotiations. Normally, countries require specific permission each time they wish to reprocess spent fuel from safeguarded facilities, particularly when the fuel or reactor components are of foreign origin.
- The agreement granted India this "advance right" subject to establishing a new dedicated reprocessing facility under IAEA safeguards. This was a significant concession, acknowledging India's need to manage its nuclear fuel cycle independently for energy security.
- Therefore, this issue was indeed a significant part of the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement discussions and final text.
Option 2: India did not have the right to build a strategic fuel reserve with the help of the other supplier countries.
- A "strategic fuel reserve" refers to stockpiling nuclear fuel to ensure uninterrupted operation of nuclear power plants, protecting against potential supply disruptions.
- Far from prohibiting this, the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement explicitly allowed and facilitated India's ability to build a strategic reserve of nuclear fuel to guard against any disruption of supply for its safeguarded civilian reactors.
- The agreement encouraged other Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) members to cooperate with India in building such a reserve.
- Thus, this statement is incorrect. India gained the right to build a strategic fuel reserve as a result of this agreement.
Option 3: India should not test a nuclear device.
- The Indo-US Nuclear Agreement itself did not contain an explicit clause stating that India should not test a nuclear device.
- However, the broader understanding and the subsequent waiver granted to India by the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) in 2008 were based on India's voluntary moratorium on nuclear testing.
- Resuming nuclear testing would likely jeopardize the benefits derived from the agreement and the NSG waiver, potentially leading to the cessation of nuclear cooperation.
- While the agreement relied on India's commitment to its test moratorium, the specific prohibition was not a direct clause within the 2007 agreement text itself in the way described.
Option 4: The US will impede the growth of India's nuclear weapons programme.
- The primary focus of the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement was civil nuclear cooperation and bringing India's civilian nuclear facilities under international safeguards.
- A key prerequisite for the agreement was the separation of India's civilian and military nuclear facilities. India committed to placing its civilian reactors and facilities under IAEA safeguards.
- The agreement did not aim to impede India's existing military nuclear program. By separating civilian and military facilities and safeguarding the civilian side, the agreement effectively acknowledged India's military program while enabling civil cooperation.
- The agreement facilitated access to fuel and technology for the civilian sector, which could arguably free up India's domestic resources for other areas, but its direct purpose was not to hinder the weapons program.
Based on the analysis, the provision granting India the 'advance right to reprocess' US-origin safeguarded spent fuel was a specific and crucial issue included and resolved in the Indo-US Nuclear Agreement of 2007.
Revision Table: Key Features of Indo-US Nuclear Agreement (2007)
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Purpose | Enabled civil nuclear cooperation between India and the USA. |
| Safeguards | India agreed to place identified civilian nuclear facilities under IAEA safeguards. |
| Fuel Supply Assurance | Provided access to international nuclear fuel markets. |
| Strategic Reserve | Allowed India to build a strategic nuclear fuel reserve. |
| Reprocessing Rights | Granted India 'advance right to reprocess' US-origin spent fuel under safeguards. |
| Technology Transfer | Opened avenues for transfer of civil nuclear technology. |
Additional Information on Indo-US Nuclear Cooperation
The Indo-US Nuclear Agreement of 2007 paved the way for India to gain a waiver from the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) in 2008. This waiver allowed member states of the NSG to engage in civilian nuclear trade with India, despite India not being a signatory to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). The agreement and the subsequent NSG waiver were significant milestones, ending India's isolation from the international mainstream of nuclear commerce that had persisted since its 1974 nuclear test.
The formal title of the agreement is "Agreement for Cooperation Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of India Concerning Peaceful Uses of Nuclear Energy". It is commonly referred to as the '123 Agreement' because it is required under Section 123 of the U.S. Atomic Energy Act of 1954.
Similar Questions
Afro-Asian solidarity as a central element of India's foreign policy was initiated by which of the following Prime Ministers?
Which country signed a Memorandum of Understanding with India for promoting the production of Pigeon peas/Tur another pulses in July 2016?
India became a member of which one of the following in 2016?
The 'Gujral Doctrine' relates to which one of the following issues?
India is the first country in the world to deploy an all-woman contingent to a UN Peacekeeping Mission. In which country did this mission operate?
In October 2017, India sent its first shipment of wheat to Afghanistan as a part of commitment made by the Government of India to supply 1-1 million tons of wheat to that country on grant basis. The shipment was sent through
Which one of the following statements is not correct?
The 2+2 Bilateral Dialogue was held in September 2018 between ________.
Important Questions from India and World
Italy has launched its first-ever mega food park project in which of the following states in India in April 2021?
Recently, India has delivered three Cheetal military choppers to which neighbouring country?
Afro-Asian solidarity as a central element of India's foreign policy was initiated by which of the following Prime Ministers?
Which Agency is financing the External Aided Project - Rajasthan Urban Sector Development Program?
In which of the following country India organised a Cultural festival to mark Tagore's 156th birth anniversary?
