The Fundamental Rights guaranteed in the Constitution of India can be suspended only by ________.
A proclamation of National Emergency
Understanding the Suspension of Fundamental Rights in India
The Constitution of India guarantees certain Fundamental Rights to its citizens. These rights are considered essential for the overall development of individuals. However, like many rights, they are not absolute and can be subject to certain restrictions or even suspension under specific circumstances.
How Fundamental Rights Can Be Suspended
Let's examine the circumstances under which the Fundamental Rights guaranteed in the Constitution of India can be suspended. The question asks specifically about the primary mechanism for suspending these rights.
The suspension of Fundamental Rights is a significant constitutional provision that comes into play during extraordinary situations. The Indian Constitution provides a specific mechanism for this, primarily linked to times of grave national crisis.
Analyzing the Options
Let's look at the given options to determine which one correctly identifies the event that can lead to the suspension of Fundamental Rights:
- A proclamation of National Emergency: This refers to a declaration made by the President of India under Article 352 of the Constitution when the security of India or a part of it is threatened by war, external aggression, or armed rebellion. The Constitution contains specific provisions regarding the effect of such a proclamation on Fundamental Rights.
- An Act passed by the Parliament: While Parliament has the power to make laws, including laws that may impose reasonable restrictions on Fundamental Rights as permitted by the Constitution (e.g., under Article 19), a general Act of Parliament cannot simply suspend all Fundamental Rights at will. The power of Parliament is subject to judicial review to ensure it doesn't violate the basic structure or spirit of the Constitution, including the Fundamental Rights themselves.
- An amendment to the Constitution of India: Constitutional amendments are procedures to change the Constitution itself (under Article 368). While an amendment can modify or even potentially remove certain rights (subject to the basic structure doctrine laid down by the Supreme Court), it is a process of changing the permanent law, not a mechanism for temporary suspension of rights during an emergency.
- The judicial decisions of the Supreme Court: The Supreme Court is the guardian of the Constitution and the protector of Fundamental Rights. Its decisions interpret the scope and limitations of these rights and can strike down laws that violate them. Judicial decisions uphold and enforce Fundamental Rights; they do not suspend them.
The Role of National Emergency
The Constitution explicitly states that during a Proclamation of National Emergency, the Fundamental Rights guaranteed by Article 19 (like freedom of speech, assembly, association, movement, residence, and profession) are automatically suspended (Article 358). Furthermore, the President can, by order, suspend the right to move any court for the enforcement of other Fundamental Rights (except those guaranteed by Articles 20 and 21) for the period the Proclamation of Emergency is in force (Article 359).
This means that the most direct and significant mechanism for the suspension of a wide range of Fundamental Rights is indeed a proclamation of National Emergency.
Therefore, the correct answer is that Fundamental Rights can be suspended only by a proclamation of National Emergency, subject to the specific provisions of Articles 358 and 359.
Key Articles Related to Emergency and Fundamental Rights
- Article 352: Proclamation of Emergency (National Emergency).
- Article 358: Suspension of provisions of Article 19 during emergencies. This suspension is automatic upon a National Emergency declaration based on war or external aggression.
- Article 359: Suspension of the enforcement of the rights conferred by Part III during emergencies. This requires a specific Presidential Order and cannot extend to Articles 20 and 21.
- Article 20: Protection in respect of conviction for offences.
- Article 21: Protection of life and personal liberty. These two rights cannot be suspended even during a National Emergency.
| Event | Effect on Article 19 | Effect on Other Fundamental Rights (except 20 & 21) |
|---|---|---|
| Proclamation of National Emergency (War/External Aggression) | Automatically suspended (Article 358) | Can be suspended by Presidential Order (Article 359) |
| Proclamation of National Emergency (Armed Rebellion) | Not automatically suspended; can be suspended by Presidential Order (Article 359) | Can be suspended by Presidential Order (Article 359) |
Revision Table: Fundamental Rights Suspension
| Mechanism | Effect on Fundamental Rights |
|---|---|
| Proclamation of National Emergency | Suspends Article 19 automatically (under specific grounds) and allows suspension of enforcement of other rights (except 20 & 21) via Presidential Order. This is the primary mechanism. |
| Act passed by Parliament | Can impose reasonable restrictions, but cannot generally suspend rights. |
| Amendment to the Constitution | Changes the fundamental law itself, not a temporary suspension mechanism. |
| Judicial decisions of Supreme Court | Interpret and protect rights, do not suspend them. |
Additional Information: Emergency Provisions and Fundamental Rights
The emergency provisions in Part XVIII of the Indian Constitution (Articles 352-360) are designed to enable the Union government to meet extraordinary situations effectively. The suspension of Fundamental Rights during a National Emergency is a controversial but constitutionally provided measure intended to strengthen the hands of the government in safeguarding the security and stability of the nation during crisis. However, the power to suspend rights is not absolute and is subject to constitutional limits, including the non-suspension of rights under Articles 20 and 21 and the requirement for parliamentary approval of the emergency proclamation.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following statements is not true of the Protection of women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005?
Under which one of the following Articles of the Constitution of India, a statement of estimated receipts and expenditure of the Government of India has to be laid before the Parliament in respect of every financial year?
Article 231 of the Constitution of India grants power to establish a common High Court for two or more states to
Article 371 A of the Constitution of India provides special privileges to __________.
How many Zonal Councils were set up vide Part-III of the States Re-organization Act, 1956?
Which article prescribes that all proceedings in the Supreme Court shall be in English language?
Which one of the following conditions laid down in the Constitution of India for the issue of a writ of Quo- Warranto is not correct?
Which one among the following is not a part of the Fundamental Rights (Part III) of the Constitution of India?
Which of the following features were borrowed by the Constitution of India from the British Constitution?
1. Rule of Law
2. Law-making Procedure
3. Independence of Judiciary
4. Parliamentary System
Select the correct answer using the code given below.Which one of the following Schedules of the Constitution of India has fixed the number of Members of the Rajya Sabha to be elected from each State?
Important Questions from Basics of Constitution
Which article of Indian constitution is related with Official language of the Union?
In which year was the Indian ‘Wildlife (Protection) Act’ implemented?
Which article of the Indian constitution was called the 'heart and soul' of the constitution by Dr. B. R. Ambedkar?
In 1946, who among the following was made the interim president of the Indian Constituent Assembly ?
Who was the Chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Constituent Assembly of India?
