Directions: The following seven (7) items consist of two statements, Statement I and Statement II. Examine these two statements carefully and select the correct answer using the code given below. Statement I: By far the most common topographic form in a Karst terrain is the sinkhole. Statement II: Topographically, a sinkhole is a depression that varies in depth from less than a meter to few hundred meters.
Both the statements are individually true, but Statement II is not the correct explanation of Statement I
Understanding Karst Terrain and Sinkholes
The question asks us to examine two statements about Karst terrain and the topographic forms found within it, specifically focusing on sinkholes.
Let's analyze each statement individually to determine its truthfulness in the context of Karst topography.
Analysis of Statement I: Sinkholes in Karst Terrain
Statement I: By far the most common topographic form in a Karst terrain is the sinkhole.
Karst terrain is a landscape formed from the dissolution of soluble rocks such as limestone, dolomite, and gypsum. This dissolution process creates distinctive landforms both above and below the ground. Common features include caves, underground drainage systems, and various types of surface depressions.
Sinkholes, also known as dolines, are among the most characteristic and widespread surface features in Karst landscapes. They are formed by the collapse of surface material into underlying cavities or by the gradual dissolution of bedrock from the surface downwards. Due to the pervasive nature of dissolution in soluble rock areas, sinkholes are indeed very common and often dominate the surface topography of Karst regions.
Based on geographical and geological studies of Karst areas worldwide, sinkholes are considered the most frequent and easily recognizable surface landform. Therefore, Statement I is considered true.
Analysis of Statement II: Description of a Sinkhole
Statement II: Topographically, a sinkhole is a depression that varies in depth from less than a meter to few hundred meters.
As discussed, a sinkhole is a depression in the ground. These depressions can form through different processes: gradual dissolution or sudden collapse. The size and depth of sinkholes are highly variable. Some are small, shallow bowl-shaped features only a meter or two across and less than a meter deep, often called dissolution sinkholes or dolines proper.
Others, particularly those formed by the collapse of cave roofs, can be much larger and deeper, sometimes hundreds of meters across and similarly deep. These are often referred to as collapse sinkholes or cenotes (in certain regions).
Thus, stating that a sinkhole is a depression varying in depth from less than a meter to few hundred meters is an accurate description of the topographic form and dimensional range of sinkholes found in Karst terrain.
Therefore, Statement II is considered true.
Relationship Between Statements I and II
We have determined that both Statement I and Statement II are individually true. Now we need to evaluate if Statement II is the correct explanation for Statement I.
- Statement I claims sinkholes are the *most common* form in Karst terrain.
- Statement II *describes* what a sinkhole is: a depression of varying depth.
Statement II provides a description of a sinkhole's physical characteristics (it's a depression and its possible depth range). This description helps us understand what a sinkhole looks like, but it does not explain *why* sinkholes are the *most common* feature in Karst terrain. The reason for their prevalence is linked to the fundamental processes of Karst formation – the widespread dissolution of soluble bedrock and the subsequent creation of voids and collapses, which are manifested on the surface primarily as sinkholes.
Therefore, Statement II describes a sinkhole but does not explain the reason for its high frequency or dominance in Karst landscapes.
Conclusion: Both statements are individually true, but Statement II is not the correct explanation of Statement I.
Based on this analysis, the correct option is the one stating that both statements are individually true, but Statement II is not the correct explanation of Statement I.
| Statement | Truth Value | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Statement I: By far the most common topographic form in a Karst terrain is the sinkhole. | True | Sinkholes (dolines) are the most widespread and characteristic surface features formed by the dissolution of soluble rock in Karst landscapes. |
| Statement II: Topographically, a sinkhole is a depression that varies in depth from less than a meter to few hundred meters. | True | Sinkholes are indeed depressions, and their depth varies significantly depending on the formation process and geological setting, ranging from shallow features to deep pits. |
Evaluation of Explanation: Statement II describes the form and scale of a sinkhole. This description does not explain why sinkholes are the *most common* form in Karst areas. The commonality is due to the pervasive nature of dissolution and subsequent surface manifestations in Karst landscapes.
Therefore, Statement II is not the correct explanation for Statement I.
Revision Table: Key Terms in Karst Topography
| Term | Definition | Relevance to the Question |
|---|---|---|
| Karst Terrain | A landscape shaped by the dissolution of a layer or layers of soluble bedrock, usually limestone, dolomite, or gypsum. | The geographical context for the statements. |
| Sinkhole (Doline) | A depression or hole in the ground caused by some form of collapse of the surface layer. Sinkholes can be formed gradually by the dissolution of bedrock or by the collapse of a cave roof or void. | The specific topographic form discussed in both statements. |
| Topographic Form | A natural feature of the Earth's surface; a landform. | Refers to sinkholes as a type of landform in Karst areas. |
| Dissolution | The process by which a solid is dissolved by a solvent, typically water dissolving soluble minerals in bedrock. | The primary geological process forming Karst features like sinkholes. |
Additional Information on Sinkhole Formation
Sinkholes form primarily through two main mechanisms in Karst terrain:
- Dissolution Sinkholes: These form gradually where water percolates through soil and sediment, dissolving the underlying soluble bedrock along fractures and joints. This slow dissolution creates a depression on the surface as the ground level lowers.
- Cover-Collapse Sinkholes: These occur where a void develops in the bedrock beneath a layer of soil or sediment. When the cavity in the bedrock becomes large enough, the overlying cover material collapses suddenly into the void, creating a dramatic and often deep sinkhole.
The varied depths mentioned in Statement II are a result of these different formation processes and the specific geological conditions.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following statements with regard to volcanoes is not correct?
Which one of the following is not related to wind erosion?
Which one of the following pairs isnotcorrectly matched?
Geomorphic factors influencing plant and animal distributions are
Which of the following statements regarding continent of Antarctica is/are correct?
1. It has the highest average elevation as compared to all other continents.
2. Mount Vinson is the highest peak of this continent.
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
With reference to earthquakes, which of the following statements are correct?
1. Earthquakes largely occur along the converging plate boundaries.
2. Point of origin of the earthquake in the lithosphere is known as the focus/Hypocentre.
3. The intensity of the earthquake decreases with distance from the epicentre.
4. The epicentre of the earthquake always remains over continents only.
Select the correct answer using the code given below.Stalactites and stalagmites are features of __________.
Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists :
List-I List-II (Active Volcano) (Location) A. Mount Merapi 1. Hawaii B. Sakurajima 2. Italy C. Mount Vesuvius 3. Japan D. Mauna Loa 4. Indonesia What is the approximate percentage of carbon in the Earth’s crust ?
'Pingos' are associated with which one of the following process?
Important Questions from Geomorphology
Marble is the metamorphosed form of?
Asthenosphere is:
The discontinuity present in earth's interior between lower mantle and outer core is called _________.
Which of the following igneous rocks contain silica in excess of 65%?
Which one of the following describes the Lithosphere?
