All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Consider the given statement and decide which of the following argument(s) is/are strong.

Statement:

Should CBDT abolish income tax in India?

Argument 1: Yes, it is an unnecessary burden on the wage earners in India.

Argument 2: No, it is a good source of revenue for Indian Government.

This question was previously asked in
RRB ALP/Technician 2018 CBT 2 Electronics Mechanic Question Paper (23-Jan-2019) (Shift 1)
The correct answer is

Only argument 2 is strong.

Analyzing Arguments on CBDT Abolishing Income Tax in India

Let's break down the statement and the arguments given regarding the potential abolition of income tax in India by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT).

Understanding the Statement and Arguments

The core question is whether the CBDT should abolish income tax in India. Two arguments are presented:

  • Argument 1: Supports abolition, claiming it's an unnecessary burden on wage earners.
  • Argument 2: Opposes abolition, stating it's a good source of government revenue.

Evaluating Argument 1: Income Tax as an Unnecessary Burden?

Argument 1 claims income tax is an "unnecessary burden" on wage earners. Let's consider this:

  • Income tax does represent a portion of a person's income that goes to the government, which can be perceived as a burden.
  • However, describing it as "unnecessary" is a strong and questionable claim. Taxes are the primary means by which governments fund essential public services like infrastructure (roads, bridges), healthcare, education, defense, law enforcement, and social welfare programs.
  • Removing this "burden" would necessitate finding an alternative, equally substantial source of revenue, or drastically cutting public spending, neither of which is simple or necessarily beneficial for society as a whole.
  • Focusing only on the perspective of wage earners and calling the tax "unnecessary" without considering its vital role makes this argument weak. It doesn't provide a robust justification for complete abolition.

Based on this analysis, Argument 1 is not strong because it uses subjective terms ("unnecessary burden") and ignores the fundamental purpose and necessity of income tax for government functioning and public welfare.

Evaluating Argument 2: Income Tax as a Good Source of Revenue?

Argument 2 states that income tax is a "good source of revenue for Indian Government." Let's examine this claim:

  • Factually, income tax is one of the major sources of revenue for the government in India. This revenue is crucial for funding the Union Budget and enabling the government to carry out its functions and development initiatives.
  • Abolishing a significant revenue source like income tax would create a massive fiscal deficit and cripple the government's ability to provide public goods and services, manage the economy, and meet its financial obligations.
  • Governments worldwide rely heavily on income tax (or similar direct taxes) precisely because they are effective ways to collect revenue based on individuals' capacity to pay.

This argument is strong because it points to a crucial, factual aspect of income tax – its role as a vital source of government funding. Abolishing it would have severe, negative consequences for the government's finances and its ability to serve the public.

Conclusion on Argument Strength

Comparing the two arguments:

  • Argument 1 is weak because it is based on a subjective perception of income tax as an "unnecessary burden" and fails to acknowledge its essential role in public finance.
  • Argument 2 is strong because it highlights the undeniable fact that income tax is a major source of government revenue, and removing it would have profound negative impacts on public services and governance.

Therefore, only Argument 2 provides a strong reason relevant to the decision of whether or not to abolish income tax.

Final Decision Justification

Considering the strength of the arguments, Argument 2 presents a compelling reason against abolishing income tax, focusing on its essential function for government revenue. Argument 1, while acknowledging the tax is a burden, fails to present a strong, justified reason for its complete abolition by calling it "unnecessary" without proposing viable alternatives for funding public services. Thus, only Argument 2 holds significant weight in this debate.

Argument Claim Evaluation Strength
Argument 1 Income tax is an unnecessary burden on wage earners. Focuses on individual perception; ignores vital role in funding public services. Weak
Argument 2 Income tax is a good source of revenue for Indian Government. Highlights essential function for government finances and public services. Strong

Revision Table: Key Concepts Revisited

Concept Description Relevance to Arguments
Income Tax A direct tax levied on the income of individuals and corporations. The subject of the statement and arguments.
CBDT (Central Board of Direct Taxes) The statutory body in India responsible for administering direct taxes, including income tax. The entity mentioned in the statement as potentially making the decision.
Government Revenue Funds collected by the government through various sources (taxes, fees, etc.). Argument 2's core point; essential for government operations and services.
Public Services Services provided by the government for its citizens (e.g., healthcare, education, infrastructure). Funded by government revenue, significantly impacted by tax policy decisions.

Additional Information: Understanding Income Tax in India

Income tax plays a critical role in India's fiscal policy. It's not just about collecting money; it's also a tool for:

  • Funding Public Expenditure: As discussed, it's a primary source for funding government programs and services.
  • Reducing Inequality: Progressive tax systems (where higher earners pay a larger percentage of their income in tax) can help redistribute wealth and reduce income inequality.
  • Economic Management: Tax policies can be used to stimulate or slow down the economy, encourage savings or investment, and achieve specific economic goals.

While taxes are a financial obligation, the revenue they generate is indispensable for the functioning and development of the country. Any discussion about abolishing income tax must address how the government would replace this lost revenue and continue to provide essential services. Argument 2 directly addresses this fundamental point, making it a strong argument in this context.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is / are implicit.

    Argument:

    Today is Sunday.

    Assumption:

    1. Tomorrow is Monday.

    2. Today is a holiday.
  2. Read the given question and decide which of the following argument(s) is/are correct.

    Hydrogen is in a cylinder.

    Argument 1: Hydrogen is in a liquid state.

    Argument 2: Hydrogen is in a gaseous state.
  3. Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.

    Argument:

    The present government had reduced the base price for auctioning for the 2G spectrum.

    Assumptions:

    1. Next time price will reduce further.

    2. Last time the auction was not good.

  4. Read the given question and decide which of the following argument is/are strong.

    Are stock markets sources of wealth creation?

    Arguments:

    1. Yes, money multiplies in stock markets.

    2. No, investments in stock markets are subjected to market risk.
  5. Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.

    Argument:

    The year 2020 is a leap year.

    Assumptions:

    1. February will have 29 days in 2020.

    2. The year 2017 is not a leap year.
  6. Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumption(s) is (are) implicit

    Statement:

    The train fares have increased by 20% with immediate effect.

    Assumptions:

    I. People still prefer travelling by train despite the increase.

    II. Other modes of commutation may also increase their fares.

  7. Read the question and answer from the given information:

    Pravalika is studying 10 th class. Is Pravalika elder than Pranitha who is her classmate?

    Argument 1 : Yes, as she is her classmate Pranitha is younger to her.

    Argument 2 : No, as she is classmate Pranitha is elder to her.
  8. Read the following question and decide which of the given arguments is/are strong.

    Question: Should CBSE introduce the retention system till Class 10?

    Argument 1: Yes, as the foundations laid in lower classes are important for higher education.

    Argument 2: No, it is boring for a student to repeat the same class again.
  9. Given below is a question, followed by two arguments, I and II. You have to decide which of the given arguments, if any, is a strong argument, with respect to the question.

    Question: Should advertisements be banned on television?

    Argument I: Yes, advertisements are immoral.

    Argument II: No, advertisements bring in revenue which helps reduce cost for viewers.
  10. Read the question and answer from the given information:

    Should the government stop permission to new industries?

    Argument 1: Yes, new industries create environment pollution.

    Argument 2: No, New industries improves employment and takes part in economic growth of country.

Important Questions from Statements and Arguments

  1. Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered 1 and 2. You have to decide which of the arguments
    is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.

    Give answer:
    (A) If only argument1 is strong
    (B) If only argument 2 is strong
    (C) If either 1 or 2 is strong
    (D) If neither 1 nor 2 is strong and
    (E) If both 1 and 2 are strong.Statement:
    Should the colleges be free?

    Arguments:
    1. Yes, it creates a more well-educated workforce and a population that has better critical thinking skills.
    2. No, it will increase the race among the rich people.
  2. Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.

    Give answer:
    (A) If only argument I is strong
    (B) If only argument II is strong
    (C) If either I or II is strong
    (D) If neither I nor II is strong and
    (E) If both I and II are strong.

    Statement:
    Should the government be involved in internet censorship?

    Arguments:
    I. Yes, if more content is closely monitored by the government, it could cut down on the mass amounts of fraudulent information including false advertising.
    II. No, government should concentrate on other sensitive issues.

  3. The question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered 1 and 2. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.

    Give answer:
    (A) If only argument1 is strong
    (B) If only argument 2 is strong
    (C) If either 1 or 2 is strong
    (D) If neither 1 nor 2 is strong and
    (E) If both 1 and 2 are strong.

    Statement:
    Should there be a ban on smoking in public places?

    Argument:
    1. Yes, this will decrease the possibility of fire disasters.
    2. No, they are not effective.

  4. Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered 1 and 2. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.
    Give answer:
    (A) If only argument1 is strong
    (B) If only argument 2 is strong
    (C) If either 1 or 2 is strong
    (D) If neither 1 nor 2 is strong and
    (E) If both 1 and 2 is strong.
    Statement:
    Should the government spend money on art?
    Arguments:
    1. Yes, art brings quality into one's life.
    2. No, quality in a person's life derives from a decent opportunity in life, not a sculpture.
  5. Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument. 

    Give answer: 

    (A) If only argument I is strong 

    (B) If only argument II is strong 

    (C) If either I or II is strong 

    (D) If neither I nor II is strong and 

    (E) If both I and II are strong. 

    Statement: 

    Should kids be allowed to drink coffee? 

    Arguments: 

    I. Yes, kids might suffer from stomach problems that occur from a decreased appetite due to the stimulating nature of caffeine. 

    II. No, drinking coffee at night causes sleep issues.

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB Staff Nurse
November 23, 2026
RRB Paramedical
November 23, 2026
Test Series
RRB ALP img
Railways
RRB ALP 2026 Mock Test series
1035 Tests 1 Tests Free
1782 Attempts
4.3(259)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App