Consider the following statement: “So much is wrung from the peasants, that even dry bread is scarcely left to fill their stomachs.” Who among the following European travellers had made the above statement about the condition of peasantry in the Mughal Empire?
Francisco Pelsaert
Understanding Peasant Conditions in the Mughal Empire
The statement, “So much is wrung from the peasants, that even dry bread is scarcely left to fill their stomachs,” offers a stark portrayal of the difficult living conditions faced by the peasantry during the Mughal Empire. Many European travellers visited India during this period and recorded their observations, providing valuable insights into the society, economy, and administration.
Identifying the European Traveller
Several European travellers visited the Mughal Empire and documented their experiences. Among them are Francisco Pelsaert, Francois Bernier, Jean-Baptiste Tavernier, and Niccolao Manucci. Their accounts often touched upon various aspects of life, including the state of agriculture and the condition of the common people.
Let's look at the prominent works of these travellers:
- Francisco Pelsaert: A Dutch factor of the Dutch East India Company who stayed in Agra from 1620 to 1627. His work, 'Remonstrantie' (or 'Occasional Discourse'), is a detailed account of Mughal India, particularly focusing on economic conditions and social life. Pelsaert extensively described the exploitation of peasants and artisans by the state officials and nobles (jagirdars).
- Francois Bernier: A French physician and traveller who visited India during the reign of Aurangzeb (1658-1668). His work, 'Travels in the Mogul Empire', provides a critical view of the Mughal system, focusing on the concept of state ownership of land and its impact on the decline of agriculture and the misery of peasants.
- Jean-Baptiste Tavernier: A French gem merchant who made multiple voyages to India between 1638 and 1668. His 'Travels in India' primarily focuses on trade routes, precious stones, and the economic aspects, including the wealth of the nobility, though he also commented on the general state of affairs.
- Niccolao Manucci: An Italian adventurer who came to India around 1653 and served in various capacities, including as a physician. His 'Storia do Mogor' is a comprehensive history and account of the Mughal Empire, offering detailed descriptions of the court, administration, and social customs, often from a personal perspective.
Analyzing the Statement and Attribution
The given statement highlights the severe oppression and economic hardship faced by the peasants, suggesting that excessive demands (taxes, dues, forced labour) left them with barely enough to survive. This description strongly aligns with the observations made by Francisco Pelsaert in his 'Remonstrantie'. Pelsaert's account is known for its critical assessment of the exploitative nature of the Mughal administration concerning the primary producers.
In his writing, Pelsaert specifically detailed how jagirdars (assignees of land revenue) extracted as much as possible from the peasants within their tenure, without considering the long-term prosperity of the land or the welfare of the cultivators. This short-sighted exploitation is precisely what is captured in the quoted statement about peasants being 'wrung' dry.
While other travellers like Bernier also commented on the impoverished state of the peasantry due to the land system and constant transfers of jagirdars, the specific phrasing and detailed account of this particular level of exploitation are most famously associated with Francisco Pelsaert.
Therefore, the European traveller who made the statement about the harsh condition of peasantry in the Mughal Empire, that "So much is wrung from the peasants, that even dry bread is scarcely left to fill their stomachs," was Francisco Pelsaert.
Revision Table: European Travellers and Mughal India
| Traveller | Nationality | Period in Mughal India | Key Work | Focus/Observations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Francisco Pelsaert | Dutch | c. 1620-1627 | Remonstrantie | Economic conditions, exploitation of peasants/artisans, social life |
| Francois Bernier | French | c. 1658-1668 | Travels in the Mogul Empire | Political system, land ownership, condition of peasants, comparison with Europe |
| Jean-Baptiste Tavernier | French | Multiple voyages (1638-1668) | Travels in India | Trade routes, diamond mines, economic aspects, wealth of nobility |
| Niccolao Manucci | Italian | c. 1653 onwards | Storia do Mogor | Comprehensive history, court life, administration, social customs |
Additional Information: Peasant Life in Mughal India
The condition of peasants in the Mughal Empire was complex and varied regionally and over time. However, accounts from various sources, including European travellers and indigenous records, suggest that while agriculture was the backbone of the economy, the life of the average peasant was often difficult.
- Taxation: The primary demand on the peasants was land revenue, which could be collected in cash or kind. The rate of demand was often high, sometimes up to half of the produce.
- Jagirdari System: The system where nobles were assigned rights to collect revenue from specific areas (jagirs) led to frequent transfers. This encouraged jagirdars to extract maximum revenue quickly, without investing in agricultural improvements or caring for the long-term welfare of the peasants.
- Crop Failures and Famine: Dependence on monsoon, coupled with inadequate irrigation in many areas, made peasants vulnerable to crop failures and famines, which were frequent occurrences and severely impacted their lives.
- Social Hierarchy: Peasants were part of a hierarchical rural society, subject to demands not only from the state and jagirdars but also from zamindars and village headmen.
Accounts like Pelsaert's, while potentially biased from a European perspective, provide valuable external validation for the pressures faced by the peasant population under the Mughal administration.
Similar Questions
- Who was the author of the book of travels, called Rihla, written in Arabic, providing extremely rich and interesting details about India ?
How many of the following statements regarding medicine and related practices in medieval India is/are correct?
1. Indian medicine of the Graeco- Arabic tradition (Tibb-i-Yunani) was almost identical in its practice with contemporary Persian medicine.
2. Harvey's discovery of the circulation of blood was explained to a scholarly noble by European traveller Francois Bernier.
3. The practice of smallpox inoculation was described in contemporary Yunani Ayurvedic texts.
Select the correct answer.
Who among the following European travellers never returned to Europe and settled down in India?
According to the French traveller Tavernier, the majority of houses in Varanasi during the 17th century were made of ________.
Francois Bernier was physician to __________.
Ibn Batuta went to China as the envoy of which one of the following Delhi Sultans?
Which one of the following European travelers have NOT written an account of the Vijayanagara Empire?
Important Questions from Travellers of Medieval India
Foreign traveller Ibn Battuta, who came to India during the medieval period, had come from?
Francisco Pelsart was a _____ traveller.
Who among the following foreign travelers wrote that the Vijayanagara Empire had an estimated "90,000 men fit to bear arms"?
Pick the right sequence as per chronological order in terms of visits of the following foreign travelers in India
A. Marco Polo
B. Duarte Barbosa
C. Nikitin
D. Peter Mundy
E. Francois Bernier
Choose the correct answer from the options given below
Who among the following travellers visited a "Hospital of Birds" at Cambay in 1623-24, where he saw some lame, sick and mateless birds and some tiny orphan mice. He writes, "A venerable old man with a white beard was keeping them in a box amongst cotton, with his spectacles on his nose, giving them milk to eat with a bird's feather, because they were so little that as yet they could eat nothing else, and as he told us, he intended when they are grown up to let them go free whither they please".
