All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Can one's right to life be absolute ? Answer with reference to the idea of Capital Punishment.

This question was previously asked in
UPSC CSE 2025 (Prelims) CSAT Official Paper (25-May-2025)

The "right to life" is a fundamental human entitlement to not be killed by another individual or the state. The question of whether this right can be considered absolute is intensely debated, especially when confronted with the idea of Capital Punishment.

If the right to life were truly absolute, it would mean that no circumstance, no crime, and no justification could ever warrant its deliberate termination by the state. This position holds that human life is inherently sacred and inviolable, regardless of an individual's actions.

However, the existence and arguments for capital punishment fundamentally challenge this absolute stance. Proponents of capital punishment argue that in extreme cases, particularly for heinous crimes like premeditated murder, the perpetrator forfeits their right to life by violating another's. This perspective often rests on principles of retribution, arguing that justice demands a proportional response to the taking of another life. It also posits deterrence – that executing criminals prevents future crimes and protects society, implying the state has a right to prioritize the safety of its citizens, even if it means revoking a murderer's right to life under specific, grave conditions. Here, the state's duty to justice and protection might override the individual's right.

Conversely, abolitionists argue that the right to life is absolute and that capital punishment is inherently immoral and unjustifiable. They emphasize the inviolability of human life, asserting that no state has the moral authority to intentionally take a life, regardless of the crime committed. Concerns about the irreversibility of execution and the tragic possibility of executing an innocent person are central to this argument. They also point to the potential for cruel and unusual punishment and the state's perpetuation of violence. For them, a state that truly values life must protect it, even for those who have committed terrible acts, advocating for rehabilitation and restorative justice instead.

In conclusion, the debate over capital punishment squarely places the "absolute" nature of the right to life under scrutiny. While some argue for its forfeiture under specific, grave circumstances, others maintain its fundamental and unwavering inviolability, making it a cornerstone of their ethical framework.

Answered By:

Sarvesh Jha

Sarvesh Jha is a seasoned government exam mentor with firsthand success in top exams like IBPS PO, SBI PO, CDS, RRB JE, SSC CGL, BPSC, and CTET. Known for his deep conceptual clarity and strategic approach, he has guided over 5000 students through personalized mentorship. He has been creating well researched content for last 5 years.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. "Corrupt practices reveal an inherent tension between particularistic and universalistic normative standards." Do you agree with this statement? Give reasons and justification for your answer.

  2. How does gender as a social construct affect individuals' opportunities, rights, and access to resources? Critically discuss. 

  3. Discuss the salient features of equality according to J.S. Mill.

  4. Is the idea of secularism necessarily related to the idea of religious pluralism? Discuss.

  5. Comment on Plato's critique of Democracy.

  6. Present a detailed account of the debate between Gandhi and Ambedkar on the issue of caste discrimination.

  7. How does the reconciliation of opposites take place in the Humanism of Tagore? Evaluate.

  8. Evaluate Marxism as a Political Ideology.

  9. There is no permanent friend or permanent enemy.' Discuss this statement in the light of Kautilya's view on Sovereignty.

  10. Is it possible to reconcile the concept of development with tribal values to bring social and economic progress? Discuss.


Important Questions from Miscellaneous

  1. Write a note in 150 words
    Mendelian and non-Mendelian traits.

  2. Write a note in 150 words
    Theoretical significance of Purum kinship-system.

  3. Write a note in 150 words
    Smell as a signal among non-human primates.

  4. Write a note in 150 words
    Osteodontokeratik culture and its makers.

  5. Discuss the Miocene hominoid remains and their significance in evolution.

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
UPSC CMS
August 02, 2026
IAS Exam
August 21, 2026
UPSC SO Steno
December 12, 2026
Test Series
IAS img
UPSC
UPSC CSE (IAS) 2027 Prelims Mock Test Series
654 Tests 3 Tests Free
681 Attempts
4.8(182)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App