"I am going to watch her expenditure pattern because I notice a tendency on her part to splurge."
Which of the following conclusions is/are valid with respect to the statement?
(A) The speaker is a well-wisher of hers.
(B) She is spending beyond her means.
(C) The speaker is a concerned parent.
Analyzing the Statement on Expenditure
The core of the question lies in interpreting the statement: "I am going to watch her expenditure pattern because I notice a tendency on her part to splurge." We need to determine which conclusions logically follow from this statement alone.
Evaluating Potential Conclusions
-
Conclusion A: The speaker is a well-wisher of hers.
- The speaker is observing the subject's spending ("expenditure pattern").
- The reason for observation is noticing a negative tendency ("splurge").
- Monitoring someone's potentially problematic financial behavior ("splurge") suggests a desire for their well-being or to prevent negative consequences. This aligns with the role of a well-wisher.
- Therefore, this conclusion is valid.
-
Conclusion B: She is spending beyond her means.
- The statement mentions a tendency to "splurge," which means spending extravagantly or wastefully.
- However, "splurging" does not automatically equate to spending "beyond her means." The person might be spending lavishly but still within their financial capacity.
- The statement doesn't provide enough information to confirm if the spending exceeds her income or resources.
- Therefore, this conclusion is not necessarily valid.
-
Conclusion C: The speaker is a concerned parent.
- While a parent might exhibit this behavior (monitoring a child's spending), the statement doesn't specify the speaker's relationship to the subject.
- The speaker could be a friend, guardian, spouse, or another concerned individual.
- Concluding they are specifically a parent is an assumption not directly supported by the text.
- Therefore, this conclusion is not necessarily valid.
Final Conclusion Derivation
Based on the analysis, only the conclusion that the speaker is a well-wisher is directly and logically supported by the provided statement about observing an expenditure pattern due to a tendency to splurge. The specific relationship (parent) or financial status (beyond means) cannot be definitively concluded.
Similar Questions
- Select the conclusion, from among the following options, which logically follows from the given statement.
Statement:
One must work hard to be successful in life. - Read the given statement and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statement:
Doing exercises in the morning is good for health.
Conclusion 1:
Health can be maintained by doing exercises only.
Conclusion 2:
Without doing exercises, people will become ill. - Read the given statements and conclusions carefully and select the conclusion(s) that logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
Indian Education is lacking quality due to low funds. India is allocating additional funds to education sector.
Conclusions:
I. There would be improvement in quality of education in India.
II. Only funds can improve the education standards. - In the question below is given a statement followed by two conclusions numbered I and II. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.
Statement:
If A was there in XYZ cricket team, XYZ would have been the invincible team in the world.
Conclusion:
I. Without A, XYZ cannot win.
II. A is more talented than anyone else in the XYZ cricket team - Read the given statement carefully and select from among the given options, the conclusion that logically follows from the statement.
Statement:
Ability is a poor man's wealth. - Read the given statement and conclusions carefully and decide which conclusion(s) is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
No nation is completely self-dependent these days.
Conclusions:
I. Citizens of the country have become lazy.
II. It is impossible to grow and produce all that a nation needs. - Read the given statements and conclusions carefully and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
1. Lack of education is responsible for lower income of a state.
2. Bihar ranks very low in per capita income.
Conclusions:
I. Bihar has a lower rate of education.
II. Bihar is a very historic state. - Read the given statement and conclusions carefully and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.
Statement:
Company ABC has the highest number of customers as compared to its competitors.
Conclusions:
1. Company ABC has 58% of the total customers.
2. Company ABC's products are the cheapest in the market. - Read the given statement and conclusions carefully and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.
Statement:
Most students have charismatic personalities.
Conclusions:
1. Some students have charismatic personalities.
2. All students have charismatic personalities. Read the given statement and conclusions carefully and decide which of the conclusions logically follow(s) from the statement.
Statement:
The book 'P' emphasizes only on population of India and its related problems during 2001-2015.
Conclusions:
I. Increasing population is the biggest problem in India.
II. The book is the only book which deals with the problem of population in India.
Important Questions from Statement and Conclusions
Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusion(s) logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
All cats are bills.
No snakes are bills.
All snakes are dolls.
Conclusions:
(I) Some dolls are not cats.
(II) No bills are dolls.- Statement: Resilience supports recovery from setbacks, but without learning from mistakes, progress may stall.
Conclusion I: Resilience alone may not ensure progress.
Conclusion II: Learning from mistakes guarantees recovery.
Which conclusion follows? - Read the following statement carefully and identify the conclusion that follows.
Statement: "Government should provide free education to all children up to the age of 14."
Conclusions:
I. Education is a basic right of every child.
II. A large number of children are deprived of basic education. - Statement: Ethical behavior fosters trust, but profitability often relies on operational efficiency as well.
Conclusion I: Ethical behavior is not sufficient for profitability.
Conclusion II: Operational efficiency is required for trust.
Which conclusion follows? - Read the following statement carefully and identify the conclusion that follows.
Statement: "Online learning has increased student participation."
Conclusions:
I. Students did not participate in physical classes.
II. Technology helps in engaging students.
