All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read the following question and decide which of the given statements is/are sufficient.

Question:

Is Y > 0?

Statements:

1. X + Y > 0

2. X - Y > 0

This question was previously asked in
RRB ALP/Technician 2018 CBT 2 Electronics Mechanic Question Paper (23-Jan-2019) (Shift 1)
The correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2 is sufficient to answer the question.

Understanding Data Sufficiency and Inequality Questions

Data Sufficiency questions test your ability to determine if the information given in the statements is enough to answer the question asked. You don't need to find the exact value of a variable, just whether the statements provide sufficient information to answer the question definitively (either always YES or always NO).

The question asks: Is \(Y > 0\)?

We are given two statements:

  • Statement 1: \(X + Y > 0\)
  • Statement 2: \(X - Y > 0\)

Let's evaluate each statement separately, and then combine them, to see if we can definitively answer whether \(Y > 0\).

Analysing Statement 1 for Sufficiency

Statement 1 says \(X + Y > 0\). This means the sum of X and Y is a positive number.

Let's test some values for X and Y that satisfy this condition and see if Y must be greater than 0.

Example Values Is \(X + Y > 0\)? Is \(Y > 0\)?
\(X=2, Y=1\) \(2+1 = 3 > 0\) (Yes) \(1 > 0\) (Yes)
\(X=3, Y=-1\) \(3+(-1) = 2 > 0\) (Yes) \(-1 > 0\) (No)

In the first example, \(Y\) is positive. In the second example, \(Y\) is negative. Since we can find cases where \(Y > 0\) is true and cases where \(Y > 0\) is false, Statement 1 alone is not sufficient to answer the question.

Checking Statement 2 Alone

Statement 2 says \(X - Y > 0\). This means X is greater than Y, or \(X > Y\).

Let's test some values for X and Y that satisfy this condition and see if Y must be greater than 0.

Example Values Is \(X - Y > 0\)? Is \(Y > 0\)?
\(X=3, Y=1\) \(3-1 = 2 > 0\) (Yes) \(1 > 0\) (Yes)
\(X=1, Y=-2\) \(1-(-2) = 3 > 0\) (Yes) \(-2 > 0\) (No)

In the first example, \(Y\) is positive. In the second example, \(Y\) is negative. Since we can find cases where \(Y > 0\) is true and cases where \(Y > 0\) is false, Statement 2 alone is not sufficient to answer the question.

Combining Statements 1 and 2 for Sufficiency

Now, let's assume both statements are true:

  1. \(X + Y > 0\)
  2. \(X - Y > 0\)

We can add these two inequalities together:

\((X + Y) + (X - Y) > 0 + 0\)

\(2X > 0\)

Dividing by 2 (a positive number), we get \(X > 0\). So, if both statements are true, X must be positive.

From Statement 2, we also know \(X > Y\).

So, we know \(X\) is positive and \(X\) is greater than \(Y\). Does this guarantee that \(Y\) is positive?

Let's test some values that satisfy both \(X > 0\) and \(X > Y\), and also satisfy the original statements:

Example Values Is \(X + Y > 0\)? Is \(X - Y > 0\)? Is \(Y > 0\)?
\(X=2, Y=1\) \(2+1 = 3 > 0\) (Yes) \(2-1 = 1 > 0\) (Yes) \(1 > 0\) (Yes)
\(X=2, Y=0\) \(2+0 = 2 > 0\) (Yes) \(2-0 = 2 > 0\) (Yes) \(0 > 0\) (No)
\(X=2, Y=-1\) \(2+(-1) = 1 > 0\) (Yes) \(2-(-1) = 3 > 0\) (Yes) \(-1 > 0\) (No)

We found examples where both statements are true, and \(Y\) can be positive (\(Y=1\)), zero (\(Y=0\)), or negative (\(Y=-1\)). Since \(Y\) can be positive or not positive while satisfying both statements, the statements together are not sufficient to answer the question definitively.

Conclusion on Data Sufficiency

Based on our analysis:

  • Statement 1 alone is not sufficient.
  • Statement 2 alone is not sufficient.
  • Statements 1 and 2 together are not sufficient.

Therefore, neither statement alone nor both statements together are sufficient to answer the question "Is \(Y > 0\)?".

Revision Table: Evaluating Sufficiency

Condition Sufficient? Reason
Statement 1 Alone No \(Y\) can be positive or negative while \(X+Y > 0\).
Statement 2 Alone No \(Y\) can be positive or negative while \(X-Y > 0\).
Statements 1 & 2 Together No Combining statements gives \(X > 0\) and \(X > Y\), but \(Y\) can still be positive, zero, or negative.

Additional Information on Inequalities

Inequalities are mathematical statements that compare two expressions using symbols like \( > \) (greater than), \( < \) (less than), \( \ge \) (greater than or equal to), or \( \le \) (less than or equal to).

When working with inequalities:

  • You can add or subtract the same number or expression from both sides without changing the direction of the inequality. For example, if \(a > b\), then \(a+c > b+c\).
  • You can multiply or divide both sides by the same positive number without changing the direction of the inequality. For example, if \(a > b\) and \(c > 0\), then \(ac > bc\).
  • If you multiply or divide both sides by a negative number, you must reverse the direction of the inequality. For example, if \(a > b\) and \(c < 0\), then \(ac < bc\).
  • Adding two inequalities: If \(a > b\) and \(c > d\), then \(a+c > b+d\). This is what we did when combining the two statements in the problem.

Data Sufficiency problems often require you to explore different cases or use properties of numbers and inequalities to determine if a definitive answer is possible.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. In a certain code language,
    A + B means 'A is the mother of B',
    A - B means 'A is the brother of B',
    A \(\times\) B means 'A is the wife of B' and
    A \(\div\) B means 'A is the father of B'.
    Based on the above, how is Q related to T if 'P \(\times\) Q \(\div\) R - S + T'?
  2. In a certain code language, 
    'A × B' means 'A is the son of B', 
    'A - B' means 'A is the brother of B', 
    'A + B' means 'A is the wife of B' and 
    'A % B' means 'A is the father of B'. 
    How is M related to T if 'M × N % P + S - T'?

  3. If X's mother is the only daughter of Y's father, then Y's husband's father is X's ________.
  4. In a certain code language,

    A + B means ‘A is the mother of B’

    A – B means ‘A is the brother of B’

    A × B means ‘A is the wife of B’

    A ÷ B means ‘A is the father of B’

    A # B means ‘A is the daughter of B’

    How is P related to K if ‘Q – R × P ÷ S – T + K’?

  5. In a certain code language,

    ‘A + B’ means ‘A is the mother of B’,
    ‘A − B’ means ‘A is the brother of B’,
    ‘A × B’ means ‘A is the wife of B’ and
    ‘A ÷ B’ means ‘A is the father of B’.

    How is M related to T if ‘M ÷ N × P − S + T’?

  6. In a certain code language,
    ‘A + B’ means ‘A is the mother of B’,
    ‘A - B’ means ‘A is the brother of B’,
    ‘A × B’ means ‘A is the wife of B’ and
    ‘A & B’ means ‘A is the father of B’.
    How is E related to T if ‘E & F + G – H × T’?

  7. C said to D, "You are my sister's husband's mother-in-law." How is D related to C?

  8. In a certain code language,
    'S + T' means 'S is the father of T',
    'S - T' means 'S is the brother of T',
    'S x T' means 'S is the wife of T' and
    'S ÷ T' means 'S is the sister of T'.
    Based on the above, how is M related to Q if 'M - N ÷ O + P x Q'?
  9. In a certain code language,
    'A - B' means 'A is the daughter of B',
    'A / B' means 'A is the son of B',
    'A * B' means 'A is the wife of B' and
    'A + B' means 'A is the husband of B'.
    Based on the above, how is T related to Z if 'T / L + H - Z'?
  10. In a certain code language,

    'A + B' means 'A is the mother of B',

    'A - B' means 'A is the brother of B',

    'A x B' means 'A is the wife of B' and

    'A ÷ B' means 'A is the father of B'.

    How is M related to T if 'M - N + P ÷ S x T'?


Important Questions from Blood Relations

  1. In a certain code language,
    A + B means 'A is the mother of B',
    A - B means 'A is the brother of B',
    A \(\times\) B means 'A is the wife of B' and
    A \(\div\) B means 'A is the father of B'.
    Based on the above, how is Q related to T if 'P \(\times\) Q \(\div\) R - S + T'?
  2. A is the father of H. H is the father of G. G is the son of E. F is the father of E. How is A related to F?
  3. In a certain code language,
    A + B means 'A is the son of B',
    A - B means 'A is the sister of B',
    A $\times$ B means 'A is the wife of B' and
    A $\div$ B means 'A is the father of B'.


    How is Q related to D if 'Q $\div$ E - R $\times$ C + D'?

  4. K is the son of I. I is the father of L. L is the mother of O. O is the brother of S. How is K related to O?
  5. In a certain code language,
    A + B means 'A is the daughter of B',
    A - B means 'A is the wife of B',
    A $\times$ B means 'A is the father of B' and
    A $\div$ B means 'A is the brother of B'.
    How is A related to S if 'A + E - F $\times$ N \(\div\) S'?

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB Paramedical
November 23, 2026
Test Series
RRB ALP img
Railways
RRB ALP 2026 Mock Test series
1035 Tests 1 Tests Free
1766 Attempts
4.3(258)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App