All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Why is the net magnetic flux through any closed surface always zero?

This question was previously asked in
RRB JE 2025 CBT 2 Mechanical and Allied Engg Question Paper English (2-Jul-2026) (Shift-1)
The correct answer is

Magnetic monopoles do not exist

This result is known as Gauss's Law for Magnetism, and it is one of the four fundamental Maxwell's equations that govern classical electromagnetism. In integral form it is written as:

∮ B · dA = 0

This states that the net magnetic flux through any closed surface (a \"Gaussian surface\") is always zero, no matter what shape the surface has or where it is placed — inside a magnet, around a solenoid, or in free space.

The physical reason behind this is that magnetic monopoles do not exist in nature. Every magnetic field line is a closed loop: outside a magnet it runs from the North pole to the South pole, and it continues inside the magnet from the South pole back to the North pole, forming a continuous loop with no beginning or end. Because of this, for any closed surface you draw, every field line that enters the surface at one point must also leave it at another point. The \"incoming\" flux and the \"outgoing\" flux always cancel exactly, making the net flux zero.

This is fundamentally different from the electric case. Gauss's Law for electricity states ∮ E · dA = Qenclosed/ε₀, which is generally not zero whenever a net electric charge is enclosed, because isolated positive and negative electric charges (monopole-like sources) genuinely exist and electric field lines can start or end on them.

Now consider why the other explanations fail:

  • The claim that magnetic field lines are straight is incorrect — field lines around a bar magnet or current loop are curved, forming closed loops, not straight lines.
  • The idea that electric charges cancel the magnetic field has no physical basis; electric charge and magnetic flux are governed by separate Maxwell's equations and one does not cancel the other.
  • The strength (weakness) of a magnetic field has nothing to do with whether the net flux through a closed surface is zero — even a very strong magnet obeys ∮ B · dA = 0, because the zero result comes from the topology of field lines (closed loops), not from field magnitude.

Thus, the absence of magnetic monopoles is the correct and complete explanation, and this law also forms the theoretical basis for the statement \"isolated magnetic poles do not exist\" often taught in basic magnetism.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. What happens to the magnetic field around a straight current-carrying conductor when the current through it is increased?

  2. Which statement about magnetic flux is false?

  3. Retentivity in a B-H curve indicates:

Important Questions from Magnetism and Maxwell's Equations

  1. The instrument that is based on the principle that when an electric current flows in a coil placed in a magnetic field, a deflecting torque acts upon the coil is:

  2. Identify which of the following expressions is not Maxwell’s equation for time-varying fields.

  3. Which of the following materials is used for the generation of ultrasonic waves by using magnetostriction effect?

  4. A magnetic field of 3.6T is applied to a paramagnetic gas. The atoms of the gas have magnetic dipole moment of 4.5 × 10-23 J/T. At what temperature, will the mean translation kinetic energy kinetic energy of an atom of the gas be equal to the energy required to change the alignment of atom’s magnetic dipole form antiparallel to parallel (to the magnetic field) (Boltzmann constant = 1.38 × 10-23 J/K)

  5. The Curie temperature for cobalt is:

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
RRB JE img
Railways
RRB JE (CBT 1 + CBT 2) 2026 Mock Test Series
1515 Tests 19 Tests Free
1826 Attempts
4.3(163)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App