All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

But for one witness the accused ought to have been sent to jail.

This question was previously asked in
CDS I 2017 General Knowledge Previous Year Paper (05-Feb-2017)
The correct answer is

Would have

Sentence Improvement with "But For" and Conditionals

The question asks us to find the best substitution for the underlined phrase "ought to have been sent" in the sentence: "But for one witness the accused ought to have been sent to jail." We need to understand the meaning of the original sentence and how each option changes it.

The original sentence describes a situation where the accused was not sent to jail, and the presence of one witness is presented as the reason for this outcome.

Understanding the Phrase "But For"

The phrase "But for" is a conjunction that means "except for" or "if... had not happened". It introduces a condition that prevented something else from occurring. In this sentence, "But for one witness" means "If that one witness had not been present" or "Except for the presence of one witness". It sets up a counterfactual situation (what would have happened if the witness hadn't been there).

Analyzing the Original Phrase: "ought to have been sent"

The phrase "ought to have been sent" uses the modal verb structure "ought to have" + past participle. This structure is typically used to express:

  • A past obligation or duty that was not fulfilled.
  • Something that was expected or considered right to happen in the past, but did not happen.

So, "the accused ought to have been sent to jail" implies that, according to some standard of justice or expectation, sending the accused to jail was the right course of action, but it didn't happen. When used with "But for one witness," the original sentence suggests that because of the witness, the right thing (sending to jail) did not happen.

Evaluating the Options for Sentence Improvement

Let's examine how each given option functions when it replaces the underlined part in the sentence "But for one witness, the accused ______ to jail."

Option (a): Would have

Substituting "would have" gives: "But for one witness, the accused would have been sent to jail."

This structure, "But for X, Y would have happened," is a standard way to express a past counterfactual conditional. It means "If X had not happened, Y would have happened." This structure clearly states that the presence of the witness (X) prevented the accused being sent to jail (Y) from happening. This fits the likely intended meaning of the sentence: the witness's testimony or presence saved the accused from going to jail.

Option (b): Had

Substituting "Had" gives: "But for one witness, the accused had been sent to jail."

The past perfect tense ("had been sent") describes an action completed before another point in the past. Using it directly after "But for" in this context is grammatically incorrect and illogical. It does not fit the structure needed to express a consequence that was prevented by the witness.

Option (c): Should have

Substituting "Should have" gives: "But for one witness, the accused should have been sent to jail."

Similar to "ought to have," "should have" + past participle expresses a past expectation or moral obligation that wasn't met. While it conveys that sending the accused to jail was the appropriate outcome, it doesn't form the most natural or standard conditional structure when used with "But for". The phrase "But for X" usually sets up a consequence using "would have," describing what was likely or certain to happen but was prevented, rather than what was morally required or expected.

Option (d): No improvement

Option (a) "Would have" provides a grammatically correct and idiomatic structure ("But for X, Y would have happened") that precisely conveys the sense that the witness's presence prevented the accused from being sent to jail. This is a clear improvement over the original sentence's less common phrasing for this type of conditional.

Conclusion on Sentence Improvement

The structure "But for X, Y would have happened" is the conventional way to express that past condition X prevented past outcome Y. Option (a) "Would have" correctly completes this structure, making the sentence grammatically sound and clear. Options (b) and (c) do not fit this standard conditional pattern as well as (a).

Revision Table: Comparing Conditional Structures

Structure Meaning Example
But for X, Y would have + past participle. If X had not existed/happened, Y would have happened. (X was a necessary condition to prevent Y) But for the doctor's quick action, he would have died.
Ought to have + past participle Something was expected/right but didn't happen in the past. You ought to have called me earlier.
Should have + past participle Something was expected/right but didn't happen in the past (often interchangeable with ought to have). They should have informed us.

Additional Information: "But For" and Past Conditionals

The phrase "But for" is a type of prepositional phrase that functions like a conditional clause, often introducing a condition that contrasts with reality. When used to refer to a past situation that prevented a result, it pairs naturally with the perfect conditional tense ("would have" + past participle) in the main clause.

Consider these examples:

  • "But for your help, I would have failed." (Reality: You helped. Counterfactual: If you hadn't helped, I would have failed.)
  • "But for the traffic, we would have arrived on time." (Reality: There was traffic. Counterfactual: If there hadn't been traffic, we would have arrived on time.)

In the question, "But for one witness" sets up the counterfactual situation where the witness was absent. The consequence of that absence, expressed by "would have been sent," is the likely outcome if the preventing condition (the witness) hadn't existed. This structure is clear and standard English grammar.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    Go north-east across the mountains till you will reach an island.

  2. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    It is hard these days to cope with the rising prices.

  3. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    He took a loan of hundred rupees from me.

  4. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    From the last five days, it has been raining torrentially.

  5. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence is given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    The teacher, along with her three children, were taken to hospital.

  6. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    The Prime Minister had wide-ranging discussions on the international situation.

  7. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    The man disappeared after he was rescuing a boy from drowning.
  8. Direction: Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the bold/underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    I shall be obliged if youcould grantme an interview.

  9. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    By 8.00 in the morning he wrote four letters to his friends.

  10. Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response against the corresponding letter. If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response.

    He is now looking about a job.


Important Questions from Phrase Replacement

  1. Select the most appropriate word to substitute the underlined word of the given sentence. If no substitution is required, select ‘No improvement’.

    There is a great degrade in value s in modern age.

  2. Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence.

    No effort has been made by the Indian cricket team to cash off on its vibrant image in the World Cup. 

  3. Directions: Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence. If there is no need to substitute it, select ‘No improvement’.

    As many as I care for her, I still have to disagree with her on this topic.

  4. Directions: Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence. If there is no need to substitute it, select ‘No improvement’.

    Prithvi likes baseball as long as she likes cricket.

  5. Directions: Select the most appropriate option to substitute the underlined segment in the given sentence. If there is no need to substitute it, select ‘No improvement’.

    As long to funding is not made available, our construction dreams have been deferred.

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
CDS img
Defence
UPSC CDS 2026 Mock Test Series
559 Tests 4 Tests Free
1842 Attempts
4.3(195)
English, Hindi
More Questions from CDS

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App