Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumption(s) is (are) implicit. Statement: Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”. Assumptions: 1. Gita likes to travel to Sri Lanka. 2. Shyam is fond of advising people.
Neither assumption 1 nor 2 is implicit
This question asks us to analyze a given statement and determine which of the provided assumptions are implicit, meaning they are implied or understood without being directly stated in the statement.
Understanding Statement and Assumptions
In logical reasoning, a 'statement' is a piece of information given, and an 'assumption' is something that is taken for granted or supposed to be true while making the statement. We need to find which assumptions are logically required for the statement to be made.
Analyzing the Statement: Ways to Reach Sri Lanka
The statement is: "Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”."
This statement simply provides information about the available modes of transport to reach Sri Lanka. It lists two specific ways: by air and by water.
Evaluating Assumption 1: Gita's Travel Interest
Assumption 1 states: "Gita likes to travel to Sri Lanka."
Let's consider if this assumption is implicit in Shyam's statement. Shyam is telling Gita about the ways to reach Sri Lanka. Does this necessarily mean Gita likes or wants to travel there? Not necessarily. Shyam might be providing this information for various reasons:
- Gita might have asked for the information because she is planning a trip.
- Gita might have asked out of general curiosity.
- Shyam might be sharing general geographical or travel information.
- They might be discussing travel in general.
The statement itself only conveys the information about travel modes. It doesn't provide any insight into Gita's feelings or desires regarding traveling to Sri Lanka. Therefore, we cannot assume that Gita likes to travel there based solely on this statement.
Assumption 1 is not implicit.
Evaluating Assumption 2: Shyam's Fondness for Advising
Assumption 2 states: "Shyam is fond of advising people."
Shyam telling Gita the ways to reach Sri Lanka is an act of providing information. Is this single instance sufficient to conclude that Shyam is "fond of advising people" in general? Being 'fond of' something suggests a habitual tendency or enjoyment in doing it. A single instance of giving information does not automatically establish a general trait like being fond of advising. Shyam might have given this information because he was asked, because it came up in conversation, or for any other reason specific to this interaction.
We cannot infer a general personality trait or hobby of Shyam from this one statement. Therefore, we cannot assume that Shyam is fond of advising people based solely on this statement.
Assumption 2 is not implicit.
Conclusion on Implicit Assumptions
Based on the analysis of both assumptions, neither Assumption 1 (Gita likes to travel to Sri Lanka) nor Assumption 2 (Shyam is fond of advising people) is implicit in the statement "Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”". The statement is a simple factual statement about travel methods, and it does not logically depend on either of these assumptions being true.
Identifying Implicit Assumptions
When solving Statement and Assumption questions, ask yourself: "Does the statement make sense *without* this assumption?" If the statement still holds true or is reasonable even if the assumption is false, then the assumption is NOT implicit. If the statement *requires* the assumption to be true to be meaningful or logical in its context, then the assumption IS implicit.
- For Assumption 1: Does the statement require Gita to like traveling to Sri Lanka? No. Shyam can tell her the ways regardless of her travel preferences.
- For Assumption 2: Does the statement require Shyam to be fond of advising? No. Shyam can provide this information for many reasons other than being fond of advising.
Revision Table: Statement and Assumption Analysis
| Statement | Assumption | Is it Implicit? | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”. | Gita likes to travel to Sri Lanka. | No | The statement gives travel information; it doesn't reveal Gita's preferences or interests in traveling to Sri Lanka. |
| Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”. | Shyam is fond of advising people. | No | A single instance of providing information does not prove a general tendency or fondness for advising people. |
Additional Information: Types of Assumptions in Reasoning
Understanding different types of assumptions can help in reasoning questions:
- Necessary Assumption: An assumption that *must* be true for the conclusion to hold. If the assumption is false, the conclusion falls apart.
- Sufficient Assumption: An assumption that, if true, *guarantees* the conclusion is true. It might not be the only assumption needed, but it's enough on its own (or with the given premises).
- Implicit Assumption: An assumption that is not explicitly stated but is understood or implied by the context of the statement. This is what is typically tested in Statement and Assumption questions. The statement relies on these unstated premises to be meaningful.
In this question, we were looking for implicit assumptions that the statement relies upon. As we found, neither assumption provided is necessary for the statement to be made or understood.
Similar Questions
One statement is given followed by two assumptions, I & II. You have to consider the statement to be true, even if it seems to be at variance from commonly known facts. You are to decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the given statement.
Statement: Teachers should never scold students who make repeated mistakes.
Assumptions:
I. Students do not make repeated mistakes intentionally.
II. Negative reinforcements are NOT a good method to improve student performance.Given below is a statement followed by two assumptions numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement: College students should work during summer holidays to improve their chances of getting a job.
Assumption I: Not all college students want a job.
Assumption II: There are enough summer jobs for most college students.Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
Honesty is the best policy.
Assumptions:
I)Honest people are policy makers.
II)Each policy must contain honesty.
Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
Teachers must attend workshop.
Assumptions:
Workshop updates teachers.
Workshops kill time.Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the argument.
Argument:
The campaign ‘Swachh Bharat’, to keep one's cities clean, started by the apartment association, didn’t bring much of a response from its residents.
Assumptions:
1. The residents do not wish to keep their apartment clean.
2. The association head failed in the campaign.Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/re implicit.
Argument:
Public smoking is an offence under the law.
Assumption:
- Smoking is injurious to the health of the person who smoke.
- Smoke is injurious even to others health in the public places.
Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit
Argument:
The BEST bus travels company has decided to increase its fare by 10%.
Assumptions:
1. Passengers may opt for other buses costing less than the BEST bus travels company.
2. The demand for the buses by some passengers may remain unchanged even after the fare hike.Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
Due to the water crisis in the city, the authority had asked all the citizens to reduce their water consumption by 25%.
Assumptions:
1. Many citizens may reduce their water consumption.
2. Many activists may protest to this advisory by the authority.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
All girls love reading novels.
Assumptions:
1. Novels are the only reading materials.
2. No girl loves to read other materials.
One statement is given, followed by two assumptions, I & II. You have to consider the statement to be true, even if it seems to be at variance from commonly known facts. You are to decide which of the given assumptions can definitely be drawn from the given statement.
Statement: “You are appointed as a trainee accountant on temporary basis. Your employment status will automatically be converted to permanent on submission of pass result of M Com final exam." — Extract from an appointment letter.
Assumptions:
I. M Com final exam is a reasonable proof of an accountant's capability.
II. All trainees are appointed on temporary basis.
Important Questions from Statements and Assumptions
Direction: A statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered I and II. Assuming that the given statement is true even if it seems to be at variance from commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the given statement.
Statement:
In a football match between Team-X and Team-Y, the total number of goals scored by Team-Y was 5, out of which 3 goals were scored by the left footed player.
Assumption:
I. The left-footed player was adept at scoring goals.
II. 60% of the players in Team Y are left footed.
Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is implicit in the statement.
statement:
P advised Q, "Go to Mumbai via Jaipur ____ the shortest route"
Assumptions: I. P advises everybody.
II. Q wishes to go to Mumbai.
Read the given statement and assumptions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statement is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given assumptions logically follow(s) from the statement.
Statement:
During exams, invigilators are not supposed to use mobile phones in the examination hall.
Assumptions:
I. Mobile disturbs students during examination.
II. Keeping mobiles switched off helps to improve their vigilance.
Consider the given statements and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
To expand their business, a budding company now requires more staff.
Assumptions:
I: The current staff is incompetent.
II: Business can only be expanded by always hiring new staff.
Read the given statement and conclusions carefully and decide which of the assumptions is implicit in the statement.
Statement:
"SAVE MONEY - BUY 1 GET 3" — Advertisement by a commercial brand.
Assumptions:
1. Brand sales increased profusely after the offer.
2. People are more attracted to buy if they are offered more than what they are already paying.
