Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit. Argument: All girls love reading novels. Assumptions: 1. Novels are the only reading materials. 2. No girl loves to read other materials.
Neither assumption 1 nor 2 is implicit.
Analyzing Argument Assumptions: Girls and Novels
Let's break down the given argument and the assumptions to determine which assumptions are considered implicit in the argument.
Understanding the Argument and Assumptions
The argument presented is:
- Argument: All girls love reading novels.
The assumptions to consider are:
- Assumption 1: Novels are the only reading materials.
- Assumption 2: No girl loves to read other materials.
What is an Implicit Assumption?
In logic and critical reasoning, an implicit assumption is a premise that is not explicitly stated in an argument but is necessary for the conclusion to be true or for the argument to make sense. If an assumption can be false while the argument still holds true, then that assumption is not implicit.
Analyzing Assumption 1: Are Novels the Only Reading Materials?
The argument "All girls love reading novels" makes a statement about the reading preference of girls towards novels. It claims that every single girl has a love for reading novels. However, this statement doesn't say anything about what other types of reading materials might exist in the world.
- Could other reading materials like magazines, newspapers, or textbooks exist? Yes, the argument doesn't contradict this.
- If other reading materials exist, does it make the statement "All girls love reading novels" false? Not necessarily. The existence of other materials is irrelevant to whether or not all girls love novels.
Since the argument "All girls love reading novels" can be true even if novels are *not* the only reading materials, Assumption 1 is not a necessary underlying condition for the argument. Therefore, Assumption 1 is not implicit.
Analyzing Assumption 2: Do Girls Only Love Novels?
The argument states that "All girls love reading novels." This is a statement about one specific thing that girls love. It does not claim that novels are the *only* thing they love to read, or the *only* thing they love in general.
- Consider a scenario where a girl loves reading novels and also loves reading poetry. Does this make the statement "All girls love reading novels" false for that girl? No, she still fits the criteria of loving novels.
- The argument is simply saying that for every girl, the condition "loves reading novels" is true. It doesn't impose any condition on what else they might love to read.
Since the argument "All girls love reading novels" can be true even if girls love to read *other* materials as well, Assumption 2 is not a necessary underlying condition for the argument. Therefore, Assumption 2 is not implicit.
Conclusion on Implicit Assumptions
Based on the analysis, neither Assumption 1 nor Assumption 2 is required for the argument "All girls love reading novels" to be valid or true. The argument focuses specifically on girls' love for novels and doesn't depend on novels being the only reading material or on girls not loving other materials.
Therefore, neither assumption is implicit in the given argument.
Argument Assumptions Revision Table
| Assumption | Statement | Implicit? | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assumption 1 | Novels are the only reading materials. | No | The argument is about girls loving novels, not about the total list of reading materials available. The argument can be true even if other materials exist. |
| Assumption 2 | No girl loves to read other materials. | No | The argument states girls love novels. It doesn't preclude them from also loving other reading materials. The argument can be true even if girls love other things. |
Additional Information on Logical Reasoning and Assumptions
When evaluating arguments and identifying implicit assumptions, it's important to distinguish between what the argument *states* and what it *implies* or *requires*. An implicit assumption is something that *must* be true for the argument to logically follow or make sense as presented.
- Scope of Statements: A universal statement like "All A are B" only makes a claim about all members of group A having property B. It does not typically make claims about group B (e.g., that only A's are B) or about what else members of A might be or do.
- Necessary vs. Possible: An implicit assumption is *necessary* for the argument. If something is merely *possible* or *consistent* with the argument but not required, it is not an implicit assumption.
In this case, the argument is a simple statement about a group's preference. Assumptions that restrict possibilities not mentioned in the argument (like restricting other reading materials or other reading loves) are generally not implicit unless the argument structure strictly demands it.
Similar Questions
Consider the argument and decide which of the given assumptions is/are implicit.
Argument:
Due to potholes in the city a large number of people are unable to reach the airport on time.
Assumptions:
1. Reaching the airport on time is not necessary.
2. There is no other route to the airport.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
In City X, people prefer to buy Honda bikes instead of Bajaj, as Honda Company brings in Japanese technology.
Assumptions:
1. If Bajaj used Japanese technology, then its sales also would be on a par with Honda Company.
2. Bikes with Japanese technology are preferred to other bikes in City X.
Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the assumptions is implicit from the statement.
Statement:
The price of onion and tomato had remained unchanged for the past 2 weeks in Delhi.
Assumptions:
1. Onion and tomato price had changed elsewhere in this 2 weeks.
2. The prices of onion and tomato 2 weeks ago were different from their present prices.
Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit.
Statement:
A leading school in Mumbai will increase its fees by 150% from the next academic year.
Assumptions:
1. Students may change school due to more fees.
2. The school may still have the same demand among the students.
Consider the given statement to be true and decide which of the following assumptions is/are implicit in the statement.
Statement:
Company X announced that in their company, 10 clerical jobs will be filled, with the minimum eligibility criteria being bachelor's degree pass.
Assumptions:
1. Those who have passed the bachelor's degree can apply.
2. Masters can also apply.
Consider the given statement true and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Statement:
A teacher tells a student, “if you don’t finish your homework, you will not be allowed into the class”.
Assumptions:
1. Discipline is a way to create effective learning.
2. The teacher will be happy not to have a student who is not punctual in his work.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
Due to the water crisis in the city, the authority had asked all the citizens to reduce their water consumption by 25%.
Assumptions:
1. Many citizens may reduce their water consumption.
2. Many activists may protest to this advisory by the authority.
Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumption(s) is (are) implicit.
Statement:
Shyam tells Gita, “The ways to reach Sri Lanka is through air and water”.
Assumptions:
1. Gita likes to travel to Sri Lanka.
2. Shyam is fond of advising people.
Consider the given argument and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Argument:
“A visit of school students to botanical garden to widen their knowledge of natural resources has been arranged” - a message on the notice board in the school.
Assumptions:
1. Botanical gardens are full of natural resources.
2. School students are likely to understand more through interaction with the new environment.
One statement is given, followed by two assumptions, I & II. You have to consider the statement to be true, even if it seems to be at variance from commonly known facts. You are to decide which of the given assumptions can definitely be drawn from the given statement.
Statement: “You are appointed as a trainee accountant on temporary basis. Your employment status will automatically be converted to permanent on submission of pass result of M Com final exam." — Extract from an appointment letter.
Assumptions:
I. M Com final exam is a reasonable proof of an accountant's capability.
II. All trainees are appointed on temporary basis.
Important Questions from Statements and Assumptions
You have to decide which of these assumptions is/are implicit in the statement, considering the statement and the assumptions that follow it.
Statement:
I like the soldiers.
I want to become a soldier.
Assumptions:
I) I am not a soldier.
II) I am a soldier.
Read the following passages and answer the question follows. Your answers to these items should be based on the passages only.
Many people in India feel that if we cut our defence expenditure on weapon-building, we can create a climate of peace with our neighbours, subsequently reducing the conflict or creating a no-war situation. People who proclaim such ideas are either the victims of war or the propagators of false argument.
With reference to the above passage, which of the following is the most valid assumption?
Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is (are) implicit.
Statement :
“Successful people are happy in life."
Assumptions :
1. Those that are unhappy are not successful
2. Most of the times success in one’s endeavours gives happiness.
In this question, a statement is followed by two assumptions:
Statements: Though he is fat yet he runs fast.
Assumptions:
I. Fat people have weak muscles.
II. Fat people generally cannot run fast.
Then which of the answer is correct?
Consider the given statement and decide which of the given assumptions is implicit in the statement.
Statement:
Television is correctly called the Idiot box.
Assumptions:
1. People who watch television are idiots.
2. People who do not watch television are intelligent.
