All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

15 pipes, each having the same diameter, can fill a cistern in 12 minutes. How long will it take for 6 pipes, each with double the original diameter, to fill the same cistern at the same speed of the flow?

This question was previously asked in
RRB ALP/Technician 2018 CBT 2 Electronics Mechanic Question Paper (23-Jan-2019) (Shift 1)
The correct answer is

7.5 minutes

Problem Analysis: Cistern Filling with Pipes

The question asks us to find the time it takes for a certain number of pipes with a different diameter to fill the same cistern, given the time it takes for a different number of pipes with the original diameter. The key factors are the number of pipes, their diameter, and the flow speed, which is stated to be the same.

The rate at which a pipe fills a cistern (its flow rate) depends on the cross-sectional area of the pipe and the speed of the fluid flow. Since the speed of flow is constant, the flow rate of a single pipe is proportional to its cross-sectional area. The cross-sectional area of a circular pipe is given by the formula for the area of a circle, which is $\pi r^2$ or $\pi (d/2)^2 = \frac{\pi d^2}{4}$, where $r$ is the radius and $d$ is the diameter.

This means the flow rate is proportional to the square of the pipe's diameter ($d^2$).

Understanding Pipe Flow Rate and Diameter

Let $d_1$ be the original diameter of the pipes.

The area of an original pipe is $A_1 = \frac{\pi d_1^2}{4}$.

The flow rate of one original pipe, $R_1$, is proportional to $A_1$. We can write $R_1 = k \cdot A_1 = k \cdot \frac{\pi d_1^2}{4}$ for some constant $k$ (related to flow speed and $\pi/4$). For simplicity in proportional calculations, we can just say $R_1 \propto d_1^2$. Let's assume $R_1$ is just proportional to $d_1^2$, so $R_1 = c \cdot d_1^2$ for some constant $c$.

Original Setup: 15 Pipes

Number of pipes = 15.

Diameter = $d_1$.

Flow rate per pipe = $R_1 = c \cdot d_1^2$.

Total flow rate for 15 pipes = $15 \times R_1 = 15 \times c \cdot d_1^2$.

Time taken to fill the cistern = 12 minutes.

Let $V$ be the volume of the cistern.

The relationship between volume, total flow rate, and time is: Volume = Total Flow Rate × Time.

So, $V = (15 \times c \cdot d_1^2) \times 12 = 180 \times c \cdot d_1^2$.

New Setup: 6 Pipes with Double Diameter

Number of pipes = 6.

New diameter, $d_2$, is double the original diameter, so $d_2 = 2d_1$.

The flow rate of one new pipe, $R_2$, is proportional to the square of the new diameter, $d_2^2$.

$R_2 = c \cdot d_2^2 = c \cdot (2d_1)^2 = c \cdot (4d_1^2) = 4 \times (c \cdot d_1^2) = 4 \times R_1$.

So, one new pipe has a flow rate 4 times that of an original pipe because its diameter is double (and area is proportional to diameter squared, $2^2=4$).

Total flow rate for 6 new pipes = $6 \times R_2 = 6 \times (4 \times R_1) = 24 \times R_1$.

Calculating Time for 6 Pipes

Let $T$ be the time taken for the 6 new pipes to fill the same cistern.

Using the formula Volume = Total Flow Rate × Time:

$V = (24 \times R_1) \times T$.

We know from the original setup that $V = 180 \times R_1$.

So, we can equate the two expressions for $V$:

$180 \times R_1 = 24 \times R_1 \times T$.

We can divide both sides by $R_1$ (since $R_1$ is a flow rate, it's not zero):

$180 = 24 \times T$.

Now, solve for $T$:

$T = \frac{180}{24}$.

Step-by-Step Calculation

  1. Understand that the flow rate of a pipe is proportional to the square of its diameter. If diameter doubles, flow rate increases by $2^2 = 4$ times.
  2. Calculate the effective total flow rate for the original setup: 15 pipes × Rate of one original pipe. Let the rate of one original pipe be $R$. Total original rate = $15R$.
  3. Calculate the total volume of the cistern: Volume = Total original rate × Time = $15R \times 12 = 180R$.
  4. Calculate the rate of one new pipe: Diameter is double ($2d$), so rate is $4 \times R = 4R$.
  5. Calculate the effective total flow rate for the new setup: 6 pipes × Rate of one new pipe = $6 \times 4R = 24R$.
  6. Calculate the time taken for the new pipes: Time = Volume / New total rate = $\frac{180R}{24R}$.
  7. Simplify the expression to find the time: $\frac{180}{24} = \frac{30 \times 6}{4 \times 6} = \frac{30}{4} = \frac{15 \times 2}{2 \times 2} = \frac{15}{2} = 7.5$ minutes.

Detailed Calculation Steps

Original Number of pipes $N_1 = 15$. Original Diameter $D_1$. Time $T_1 = 12$ minutes.

Flow rate per original pipe $R_1 \propto D_1^2$.

Total flow rate $F_1 = N_1 \times R_1 = 15 \times R_1$.

Volume of cistern $V = F_1 \times T_1 = 15 \times R_1 \times 12 = 180 R_1$.

New Number of pipes $N_2 = 6$. New Diameter $D_2 = 2 D_1$.

Flow rate per new pipe $R_2 \propto D_2^2 = (2 D_1)^2 = 4 D_1^2$. So, $R_2 = 4 R_1$.

Total flow rate $F_2 = N_2 \times R_2 = 6 \times (4 R_1) = 24 R_1$.

Time taken $T_2 = \frac{V}{F_2} = \frac{180 R_1}{24 R_1}$.

$T_2 = \frac{180}{24} = \frac{15 \times 12}{2 \times 12} = \frac{15}{2} = 7.5$ minutes.

Conclusion on Cistern Filling Time

Based on the calculation, it will take 7.5 minutes for 6 pipes, each with double the original diameter, to fill the same cistern at the same speed of flow.

Revision Table: Pipes and Cistern Filling

ParameterOriginal SetupNew Setup
Number of pipes156
Diameter$D$$2D$
Flow Rate per Pipe (proportional to Diameter$^2$)$R \propto D^2$$R' \propto (2D)^2 = 4D^2 \implies R' = 4R$
Total Flow Rate$15 \times R$$6 \times R' = 6 \times 4R = 24R$
Time Taken12 minutes$T$ minutes
Volume Filled (Total Flow Rate $\times$ Time)$15R \times 12 = 180R$$24R \times T$
Equating Volume$180R = 24R \times T$
Solving for $T$$T = \frac{180R}{24R} = \frac{180}{24} = 7.5$ minutes

Additional Information: Work Rate Problems Explained

Problems involving multiple entities working together to complete a task, like pipes filling a cistern or workers building a wall, are known as work rate problems. The fundamental principle is that the total amount of work done is equal to the rate of work multiplied by the time taken.

  • Work = Rate × Time

In this specific problem:

  • The "work" is filling the cistern, which has a fixed volume $V$.
  • The "workers" are the pipes.
  • The "rate" is the flow rate of the pipes. The total rate is the sum of the rates of all active pipes.

When dealing with pipes, the rate of a single pipe is determined by its capacity (cross-sectional area) and the speed of the fluid. Assuming constant speed, the rate is proportional to the area ($\pi r^2$ or $\pi d^2/4$). Thus, Rate $\propto$ Diameter$^2$. This square relationship is crucial in solving problems where pipe diameters change.

If you have $N$ identical pipes, the total rate is $N$ times the rate of a single pipe. If the pipes are not identical (like having different diameters), you must calculate the rate of each type of pipe based on its characteristics and then sum the rates of all active pipes to get the total rate.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Pipe A can fill an empty cistern in 6 hours while along with Pipe B it can fill it up in 4 hours. Only Pipe B is on for an hour after which Pipe A is also turned on. How much time will it take in all to fill up the cistern?
  2. Two pipes namely A and B can fill a tank in 25 minutes and half an hour respectively and a pipe C can empty 3 gallons per minute. All three pipes working together can fill the tank in 15 minutes. The capacity of the tank is:

  3. Two pipes X and Y can individually fill a tank in 48 and 72 minutes respectively. If they are opened simultaneously, how long would it take for the tank to fill?

  4. Two taps take 10 min and 15 min, respectively, to fill an empty pool. The first tap was ON for 4 min, after which it stopped working. How much time will the second tap take to fill the pool?

  5. P, Q and R are channels which discharge solutions A, B, C respectively in a tank. When the tank is empty and all the three channels are opened what is the proportion of the solution C in the tank after 3 minutes, if the channels P, Q and R can fill the tank from empty to full in 30 minutes and 20 minutes and 10 minutes respectively when they are opened one at a time.

  6. Two pipes fill a tank when working individually in 25 and 40 hours, respectively while a third pipe can drain the filled tank in 16 hours. If all the three pipes are turned on at the same time when the tank is empty, how long will it take to fill the tank completely?
  7. Pipe A could fill an empty cistern in 18 hours while Pipe B can drain a filled cistern in 30 hours. When the cistern is empty, Pipe A is turned on for an hour and then turned off. Now Pipe B is allowed to drain out water from the cistern for an hour and then turned off. The pipes were alternately left open for an hour each time till the cistern was full. How much time did it take for the cistern to be full?
  8. Two pipes A and B can fill an empty cistern in 32 and 48 hours, respectively. Pipe C can drain the entire cistern in 64 hours when no other pipe is in operation. Initially, when the cistern was empty Pipe A and Pipe C were turned on. After a few hours, Pipe A was turned off and Pipe B was turned on instantly. In all it took 112 hours to fill the cistern. For how many hours was Pipe B turned on?

  9. A tanker can fill a cistern in 12 hours. After half the cistern is filled, 2 more similar tankers are opened. What is the time taken to fill the remaining half of the tank?

  10. Pipes A, B and C are attached to an empty cistern. While the first two can fill the cistern in 4 and 10 hours, respectively, the third can drain the cistern, when filled, in 6 hours. If all the three pipes are opened simultaneously when the cistern is three-fifth full, how many hours will be needed to fill the cistern?


Important Questions from Pipe and Cistern

  1. Pipe P can fill $\frac{2}{3}$ part of a tank in 16 hours, and pipe Q can fill $\frac{5}{6}$ part of the same tank in 20 hours. Both P and Q were kept open for 2 hours, then both were closed. Pipe R alone was then opened and it emptied the water in the tank in 8 hours. Pipes P, Q and R together can fill the empty tank in:

  2. Pipe A can fill a tank in 18 hours, pipe B can fill the same tank in 30 hours and pipe C can fill the same tank in 18 hours. The time taken by them to fill the same tank if they operate together is::
  3. Pipe P can fill $\frac{2}{3}$ part of a tank in 24 hours, and pipe Q can fill $\frac{2}{3}$ part of the same tank in 16 hours. Both P and Q were kept open for 4 hours, then both were closed. Pipe R alone was then opened and it emptied the water in the tank in 5 hours. Pipes P, Q and R together can fill the empty tank in:

  4. Pipe P can fill $\frac{5}{7}$ part of a tank in 30 hours, and pipe Q can fill $\frac{2}{5}$ part of the same tank in 28 hours. Both P and Q were kept open for 7 hours, then both were closed. Pipe R alone was then opened and it emptied the water in the tank in 8 hours. Pipes P, Q and R together can fill the empty tank in:
  5. Pipe P can fill $\frac{3}{8}$ part of a tank in 21 hours and pipe Q can fill $\frac{2}{7}$ part of the same tank in 16 hours. Both P and Q were kept open for 2 hours, then both were closed. Pipe R alone was then opened and it emptied the water in the tank in 3 hours. Pipes P, Q and R together can fill the empty tank in:

Need Expert Advice?
Upcoming Exams
RRB Staff Nurse
November 23, 2026
RRB Paramedical
November 23, 2026
Test Series
RRB ALP img
Railways
RRB ALP 2026 Mock Test series
1035 Tests 1 Tests Free
1787 Attempts
4.3(259)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App