Which one of the following statements on the issue of ownership according to Smriti literature is not correct?
Stridhana was not inherited by the children without the permission of the husband.
Understanding Ownership in Ancient Indian Smriti Literature
The question asks us to identify the statement that is not correct regarding ownership according to Smriti literature. Smriti literature, including Dharmaśāstras, provides detailed guidelines on various aspects of life, including property rights, inheritance, and family law in ancient India.
What is Smriti Literature?
Smriti refers to "what is remembered," encompassing texts like the Dharmaśāstras (e.g., Manusmriti, Yajnavalkya Smriti) and other related works that deal with dharma (righteous conduct, duty, law). These texts served as foundational legal and social codes, outlining rules about property ownership, division of wealth, inheritance, and the rights of various family members.
Ownership and Property in Smriti
Smriti texts recognized different types of property and rules for their acquisition and transmission. Key aspects include:
- Joint Family Property: Property held collectively by family members, typically headed by the father. Sons acquired rights in this property by birth.
- Individual Property: Property acquired by an individual through their own efforts (e.g., earnings, gifts from strangers) or inherited separately.
- Stridhana: A special category of property belonging absolutely to a woman.
Examining the Statements on Ownership and Stridhana
Let's evaluate each statement based on the principles found in Smriti literature:
Statement 1: The paternal estate was to be divided equally amongst sons.
Smriti texts generally describe the division of paternal property (estate) among sons after the father's death or sometimes during his lifetime if he chose to retire. While practices varied slightly across different schools and periods, the principle of equal division among sons was a prominent feature of inheritance law as described in Smritis. Sons had a right by birth in the joint family property. This statement is broadly consistent with Smriti principles.
Statement 2: Women were allowed to retain the gifts they received on the occasion of their marriage.
This statement describes a key aspect of Stridhana. Gifts received by a woman on the occasion of her marriage (like presents from parents, in-laws, or guests) were considered part of her Stridhana, which was her exclusive property. She had full control over its disposal. This statement is correct according to Smriti literature.
Statement 3: The gifts to women on the occasion of their marriage were known as Stridhana.
This is the very definition of Stridhana according to Smriti texts. Stridhana encompasses various types of property a woman might acquire, with gifts received before, during, or after marriage being a primary component. The term literally means "woman's property." This statement is correct.
Statement 4: Stridhana was not inherited by the children without the permission of the husband.
This statement concerns the inheritance of Stridhana. Smriti texts provide specific rules for the succession of Stridhana upon a woman's death. These rules varied based on the type of Stridhana and whether the woman was married or unmarried, or had children. However, the inheritance of Stridhana typically devolved upon her heirs (like daughters, sons, etc.) according to prescribed rules, and the husband's permission was generally not required for her children or legal heirs to inherit it. Stridhana was her absolute property, and its devolution was governed by specific laws independent of the husband's control over her property or its inheritance. Therefore, this statement is not correct.
Conclusion
Based on the analysis, the statement that is not correct according to Smriti literature on the issue of ownership is that Stridhana was not inherited by the children without the permission of the husband.
| Statement | Correct/Incorrect (According to Smriti) | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Paternal estate divided equally amongst sons. | Correct | General principle of inheritance for joint family property. |
| Women allowed to retain marriage gifts. | Correct | These gifts form part of Stridhana, woman's absolute property. |
| Marriage gifts known as Stridhana. | Correct | Definition of a key component of Stridhana. |
| Stridhana not inherited by children without husband's permission. | Incorrect | Inheritance of Stridhana followed specific rules; husband's permission not required for children/heirs to inherit it. |
Revision Table: Key Concepts of Ownership in Smriti
| Concept | Description according to Smriti |
|---|---|
| Joint Family Property | Property held collectively by family members; sons have birthright. |
| Paternal Estate Division | Usually divided equally among sons after father's death. |
| Stridhana | Woman's exclusive property, including gifts received during marriage. |
| Woman's Control over Stridhana | Generally full control over disposal. |
| Inheritance of Stridhana | Devolves upon specified heirs (e.g., daughters, sons) according to specific rules, not subject to husband's permission. |
Additional Information on Smriti Ownership and Inheritance
Smriti texts like Manusmriti and Yajnavalkya Smriti provide detailed rules on property rights and inheritance, which form the basis of traditional Hindu law. The concept of Stridhana was significant as it represented a sphere of economic independence for women within the patriarchal family structure.
- Different types of Stridhana existed, and their inheritance rules could vary. For example, gifts received from parents might have a different order of succession than gifts received from strangers.
- Typically, Stridhana devolved first upon her female heirs (daughters, daughters' daughters, sons' daughters) and then, in their absence, upon male heirs (sons, etc.). The husband was also a possible heir in certain circumstances but not the primary one over children, and his permission was not a prerequisite for children inheriting it.
- The rules of inheritance for general property (like paternal estate) and Stridhana were distinct.
- The evolution of property laws in India, including the Hindu Succession Act, has built upon and modified these ancient principles.
Similar Questions
Which one of the following statements about the famous text of panchatantra is correct?
The Tolkappiyam is
Which one of the following is the largest linguistic group of India?
Consider the following statements about Patanjali’s Mahabhashya :
1. It makes a mention of Kautilya.
2. It is a book on grammar and refers to historical personalities only incidentally.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Which one of the following is NOT among the principal languages of Jammu and Kashmir?
The major part of Central Asia is dominated by which one of the following language families?
What is the name of the literary genre developed by the Khojas who are a branch of the Ismaili sect?
Who deciphered the Brahmi and Kharoshthi scripts?
Who is the author of Manimekalai?
Who composed Zatnavilas, a history of the rulers of Kashmir, in the time of Zainul Abidin?
Important Questions from Language and Literature
Gitanjali is a collection of poems by _______.
From which Veda Sanskrit literature has begun?
What is 'Jaya Samhita' better known as?
With reference to India, the terms ‘Halbi, Ho and Kui’ pertain to
R K Laxman is famous for ________
