All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which one of the following statements is not correct?

This question was previously asked in
NDA II 2015 GAT Previous Year Paper (16-Dec-2015)
The correct answer is

In steady flow, each particle may not follow the same path as taken by a previous particle passing through that point

Understanding Steady Fluid Flow and Streamlines

Fluid flow can be categorized in different ways based on its characteristics. Two fundamental concepts in fluid dynamics are steady flow and streamlines. Let's understand these before analyzing the given statements.

What is Steady Fluid Flow?

Steady flow is a type of fluid flow where the velocity of the fluid particles at any given point in space remains constant over time. This means if you observe a specific point in the fluid, the speed and direction of the fluid moving through that point do not change as time passes. Although the velocity is constant at a point, it can vary from one point to another in the fluid.

What are Streamlines?

A streamline is an imaginary line drawn in a fluid flow such that the tangent to the line at any point gives the direction of the fluid velocity at that point. In essence, streamlines represent the instantaneous direction of flow throughout the fluid. In steady flow, streamlines are fixed in space and do not change with time.

Relationship Between Streamlines and Particle Paths in Steady Flow

In steady flow, because the velocity at every point is constant over time, a fluid particle moving through the flow will follow a path that is identical to a streamline. This is because the direction the particle moves in at any point along its path is determined by the velocity vector at that point, and since the velocity vector field is unchanging, the path followed by the particle is also unchanging and coincides with a streamline. Therefore, in steady flow, the path traced by every fluid particle passing through a particular point is always the same, and it follows the streamline passing through that point.

Analyzing the Statements on Fluid Flow

Let's examine each statement given in the options:

  • Statement 1: In steady flow of a liquid, the velocity of liquid particles reaching at a particular points is the same path at all points

    This statement seems slightly incorrectly phrased. A more accurate phrasing would be that the velocity of liquid particles at a particular point is the same at all times. If interpreted this way, this is a defining characteristic of steady flow – the velocity vector ($\vec{v}$) at any point $(x, y, z)$ is a function of position only, i.e., $\vec{v}(x, y, z, t) = \vec{v}(x, y, z)$. If interpreted literally as written, it doesn't make sense. Assuming the intended meaning, this statement aligns with the definition of steady flow.

  • Statement 2: Steady flow is also called streamlined flow

    Steady flow is often referred to as streamlined flow or laminar flow, especially when the flow is smooth and orderly. Streamlined flow implies that the fluid particles follow well-defined streamlines. This statement is generally considered correct in the context of basic fluid dynamics.

  • Statement 3: In steady flow, each particle may not follow the same path as taken by a previous particle passing through that point

    As discussed earlier, in steady flow, the velocity at any fixed point does not change over time. This means that any fluid particle that passes through a specific point will experience the same velocity vector (speed and direction) as any previous particle that passed through that same point. Consequently, the path followed by every particle through that point will be identical. Therefore, the statement that a particle may not follow the same path is incorrect for steady flow. In steady flow, particle paths and streamlines are the same and are fixed over time.

  • Statement 4: Two streamlines cannot intersect each other

    A streamline indicates the direction of the fluid velocity at any point. If two streamlines were to intersect, it would imply that at the point of intersection, a fluid particle could move in two different directions simultaneously (along the tangents of the two intersecting streamlines). This is physically impossible for a single particle at a given instant (except possibly at stagnation points where the velocity is zero). Therefore, streamlines cannot intersect. This statement is correct.

Based on the analysis, Statement 3 is the one that is not correct regarding steady fluid flow.


Revision Table: Comparing Flow Types

Feature Steady Flow Unsteady Flow Turbulent Flow
Velocity at a point Constant over time Varies with time Rapid, random fluctuations
Streamlines Fixed in space Change with time Highly irregular, not well-defined
Particle Paths Follow streamlines, same for all particles through a point Generally do not follow streamlines (as streamlines change), vary for particles through a point Irregular, chaotic
Nature of flow Smooth, orderly (often called laminar) May be orderly or disorderly Disorderly, chaotic

Additional Information on Fluid Dynamics Concepts

Understanding fluid flow is crucial in many areas of physics and engineering. Besides steady and unsteady flow, flow can also be classified as:

  • Laminar Flow: This is a type of steady flow where the fluid particles move along smooth paths or layers, with little or no mixing between layers. Streamlines are parallel and orderly. Steady flow is often laminar at low velocities.
  • Turbulent Flow: This is a type of unsteady flow characterized by chaotic, irregular motion of fluid particles. Velocity at a point experiences rapid fluctuations. Streamlines are not clearly defined. Turbulent flow occurs at higher velocities.
  • Compressible vs. Incompressible Flow: In incompressible flow, the fluid density remains constant throughout the flow. Liquids are often treated as incompressible. In compressible flow, the density changes, which is significant for gases at high speeds.
  • Viscous vs. Inviscid Flow: Viscous flow involves internal friction within the fluid. Inviscid flow assumes zero viscosity, simplifying analysis but being an idealization.

These classifications help simplify the analysis of complex fluid behaviors observed in various physical phenomena.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Two substances of densities r 1and r 2are mixed in equal volume and their relative density is 4.

    When they are mixed in equal masses, relative density is 3. The values of r 1and r 2respectively are
  2. If some object is weighed when submerged in water, what will happen to its weight compared to its weight in air?

  3. Along a streamline flow of fluid

  4. Density of water is

  5. A container is first filled with water and then the entire water is replaced by mercury. Mercury has a density of 13.6 × 10 3kg/m 3. If X is the weight of the water and Y is the weight of the mercury, then

  6. While pouring water slowly from a jug, a general observation is that a water layer usually flows along the side of the jug. Which property of water among the following is responsible for this phenomenon?


Important Questions from Fluids

  1. When preparing systematic diagram of hydro power plant which of the following is not a component of it?

    1. Generator

    2. Turbine

  2. Two liquids of densities d1 and d2 are mixed in equal masses. Find the resultant density of the mixture.

  3. Water drops fall from the nozzle of a shower 5 m high on the floor. The drops are released at regular intervals of time such that the first drop reaches the ground when sixth drop is released from the nozzle. Taking g = 10 m/s2. What is the height of the fourth drop from the ground?

  4. Bernoulli’s theorem is based on which of the following laws?

  5. In the analysis of flow velocity of a fluid for a fixed instant of time, a space curve is drawn so that it is tangent everywhere to the velocity vector. Then this curve is usually known as

Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
NDA img
Defence
NDA 2026 Mock Test Series (Latest Pattern)
503 Tests 1 Tests Free
1066 Attempts
4.6(137)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App