All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which one of the following differential equations has a periodic solution?

This question was previously asked in
NDA I 2018 GAT Previous Year Paper (22-Apr-2018)
The correct answer is \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} + {\rm{\mu x}} = 0{\rm{\;}}\)

Understanding Periodic Solutions in Differential Equations

A periodic solution to a differential equation is a solution $x(t)$ that repeats itself after a fixed interval of time, called the period $T$. Mathematically, this means $x(t+T) = x(t)$ for all $t$, for some $T > 0$. We need to examine each given differential equation to determine which one admits such solutions.

Analyzing Option 1: \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} + {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\)

This is a second-order linear homogeneous differential equation with constant coefficients. The standard form is $a x''(t) + b x'(t) + c x(t) = 0$. Comparing this to the given equation, we have $a=1$, $b=0$, and $c=\mu$.

To find the general solution, we look at the characteristic equation, which is obtained by replacing the derivatives with powers of a variable, say $r$:

\(r^2 + \mu = 0\)

The nature of the roots of this characteristic equation determines the form of the solution.

  • If \(\mu > 0\), the roots are \(r^2 = -\mu\), so \(r = \pm \sqrt{-\mu} = \pm i\sqrt{\mu}\). These are purely imaginary roots.
  • If \(\mu = 0\), the equation becomes \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} = 0\), with roots \(r=0\) (repeated).
  • If \(\mu < 0\), let \(\mu = -k\) where \(k > 0\). The equation is \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} - {\rm{kx}} = 0\), with roots \(r^2 = k\), so \(r = \pm \sqrt{k}\) (real roots).

For periodic solutions to exist for a linear homogeneous equation of this type, the characteristic roots must be purely imaginary. This occurs when the coefficient of the $x'(t)$ term is zero (which it is, $b=0$) and the coefficients of $x''(t)$ and $x(t)$ have the same sign (which means $ac > 0$). In this case, $1 \cdot \mu > 0$, which requires \(\mu > 0\).

When \(\mu > 0\), the general solution corresponding to the roots \(r = \pm i\sqrt{\mu}\) is given by:

\(x(t) = C_1 \cos(\sqrt{\mu}t) + C_2 \sin(\sqrt{\mu}t)\)

This solution is a linear combination of sine and cosine functions with the same frequency \(\sqrt{\mu}\). Such functions are periodic with period \(T = \frac{2\pi}{\sqrt{\mu}}\).

Thus, the differential equation \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} + {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\) has periodic solutions when \(\mu > 0\). This equation represents simple harmonic motion, a classic example of a system with periodic behavior.

Analyzing Other Options

Let's briefly look at why the other options do not generally have periodic solutions.

  • Option 2: \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} - {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\)

    The characteristic equation is \(r^2 - \mu = 0\). Assuming \(\mu > 0\), the roots are \(r = \pm \sqrt{\mu}\) (real and distinct). The general solution is \(x(t) = C_1 e^{\sqrt{\mu}t} + C_2 e^{-\sqrt{\mu}t}\). Exponential functions are not periodic (unless $C_1=C_2=0$, which is the trivial zero solution, or if roots are complex, but that needs $\mu < 0$ here). For \(\mu < 0\), it becomes the same as Option 1 with a positive coefficient, so it would have periodic solutions only if $\mu$ is meant to be a parameter that can be negative. However, in the context of asking which *one* has a periodic solution, the standard interpretation of these forms points to Option 1 with positive \(\mu\) as the archetypal periodic case.

  • Option 3: \({\rm{x}}\frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{{\rm{dt}}}} + {\rm{\mu t}} = 0\)

    This is a first-order separable differential equation. We can rewrite it as \(x \, dx = -\mu t \, dt\). Integrating both sides gives:

    \(\int x \, dx = \int -\mu t \, dt\)

    \(\frac{1}{2}x^2 = -\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2 + C\)

    \(x^2 + \mu t^2 = 2C\)

    If \(\mu > 0\) and \(2C > 0\), this equation describes an ellipse in the \((t, x)\) phase plane. Solutions tracing such paths are periodic in the phase plane. However, when expressed as a function \(x(t)\), the solution is \(x(t) = \pm \sqrt{2C - \mu t^2}\). This solution is defined only for \(|t| \le \sqrt{2C/\mu}\), meaning it is only defined over a finite time interval, not for all \(t\). A periodic solution must be defined for all \(t\).

  • Option 4: \(\frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{{\rm{dt}}}} + {\rm{\mu xt}} = 0\)

    This is a first-order separable differential equation. We can rewrite it as \(\frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{\rm{x}}} = -{\rm{\mu t \, dt}}\). Integrating both sides gives:

    \(\int \frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{\rm{x}}} = \int -{\rm{\mu t \, dt}}\)

    \(\ln|x| = -\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2 + C'\)

    \(|x| = e^{C'} e^{-\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2}\)

    So, \(x(t) = C e^{-\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2}\) for some constant \(C\). Assuming \(\mu > 0\), as \(t \to \pm \infty\), \(e^{-\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2} \to 0\). This solution decays to zero and is not periodic (unless $C=0$, the trivial solution).

Based on the analysis, the only differential equation among the options that standardly and generally exhibits periodic solutions for appropriate values of the parameter (\(\mu > 0\) in this case) is the one representing simple harmonic motion.

Differential Equation Type Characteristic Equation/Method General Solution Behavior (\(\mu > 0\)) Periodic Solution?
\(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} + {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\) 2nd order linear, const. coeff. \(r^2 + \mu = 0\) (Purely imaginary roots) \(C_1 \cos(\sqrt{\mu}t) + C_2 \sin(\sqrt{\mu}t)\) Yes (if \(\mu > 0\))
\(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} - {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\) 2nd order linear, const. coeff. \(r^2 - \mu = 0\) (Real roots) \(C_1 e^{\sqrt{\mu}t} + C_2 e^{-\sqrt{\mu}t}\) No (generally)
\({\rm{x}}\frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{{\rm{dt}}}} + {\rm{\mu t}} = 0\) 1st order, separable, non-linear Integration yields \(x^2 + \mu t^2 = C\) Explicit solution \(x(t)\) defined only on finite interval No (defined for all $t$)
\(\frac{{{\rm{dx}}}}{{{\rm{dt}}}} + {\rm{\mu xt}} = 0\) 1st order, separable, linear Integration yields \(\ln|x| = -\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2 + C'\) \(x(t) = C e^{-\frac{1}{2}\mu t^2}\) (Decaying) No (generally)

Conclusion

The differential equation \(\frac{{{{\rm{d}}^2}{\rm{x}}}}{{{\rm{d}}{{\rm{t}}^2}}} + {\rm{\mu x}} = 0\), which describes simple harmonic motion when \(\mu\) is a positive constant, yields solutions that are combinations of sine and cosine functions. These are the characteristic periodic solutions.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. If x dy = y dx + y 2dy, y > 0 and y (1) = 1, then what is y (-3) equal to?

  2. What does the equation \(x \frac{dy}{dx}-2y= 0\) represent ?

  3. What is the solution of (1 +2x) dy – (1 – 2y) dx = 0?

  4. The general solution of \(\frac{{dy}}{{dx}} = \frac{{ax + h}}{{by + k}}\) represents a circle only when

  5. The differential equation of minimum order by eliminating the arbitrary constants A and C in the equation y = A [sin (x + C) + cos (x + C)] is

  6. What is the degree of the differential equation ?

  7. What is the differential equation of all parabolas of the type y2 = 4a (x - b)?

  8. The solution of the differential equation \(\frac{{{\rm{dy}}}}{{{\rm{dx}}}} = \frac{{{\rm{y}}\phi '\left( {\rm{x}} \right) - {{\rm{y}}^2}}}{{\phi \left( {\rm{x}} \right)}}\) is

  9. If y = (x x ) x , then which one of the following is correct ?
  10. If y = ln 2 \(\left(\frac{x^2−x+1}{x^2+x+1}\right)\) , then what is \(\frac{\text{dy}}{\text{dx}}\)  at x = 0 equal to ?

Important Questions from Differential Equations

  1. Given a differential equation $\frac{d^2x}{dt^2} + x = 0$ with $x(0) \neq 0$. 

    Which of the following statements is/are true?

  2. An ordinary differential equation is given below.
    $$x^2 \frac{d^2 y}{dx^2} = 6y$$
    Considering $a$ and $b$ as arbitrary constants, the general solution of the equation is
  3. If x dy = y dx + y 2dy, y > 0 and y (1) = 1, then what is y (-3) equal to?

  4. The degree of the differential equation $\frac{d^2x}{dt^2} + 2x^3 = 0$ is _______________  .

  5. If \(\frac{dy}{dx} = 2e^x y^3\), \(y(0) = \frac{1}{2}\) then what is \(4y^2(2-e^x)\) equal to ?
Need Expert Advice?
Test Series
NDA img
Defence
NDA 2026 Mock Test Series (Latest Pattern)
526 Tests 1 Tests Free
1202 Attempts
4.7(163)
English, Hindi

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App