Which of the following sentences are correct ? A. Gain of active filter can be more than 1. B. Gain of passive filter can be more than 1. C. Butterworth filter changes the roll off of output as its order changes. D. Phase of output at cutoff frequency in butterworth filter does not change with its order. E. Feedback is not needed in any filter circuit Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
A and C only
Judge each statement in turn.
A — "Gain of an active filter can be more than 1." TRUE. An active filter contains an op-amp (or transistor) powered from a supply, so it can deliver more signal power than it receives. A Sallen–Key low-pass section, for instance, has a passband gain of \(1+R_F/R_1\), which is set greater than unity whenever required.
B — "Gain of a passive filter can be more than 1." FALSE. A passive network of R, L and C contains no energy source, so it can only attenuate: \(|H(j\omega)|\le 1\) in the passband. (An LC network can show a voltage peak above unity at resonance because of Q-multiplication, but there is still no power gain, and the standard statement — and what the question tests — is that a passive filter cannot amplify.)
C — "A Butterworth filter changes the roll-off of the output as its order changes." TRUE. The stopband slope is fixed by the order n:
\(\text{Roll-off}=20n\ \text{dB/decade}=6n\ \text{dB/octave}\)
so a 1st-order section falls at 20 dB/decade, a 2nd-order at 40, a 4th-order at 80, and so on.
D — "The phase at cut-off does not change with order." FALSE. Each pole contributes 45° of lag at the cut-off frequency, so the phase there is
\(\phi = -n\times 45^{\circ}\)
−45° for first order, −90° for second order, −180° for fourth order. The phase at cut-off clearly depends on n. (What is independent of order is the magnitude at cut-off — always −3 dB — which is probably the fact the statement is trying to distort.)
E — "Feedback is not needed in any filter circuit." FALSE. Passive filters indeed use no feedback, but every active filter topology (Sallen–Key, multiple-feedback, state-variable, biquad) relies on feedback around the amplifier to place the poles and set Q. So the sweeping claim "any filter" is wrong.
The true statements are A and C.
Extra context on Butterworth. It is the maximally flat approximation, with magnitude \(|H(j\omega)|=\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{1+(\omega/\omega_c)^{2n}}}\) — no passband ripple, at the price of a gentler transition than a Chebyshev filter of the same order.
Hence, the correct answer is A and C only.
The active filter works well
What will be the 'change in roll off' when the order of a filter changes from 1st to 2nd ?
A band pass filter response has :
(a) Two critical frequencies
(b) Quality factor depends on the center frequency and the bandwidth
(c) Quality factor depends on the critical frequencies
(d) A voltage gain
Options :
A phase locked loop (PLL) consists of :
In choke input filter circuit, the first element is _______.
In the frequency response graph of an amplifier the 3 dB point refers to :
Which of the following statements is NOT correct for a Chebyshev Filter?
Which of the following statements is NOT correct about Butterworth filter?
The characteristic equation for the output voltage of an All‐pass filter is given by: