"We can affirm the truth of any sentence in our total system, in the face of whatever experience, just so long as we are prepared to make adjustments elsewhere." Discuss this statement in the light of Quine's 'Two Dogmas of Empiricism'.
This statement vividly expresses W.V.O. Quine's central argument in "Two Dogmas of Empiricism" (1951), where he fundamentally critiques two foundational tenets of logical empiricism.
The first dogma Quine attacked was the analytic-synthetic distinction: the idea that statements can be neatly divided into those true by definition (analytic) and those true by empirical fact (synthetic). Quine argued this distinction is ultimately indefensible, as no statement is immune to revision based on experience.
The second dogma was reductionism: the belief that every meaningful statement could be reduced to terms referring to immediate experience. Quine rejected this, proposing a holistic epistemology, where our knowledge forms an interconnected "web of belief."
The quoted statement illustrates this holism. It suggests that no single belief or sentence in our conceptual scheme is immune to revision. If an experience seemingly contradicts a belief, we don't have to abandon that specific belief. Instead, we can choose to make adjustments "elsewhere" in our web—revising other, more peripheral beliefs, or even logical rules, to preserve a central tenet. For example, confronted with apparent evidence contradicting a fundamental scientific law, scientists might first doubt their measurements or auxiliary hypotheses, rather than immediately discarding the law itself. This implies that the truth of statements is not determined in isolation, but by their coherence within the entire system, and our pragmatic choices about which parts to modify when faced with recalcitrant experience.
Answered By:
Discuss the role of biological, cognitive and learning influences on gender identity and gender typing by focusing on relevant theories and research studies.
Personality is all in our genes.' Evaluate the statement in the context of different personality theories.
In what ways is probability sampling appropriate in the conduct of psychological research? Illustrate your answer with different techniques of probability sampling.
When psychologists label their perspective humanistic, what does this term mean to you? What is its relevance in the modern era?
Are quasi-experimental designs more advantageous than experimental designs? Discuss in the light of various methodological considerations.
Bring out the contributions of Binet and Wechsler in the measurement of intelligence. In what ways are Wechsler's approach and procedures more effective than Binet's approach and procedures ? Discuss with examples.
Meditation alters consciousness.' Discuss this by explaining meditation and consciousness along with relevant research examples.
Do correlational studies contribute in understanding 'cause and effect' relationship in human behaviour? Discuss.
Explain how psychological and cultural factors affect perception.
Describe social cognitive theory and its applications to solve large scale societal problems.
Write a note in 150 words
Mendelian and non-Mendelian traits.
Write a note in 150 words
Theoretical significance of Purum kinship-system.
Write a note in 150 words
Smell as a signal among non-human primates.
Write a note in 150 words
Osteodontokeratik culture and its makers.
Discuss the Miocene hominoid remains and their significance in evolution.