All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

The failure plane in direct shear test is:-

The correct answer is

Horizontal Plane

The direct shear test is a common laboratory test in soil mechanics used to determine the shear strength parameters of soil, namely cohesion (\(c\)) and the angle of internal friction (\(\phi\)). Understanding the configuration of this test is crucial to identify the nature of its failure plane.

Direct Shear Test Apparatus and Procedure

The direct shear test is conducted using a shear box apparatus. This apparatus consists of a metal box split horizontally into two halves. A soil sample (either undisturbed or remolded) is placed inside this box. The test proceeds in two main stages:

  • Normal Stress Application: A vertical load is applied to the top of the soil sample, creating a normal stress (\(\sigma_n\)) across the horizontal plane where the box is split.
  • Shear Force Application: A horizontal shear force is then applied to the upper half of the shear box, while the lower half is restrained. This force causes the soil sample to shear along the predetermined horizontal plane.

Failure Plane in Direct Shear Test

The unique design of the direct shear box dictates where failure will occur. Because the box is split horizontally into two halves, and a shear force is applied to one half relative to the other, the soil sample is constrained to fail along this pre-defined, horizontal plane. This is a key characteristic of the direct shear test.

  • The test setup physically forces the failure to occur along the plane of separation of the shear box, which is always horizontal.
  • This fundamental aspect distinguishes it from other soil tests, such as the triaxial test, where the soil sample is free to fail along its weakest plane, which might be inclined at an angle determined by the soil properties.

Direct Shear Test: Why the Horizontal Plane?

The primary reason the failure plane in a direct shear test is horizontal is due to the mechanical constraint imposed by the shear box itself. The test is designed to measure the shear resistance along a specific, controlled plane. The separation of the shear box into two parts along a horizontal line directly defines the plane where shear displacement and, subsequently, failure will occur. This allows for a direct measurement of shear stress and displacement on that specific plane.

Understanding Other Failure Plane Options

Let's consider why the other options are generally not the primary failure plane in a direct shear test:

  • Weakest Plane: While in natural conditions, soil tends to fail along its weakest plane (the plane where the combination of normal and shear stresses is most critical), the direct shear test apparatus physically forces the failure to occur along the horizontal plane where the shear box is separated. Therefore, the failure plane in this test is not necessarily the intrinsically weakest plane of the soil, but rather the plane dictated by the test setup's geometry.
  • Major Principal Plane: The major principal plane is a plane on which the normal stress is maximum and the shear stress is zero. Failure in soils typically occurs on planes where the shear stress reaches a critical value, often related to the angle of internal friction, not necessarily on principal planes. In the direct shear test, the failure is along a plane subjected to both normal and shear stresses.
  • Vertical Plane: In the direct shear test, the shear force is applied horizontally to induce horizontal displacement and failure. A vertical plane is not the plane of imposed shear in this specific test setup; the primary shearing action happens horizontally.

In summary, due to the fundamental construction and operation of the direct shear apparatus, the failure plane is compelled to be the horizontal plane between the two halves of the shear box, allowing for controlled measurement of soil shear strength parameters.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Shear Strength

  1. In-situ vane shear test is conducted to determine the shear strength of

  2. For saturated soil, Skempton's pore pressure coefficient B is

  3. In tri-axial compression test, the length of specimen is kept about ________ its diameter.

  4. When drainage is permitted throughout the triaxial test, it is known as:

  5. The Mohr-Coulomb failure theory represents which of the following equation as the line that represents the failure envelope ?

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App