All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read the statement and identify the logically correct conclusions from the given information.

Statement:

Madhuri Dixit is a very good dancer. She is very flexible.

Conclusion :

I. All dancers are mostly flexible.

II. Not all dancers are flexible.

The correct answer is

Neither I nor II is correct.

Understanding Statement and Conclusions in Logical Reasoning

This question asks us to read a given statement and determine which of the provided conclusions can be logically derived from it. In logical reasoning, we must strictly adhere to the information provided in the statement and not bring in outside knowledge or make assumptions.

Analyzing the Given Statement

The statement is:

Statement: Madhuri Dixit is a very good dancer. She is very flexible.

This statement provides specific information about one individual, Madhuri Dixit. It tells us two facts about her: she is a good dancer, and she is flexible. This statement does not provide any information about other dancers or about the general relationship between dancing and flexibility.

Examining Conclusion I: All dancers are mostly flexible

The first conclusion is:

Conclusion I: All dancers are mostly flexible.

Let's evaluate if this conclusion logically follows from the statement. The statement only gives information about one dancer, Madhuri Dixit. It says she is flexible. From this single example, we cannot logically conclude that *all* dancers are mostly flexible. Making a generalization about an entire group ("All dancers") based on the observation of just one member is a logical fallacy (specifically, hasty generalization or converse accident). The statement does not provide enough evidence to support a claim about all dancers.

Therefore, Conclusion I is not logically correct based *only* on the given statement.

Examining Conclusion II: Not all dancers are flexible

The second conclusion is:

Conclusion II: Not all dancers are flexible.

Let's evaluate this conclusion. The statement tells us that Madhuri Dixit *is* flexible. It gives us absolutely no information about whether any other dancer is *not* flexible. Based solely on the statement that one dancer is flexible, we cannot logically deduce anything about the flexibility of other dancers. We don't know if some dancers are not flexible, or if all other dancers are also flexible. The statement simply doesn't provide the necessary information to support Conclusion II.

Therefore, Conclusion II is not logically correct based *only* on the given statement.

Logical Deduction Summary

Based on the analysis:

  • Conclusion I makes an invalid generalization about all dancers from a single instance.
  • Conclusion II makes a claim about the existence of non-flexible dancers, for which the statement provides no evidence.

Neither conclusion can be logically derived from the statement "Madhuri Dixit is a very good dancer. She is very flexible."

Hence, neither Conclusion I nor Conclusion II is correct.

Reviewing the Options

Let's look at the given options:

  • Only conclusion I is correct. (Incorrect)
  • Neither I nor II is correct. (Correct based on our analysis)
  • Only conclusion II is correct. (Incorrect)
  • Both I and II are correct. (Incorrect)

The logical analysis shows that neither conclusion is correct.


Item Assessment Reasoning
Statement Fact about one dancer Madhuri Dixit is a dancer and is flexible.
Conclusion I Invalid deduction Generalizing about ALL dancers from one example is illogical.
Conclusion II Invalid deduction No information in the statement supports a claim about non-flexible dancers.
Overall Neither conclusion is logically correct The statement provides insufficient evidence for either conclusion.

Revision Table: Logical Statement and Conclusion


Concept Description Relevance Here
Statement The given facts or premises. The information about Madhuri Dixit.
Conclusion An inference drawn from the statement. Proposed deductions about dancers' flexibility.
Logical Inference Drawing conclusions ONLY from the given statement. Crucial rule; external knowledge is ignored.
Generalization Making a broad statement from specific instances. Conclusion I attempts this invalidly.

Additional Information: Deductive vs. Inductive Reasoning in Logic

This question highlights the difference between deductive and inductive reasoning, although the task here is strictly deductive (drawing conclusions *necessarily* implied by the premises).

  • Deductive Reasoning: Starts with general statements and moves to specific conclusions. If the premises are true, the conclusion *must* be true. Example: All humans are mortal. Socrates is human. Therefore, Socrates is mortal. This is the type of reasoning tested in formal logic questions like Statement and Conclusion, where you check if the conclusion is *necessarily* implied.
  • Inductive Reasoning: Starts with specific observations and moves to general conclusions. The conclusion is probable, but not guaranteed, even if the observations are true. Example: Every swan I have seen is white. Therefore, all swans are white. Conclusion I in the problem ("All dancers are mostly flexible") is an attempt at inductive reasoning, but in the context of a deductive logic problem, it is considered an invalid step if the premise is only one example.

In Statement and Conclusion problems, we are primarily concerned with deductive validity. A conclusion is correct only if it *must* be true whenever the statement is true.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Statements and Conclusions

  1. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.

    Statement:
    Electrical engineers can apply for the posts currently vacant in ABC company.

    Conclusion:
    i) Banu, who is a computer engineer can apply for the post in ABC company.
    ii) ABC is a company that recruits electrical engineers in abundance.

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options
    (A) Only conclusion i follows
    (B) Only conclusion ii follows
    (C) Either i or ii follows
    (D) Neither i nor ii follows
    (E) Both i and ii follow.
  2. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement.
    Statement:
    Every kid must practise to drink a litre of water daily.
    Conclusion:
    i) Drinking water is necessary as kids play daily.
    ii) Water protect the kids from diseases.
    Choose the appropriate one from the following options
    A - The statement is definitely true.
    B - The statement is probably true.
    C - The statement cannot be determined.
    D - The statement is definitely false.
    E - Both i and ii follow.
  3. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Only Automobiles and Auto parts, are considered as luxury goods. ABC Ltd., produces luxury goods.

     Conclusions: 

    i) ABC Ltd., produces only automobiles. 

    ii) ABC Ltd., produces only auto parts. 

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options 

    (A) Only conclusion i follows 

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows 

    (C) Either i or ii follows 

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows 

    (E) Both i and ii follow.

  4. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follo follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Only rich people live in Seoul. Kim lives in Seoul. 

    Conclusion:

     i) Kim must be rich. 

    ii) Kim leads a happy life. 

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options

    (A) Only conclusion i follows

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows

    (C) Either i or ii follows

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows

    (E) Both i and ii follow

  5. In this question, a statement is given followed by two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to assume everything in the statement to be true, then consider the two conclusions together and decide which of them logically follows beyond a reasonable doubt from the information given in the statement. 

    Statement: 

    Soyabeans and cloves require a fair amount of farming space to grow. Mr. Ravi has 50 acres of land. 

    Conclusions: 

    i) Mr. Ravi can cultivate Soyabeans. 

    ii) Mr. Ravi can cultivate Cloves.

    Choose the appropriate one from the following options 

    (A) Only conclusion i follows 

    (B) Only conclusion ii follows 

    (C) Either i or ii follows 

    (D) Neither i nor ii follows 

    (E) Both i and ii follow.

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App