Pointing to a woman, Manish said, "She is the daughter of a woman who is my mother's husband's mother." How the woman is related to Manish?
Paternal aunt
Solving the Blood Relation Puzzle: Manish and the Woman's Relationship
This blood relation question requires us to carefully decipher the statement made by Manish about a woman. Let's break down the statement step by step from Manish's point of view:
- The statement is: "She is the daughter of a woman who is my mother's husband's mother."
- Let's analyze the relationships starting from "my mother's husband".
- Manish's mother's husband is Manish's father.
- Next, consider "my mother's husband's mother". This is Manish's father's mother.
- Manish's father's mother is Manish's paternal grandmother.
- So, the phrase "a woman who is my mother's husband's mother" refers to Manish's paternal grandmother.
- Now, the statement says, "She is the daughter of a woman who is my mother's husband's mother."
- This means, "She is the daughter of Manish's paternal grandmother."
Now, let's think about who the daughters of Manish's paternal grandmother could be in a typical family structure:
- The daughters of Manish's paternal grandmother are her own daughters.
- One possibility is the wife of her son (Manish's father), which is Manish's mother. However, Manish's mother is the *wife* of her son, not typically considered her *daughter* in this context unless it's a very unusual family structure, and standard blood relation questions assume direct lineage unless specified.
- The other possibilities are the sisters of Manish's father. These women are the daughters of Manish's paternal grandmother.
- The sisters of Manish's father are Manish's paternal aunts.
Therefore, the woman pointed to, who is the daughter of Manish's paternal grandmother, is Manish's paternal aunt.
Let's examine the given options:
- Paternal aunt: This fits our conclusion. A paternal aunt is the daughter of one's paternal grandmother.
- Sister: A sister is the daughter of one's mother. Manish's mother is the daughter of his grandmother, but the woman pointed to is the daughter of the grandmother directly, not the daughter of someone who is the daughter of the grandmother.
- Mother: Manish's mother is the wife of his father, who is the son of the grandmother. Manish's mother is not the daughter of his paternal grandmother (unless an unusual family structure is implied).
- Grandmother: The statement says the woman is the *daughter* of the grandmother, so the woman cannot be the grandmother herself.
Based on the analysis, the woman pointed to is Manish's paternal aunt.
Step-by-Step Relationship Breakdown
| Phrase | Meaning from Manish's perspective |
|---|---|
| My mother's husband | Manish's father |
| My mother's husband's mother | Manish's father's mother (Manish's paternal grandmother) |
| A woman who is my mother's husband's mother | Manish's paternal grandmother |
| She is the daughter of a woman who is my mother's husband's mother | She is the daughter of Manish's paternal grandmother |
| Daughter(s) of Manish's paternal grandmother | Manish's father's sister(s) which are Manish's paternal aunt(s) |
Thus, the woman pointed to is Manish's paternal aunt.
Revision Table: Blood Relation Terms
| Term | Relationship Definition |
|---|---|
| Paternal Aunt | Father's sister |
| Maternal Aunt | Mother's sister |
| Paternal Uncle | Father's brother |
| Maternal Uncle | Mother's brother |
| Niece | Brother's or sister's daughter |
| Nephew | Brother's or sister's son |
Additional Information: Solving Blood Relation Puzzles
Blood relation questions test your ability to understand and interpret complex relationship descriptions. Here are some tips for solving them:
- Break down the statement into smaller, manageable parts.
- Start from the perspective of the speaker (e.g., "my mother", "my father").
- Build a small family tree or diagram if needed to visualize the relationships.
- Translate each part of the description into a direct relationship.
- Consider all possible relationships that fit the final description (e.g., "daughter of my grandmother" could be mother or paternal aunt).
- Match your derived relationship(s) against the given options to find the correct answer.
- Pay close attention to gender and possessives (e.g., "his mother", "her brother").
Important Questions from General Blood Relation Problems
A is the husband of B, C is the mother-in-law of B, D is the father of A, E is the mother of D, F is the mother of C and G. If H is the father of D, then what is the relation of H with E?
Neeraj pointed at a photo of a lady and said, "She is the daughter of my paternal grandfather's only son. What is the relation of Neeraj with the lady in the photo?
If my sister's mother-in-law's only son is Devika's father, how is Devika's paternal grandfather related to my sister?
Pointing towards a boy, Ranjita said, “He is my husband's father-in-law's only daughter's son's father's only sister's son”. How is that boy's mother related to Ranjita's husband?
If Samaira is the daughter of my father's mother's only son, how is Samaira related to me?
