Look at the underlined part of each sentence. Below each sentence are given three possible substitutions for the underlined part. If one of them (a), (b) or (c) is better than the underlined part, indicate your response on the Answer Sheet against the corresponding letter (a), (b) or (c). If none of the substitutions improves the sentence, indicate (d) as your response on the Answer Sheet. Thus a “No improvement” response will be signified by the letter (d). They took away everything that belonged to him.
No improvement
Analyzing Sentence Structure and Verb Tense
The question asks us to evaluate if the underlined part "that belonged to him" in the sentence "They took away everything that belonged to him" can be improved by one of the given options. This involves understanding verb tenses, particularly in relative clauses, and the nature of stative verbs.
Understanding the Original Sentence
The original sentence uses the simple past tense "belonged". The verb "belong" is a stative verb, which means it describes a state or condition rather than an action. Stative verbs are typically not used in continuous tenses. The context of the sentence is the past ("They took away"). The belonging was a state that existed in the past when the things were taken away. Using the simple past tense "belonged" is appropriate for a stative verb describing a past state.
Evaluating the Substitution Options
-
Option (a): that had been belonging
This uses the past perfect continuous tense ("had been belonging"). The verb "belong" is a stative verb and is generally not used in continuous forms. This option is grammatically incorrect for the verb "belong".
-
Option (b): that belong
This uses the simple present tense ("belong"). The main clause "They took away" is in the past tense. The relative clause should reflect the state of belonging that existed at the time the action in the main clause occurred, which was in the past. Using the present tense here would imply the belonging is happening now, which doesn't fit the context of things being taken away in the past. This option is incorrect.
-
Option (c): that has been belonging
This uses the present perfect continuous tense ("has been belonging"). Similar to option (a), using the continuous form of the stative verb "belong" is grammatically incorrect. Also, the present perfect tense (even if it were correct for "belong") is typically used to connect past actions/states to the present, whereas the context here is purely in the past.
Conclusion: No Improvement Needed
The original sentence uses the simple past tense "belonged" for the stative verb "belong" to correctly describe a state that existed in the past. None of the provided substitution options improve the sentence. Options (a) and (c) incorrectly use continuous forms of a stative verb, and option (b) uses the wrong tense for the past context.
Therefore, the original sentence is grammatically correct and natural. The correct choice is that no improvement is needed.
The final answer is (d) No improvement.
Revision Table: Verb Forms and Tenses
| Verb Form | Example with "belong" | Usage Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Simple Present | It belongs to me. | General truths, habits, states (stative verbs). |
| Simple Past | It belonged to them. | Completed actions or states in the past (used here). |
| Present Continuous | N/A (for "belong") | Actions happening now (not for stative verbs like "belong"). |
| Past Continuous | N/A (for "belong") | Action ongoing at a specific time in the past (not for stative verbs). |
| Present Perfect | It has belonged to her for years. | States continuing from the past to the present. |
| Past Perfect | It had belonged to him before he sold it. | State that existed before another past action. |
| Perfect Continuous | N/A (for "belong") | Actions/states ongoing up to a point (not for stative verbs). |
Additional Information: Stative Verbs and Tense Usage
Stative verbs describe states, feelings, thoughts, possession, or senses, rather than actions. Examples include: believe, know, understand, love, hate, want, prefer, seem, appear, belong, have (for possession), own, smell, taste (when describing quality).
A key characteristic of stative verbs is that they are generally not used in continuous (or progressive) tenses (e.g., -ing forms like 'belonging', 'knowing', 'liking'). While there are some exceptions or specific contexts where this rule might be bent (especially with verbs that can function as both stative and action verbs, like 'have' or 'think'), for verbs like 'belong', the continuous form is almost always incorrect.
In relative clauses modifying a noun that was involved in a past event, the verb in the relative clause should typically use a tense that reflects its relationship to the main clause's time. If the state described by the relative clause existed at the same time as the past event in the main clause, the simple past is appropriate, especially for stative verbs.
The sentence "They took away everything that belonged to him" correctly uses the simple past "belonged" because the state of belonging existed simultaneously with the action of taking away, both occurring in the past. It follows the standard usage for stative verbs in a past context.
Important Questions from Phrase Replacement
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”
My old teacher gave many poor students money in spite of he was poor.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
You should to read the newspaper regularly if you want to be well-informed.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
If he had listening to me he would not have got lost.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”
He asked for a bank loan also he didn't have sufficient resources.
In the following question, out of the four alternatives, select the alternative which will improve the underlined part of the sentence. In case no improvement is needed, select “No improvement”.
I went to the shop to buy some stationeries .
