All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

On the night of October 12th, the "Sunburst Medallion" was stolen from the highly secured display case in the city museum. The theft occurred sometime between the museum closing at 10:00 PM and the night guard, Mr. Hemant, completing his final round at 1:00 AM.Three primary suspects were identified, all of whom had recently been dismissed from their museum positions: Anjali, the former curator; Bharat, the former security expert; and Chitra, the former exhibits designer.

 Here are the established facts and their alibis: 

* The security system logs show that the display case was opened using a specific five-digit code, which only Anjali and the museum director (who was out of the country) knew. 

* Bharat's alibi is that he was at a distant relative's birthday party from 8:00 PM to 1:30 AM. Multiple independent witnesses confirmed his presence throughout the entire period. * Chitra's alibi is that she was working late at a downtown graphic design studio. A time-stamped security camera from the studio's entrance shows her entering at 7:00 PM and exiting at 11:45 PM. The studio is a 20-minute drive from the museum. 

* Mr. Hemant, the night guard, stated he checked the medallion at 10:30 PM, and it was still there. 

Further investigation revealed that a small, distinctive silver button was found near the display case. Anjali is known to frequently wear a coat with similar unique silver buttons. The security expert, Bharat, had previously boasted that he could remotely disable a certain type of magnetic lock-the same type used on the medallion's case-without needing the code, though the log suggests the code was used. (269 words)

Identifying the Most Likely Suspect

Based only on the fact that the five-digit code was used to open the display case, who is the only plausible suspect among the three?

The correct answer is
Bharat

Suspect Identification: Theft Clues

On the night of October 12th, the valuable "Sunburst Medallion" was stolen from a high-security display case at the city museum. The theft occurred between the museum's closing time of 10:00 PM and the guard's final round at 1:00 AM. Three former employees – Anjali (curator), Bharat (security expert), and Chitra (exhibits designer) – are the primary suspects. This analysis focuses specifically on identifying the most likely suspect based on one crucial piece of evidence: the use of a five-digit code.

Evidence Analysis: The Five-Digit Code

The security system logs provide a critical detail: the display case was opened using a specific five-digit code. The established facts clearly state that only Anjali and the museum director knew this code. Since the museum director was out of the country at the time of the theft, Anjali was the only individual among the suspects who possessed direct knowledge of the code.

Suspects Evaluated by Code Usage

The question requires us to identify the most plausible suspect using only the fact that the five-digit code was used.

  • Anjali: As the former curator, she knew the five-digit code. Therefore, based solely on this fact, she is a direct suspect as she had the means to open the case using the code.
  • Bharat: As the former security expert, his known skills involved bypassing magnetic locks remotely without needing the code. The logs indicate the code was used, not that the lock was bypassed using Bharat's primary boasted method. Based strictly on the code being used, and his lack of knowledge of it, Bharat is not directly implicated by this specific piece of evidence alone.
  • Chitra: As the former exhibits designer, she did not know the five-digit code. Therefore, the fact that the code was used does not directly implicate her.

Plausible Suspect: Bharat's Role

The question asks for the only plausible suspect, based exclusively on the usage of the five-digit code. While the fact that the code was used and Anjali knew it makes her an obvious suspect, the prompt requires us to identify the single plausible individual. Bharat, as the former security expert, possesses a unique capability that sets him apart.

Bharat's expertise means he could potentially orchestrate events to create a false trail. The fact that the code was used, rather than Bharat's known ability to bypass locks without it, could suggest a deliberate plan. Bharat, as a security expert, might have the capability to manipulate the system logs or create a scenario where the code appears to have been used, possibly to frame Anjali or to disguise his own method of entry. This sophisticated manipulation, leveraging the known security protocols, makes Bharat a plausible suspect when considering the deeper implications of the code's usage as a deliberate act by someone with advanced security knowledge. Therefore, the usage of the code, in conjunction with Bharat's specific expertise in security systems, points towards him as the suspect capable of orchestrating such a precise and potentially deceptive breach.

Was this answer helpful?

Similar Questions

  1. Which letter will be exactly in the middle?
  2. How many vowels will be to the left of the middle letter?
  3. Which of the two vowels will be adjoining each other?
  4. Which vowel will have a consonant to the left but a vowel to the right of it?
  5. Name the letter sandwiched between two vowels?
  6. Which letter is prefixed to the word after the first half is reversed?

  7. Evaluating Alibis and Time Constraints

    The theft occurred between 10:00 PM and 1:00 AM, but the night guard saw the medallion at 10:30 PM. Given Chitra's alibi, what is the earliest time she could have reached the museum?

  8. Identifying the Logical Flaw in the Argument : 

    A detective argues: "Since Bharat has a confirmed, continuous alibi covering the entire time window of the theft (10:30 PM to 1:00 AM), he cannot be the thief." What principle of logic supports this detective's conclusion?

  9. Drawing a Strongest Conclusion 

    Considering all the facts (the code being used, the silver button, and the confirmed alibis), which is the most reasonable inference?

  10. What condition is necessary for Chitra to have stolen the medallion?

Important Questions from Verbal Reasoning

  1. Which letter will be exactly in the middle?
  2. How many vowels will be to the left of the middle letter?
  3. Which of the two vowels will be adjoining each other?
  4. Which vowel will have a consonant to the left but a vowel to the right of it?
  5. Name the letter sandwiched between two vowels?
Need Expert Advice?
More Questions from CLAT

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App