From the above excerpt, which of the following statement(s) is/are CORRECT?
i. Progressive mobilisations protesting violence against women can themselves reproduce patriarchy
ii. Contrary to popular perception, sexual violence against women happens only in the privacy of our homes
iii. According to popular perception, rapists are brutes or psychopaths
This question asks to identify the correct statements based on an excerpt by Flavia Agnes concerning the perception of rape following the Delhi gang rape incident.
Analyzing Flavia Agnes's Excerpt on Rape Perception
The excerpt critiques the popular narrative surrounding the Delhi gang rape. It highlights how media and public discourse often focused on specific scenarios (lonely places, late at night, strangers) and sensationalized perpetrators ('brutes or psychopaths'), while potentially overlooking the more common reality of rapes occurring within homes, schools, and by acquaintances or family members.
Statement Analysis
-
Statement i: Progressive mobilisations protesting violence against women can themselves reproduce patriarchy
The excerpt implies that by reinforcing a narrow, 'stranger danger' perception of rape, campaigns might fail to address the systemic issues of violence within domestic and familiar settings. This limited focus can inadvertently uphold patriarchal norms that obscure widespread violations within private spheres, thus potentially reproducing patriarchy.
-
Statement ii: Contrary to popular perception, sexual violence against women happens only in the privacy of our homes
The excerpt states that "most rapes take place in the privacy of our homes, in our schools." The use of "most" indicates a majority, not an exclusive occurrence. Therefore, the claim that sexual violence happens "only" in the privacy of homes is incorrect.
-
Statement iii: According to popular perception, rapists are brutes or psychopaths
The excerpt explicitly mentions that the incident reinforces the "popular perception that... rapists are brutes or psychopaths who deserve to be hanged." This statement is directly supported by the text.
Identifying Correct Statements
Based on the analysis:
- Statement i is correct as the focus on certain narratives can inadvertently perpetuate patriarchal views.
- Statement ii is incorrect because the excerpt uses "most," not "only."
- Statement iii is correct as it is directly stated in the excerpt.
Therefore, statements i and iii are correct.
Conclusion
The correct statements are i and iii.
Important Questions from Indian Family, Marriage & Kinship
- Who developed the concept of ‘seed and earth' as a way to understand the gendered division of labour and cultural construction of gender?
- Which of the following option(s) is/are CORRECT?
Patriliny is a kinship term that refers to_________.
- Which of the following author(s) highlighted the connection between kinship terminology and kinship structure in India?
- Reena and Sheena are Hindi-speaking neighbours who grew up together. Reena refers to Sheena's mother as *mausi* (mother's sister). This is an example of which of the following kinship type(s)?
