All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which one of the following statements is not correct regarding soil sampling?

The correct answer is
In thin-walled sampler, the internal diameter may range from 35 to 100 mm. The area ratio is approximately 100%.

Soil Sampling Statements Analysis

Identifying the Incorrect Statement

The question requires identifying the statement that is not correct regarding soil sampling techniques. We need to evaluate the characteristics provided for each sampler type.

Analysis of Sampler Statements

  • Option 1: This statement describes an open drive sampler with specific dimensions (internal diameter 100 mm, length 450 mm) and an area ratio of about 30%. These dimensions are plausible for certain types of open drive samplers used in soil investigations.
  • Option 2: This statement claims that thin-walled samplers have internal diameters ranging from 35 to 100 mm and an area ratio of approximately 100%. This statement is **incorrect**.
  • Option 3: This describes a split-barrel sampler with internal and external diameters of 35 mm and 50 mm, respectively, and an area ratio of about 100%. Calculating the area ratio: $ \frac{50^2 - 35^2}{35^2} \times 100\% \approx 104\% $. This value is consistent with typical split-barrel samplers (like those used in SPT).
  • Option 4: This statement characterizes a continuous sampler as a specialized tool capable of obtaining long undisturbed samples (up to 25 m), primarily used in soft clays. This description aligns with advanced sampling methods like piston samplers.

Reasoning for Incorrect Statement (Option B)

The key lies in the definition and purpose of a thin-walled sampler. These samplers are designed to extract high-quality undisturbed soil samples with minimal disturbance.

The area ratio measures the increase in area caused by the sampler wall thickness relative to the area of the sample itself. It is calculated using the formula:

$ \text{Area Ratio} = \frac{D_o^2 - D_i^2}{D_i^2} \times 100\% $ where $D_o$ is the external diameter and $D_i$ is the internal diameter.

For a sampler to be considered "thin-walled," the wall thickness ($D_o - D_i$) must be small relative to the diameter. This design minimizes soil disturbance upon entry. Consequently, thin-walled samplers inherently have a low area ratio, typically less than 10-15%. An area ratio of approximately 100% indicates a relatively thick wall, which contradicts the design principle of thin-walled samplers and would lead to significant sample disturbance.

Therefore, the statement that thin-walled samplers have an area ratio of approximately 100% is factually incorrect.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Site Investigation and Sub-Soil Exploration

  1. The ______ method of exploration was developed in connection with prospecting useful minerals and oils.

  2. Which among the following is NOT the method of exploration?
  3. Shelby tube is one of the most widely used devices for:

  4. If D1 & D2 are inside and outside diameters of the cutting edge then the Area ratio of the sampler is determined using the relation:

  5. Consider the following statements regarding anticline and syncline : 

    1. The presence of a syncline creates problem of seepage in a dam foundation. 

    2. There will be more bending of the anticlines in the upper strata and more joints due to tension stresses compared to lower strata. 

    3. A tunnel passing through a syncline will experience more lateral pressure in the middle part away from the portals. 

    Which of the above statements are correct?

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App