All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Which of the following is not a condition of Hume Rothery Rule for solid solutions?

The correct answer is

Element should form compound with each other

Hume-Rothery Rules for Solid Solutions

Solid solutions are formed when atoms of one element (solute) are dissolved into the crystal lattice of another element (solvent). For substitutional solid solutions, where solute atoms replace solvent atoms in the lattice, certain conditions favour the formation of extensive solid solutions. These conditions are known as the Hume-Rothery Rules.

The main Hume-Rothery rules are:

  • Atomic Size Factor: The atomic radii of the solute and solvent atoms should be similar. If the difference in atomic radii is more than about 15%, solid solubility is usually limited.
  • Crystal Structure: The solute and solvent metals should have the same crystal structure.
  • Valency: The solute and solvent atoms should have similar valency. A metal with a lower valency is more likely to dissolve a metal with a higher valency than vice versa.
  • Electronegativity: The electronegativity of the solute and solvent atoms should be similar. A large difference in electronegativity favours the formation of intermetallic compounds rather than solid solutions.

Identifying the Non-Hume-Rothery Condition

Let's look at the given options in the context of the Hume-Rothery rules:

  • Similar electro negativities: This is one of the stated Hume-Rothery rules. Similar electronegativity helps prevent the formation of compounds.
  • Same crystal structure: This is another key Hume-Rothery rule. Having the same crystal structure allows for easy substitution of atoms without disrupting the lattice too much.
  • Similar Valency: This is also a Hume-Rothery rule. Similar valency minimizes electrical differences between atoms, favouring solid solution formation over compound formation.
  • Element should form compound with each other: This condition directly contradicts the concept of forming a simple solid solution based on Hume-Rothery rules. Hume-Rothery rules predict conditions under which elements will form solid solutions, which are mixtures, not distinct chemical compounds. If elements readily form compounds, their tendency to form extensive solid solutions is reduced, especially if the compound formed is stable.

Therefore, the condition that "Element should form compound with each other" is not a condition that favours the formation of a solid solution according to Hume-Rothery rules; in fact, it suggests the opposite tendency (compound formation rather than simple mixing in a solid solution).

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Phase Diagrams

  1. Steel containing less than 0.8% carbons are called ________ and those which contain more than 0.8% carbons are called _______.

  2. The carbon present in Cast irons may occur in the chemically combined form known as _____

  3. The supersaturated interstitial solid solution of carbon in alpha iron is known as

  4. In an iron – carbon diagram, the percentage by weight of carbon at eutectoid composition is

  5. The mass fraction of α ferrite and cementite in pearlite is

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App