All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

The zero – air voids curve is non – linear owing to:

The correct answer is

The dry density at 100% saturation being a non – linear function of the void – ratio.

The zero – air voids curve, also known as the 100% saturation curve, represents the theoretical maximum dry density achievable for a soil at a given water content when there are absolutely no air voids present. In this state, the soil is assumed to be fully saturated (degree of saturation, S = 100% or 1).

Understanding the Zero-Air Voids Curve

The relationship between dry density ($\rho_d$), water content ($w$), specific gravity of soil solids ($G_s$), density of water ($\rho_w$), and void ratio ($e$) is given by:

\(\rho_d = \frac{G_s \rho_w}{1+e}\)

Also, the relationship between saturation, void ratio, water content, and specific gravity is given by:

\(Se = wG_s\)

For the zero – air voids curve, the degree of saturation is 1 ($S=1$). Substituting this into the second equation, we get:

\(1 \cdot e = wG_s\)

\(e = wG_s\)

Now, substitute this expression for the void ratio ($e$) into the formula for dry density ($\rho_d$):

\(\rho_d = \frac{G_s \rho_w}{1+wG_s}\)

This equation shows the relationship between the dry density ($\rho_d$) and the water content ($w$) for the zero – air voids condition.

Why the Zero-Air Voids Curve is Non-Linear

Let's examine the derived equation relating dry density ($\rho_d$) and water content ($w$) for the zero – air voids curve:

\(\rho_d = \frac{G_s \rho_w}{1+wG_s}\)

In this equation, $G_s$ and $\rho_w$ are essentially constant values for a given soil. As the water content ($w$) increases, the denominator ($1+wG_s$) increases. Since the denominator is in the form of $(1 + constant \times w)$, the relationship between $\rho_d$ and $w$ is not a simple linear one (like $y = mx + c$). This inverse relationship with a term dependent on $w$ in the denominator results in a non – linear curve when $\rho_d$ is plotted against $w$. The curve approaches the density of soil solids as water content approaches zero and decreases as water content increases.

Now consider the relationship between dry density and void ratio:

\(\rho_d = \frac{G_s \rho_w}{1+e}\)

This equation shows that the dry density is inversely proportional to $(1+e)$. This is a clear non-linear relationship between dry density and void ratio. Since, for the zero – air voids curve, the void ratio ($e$) is directly proportional to the water content ($w$) ($e = wG_s$), this non – linear dependence of dry density on the void ratio is the fundamental reason why the dry density is also a non – linear function of water content, resulting in a non – linear zero – air voids curve.

Analyzing the Options

Let's consider the given options:

  • Option 1: The standard proctor test data plotting as a non-linear curve describes the *result* of laboratory tests, not the fundamental theoretical reason for the zero-air voids curve's shape. The zero-air voids curve is a theoretical boundary based on physics.
  • Option 2: The dry density at 100% saturation being a non – linear function of the void – ratio. As shown by the formula \(\rho_d = \frac{G_s \rho_w}{1+e}\), dry density is indeed a non – linear function of the void ratio. Since $e$ is linearly related to $w$ on this curve, this non-linearity translates to the dry density vs. water content plot being non-linear. This option provides the correct physical reason.
  • Option 3: The water content altering during compaction. While water content can change during a poorly conducted test or due to evaporation, the zero-air voids curve is a theoretical plot assuming specific water content values. This doesn't explain the shape of the curve itself.
  • Option 4: The soil being compacted with an odd number of blows. This refers to the procedure of a compaction test (like Proctor), not the theoretical zero-air voids relationship, which is independent of the compaction method or number of blows.

Therefore, the non – linear relationship between dry density and void ratio at 100% saturation is the underlying reason for the zero – air voids curve being non – linear when plotted as dry density versus water content.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Compaction

  1. In a standard proctor test, the water content (W 1) and maximum dry density (γ dmax) are related as

  2. For standard compaction test done on soil, the mass of hammer and drop of the hammer are:

  3. In a Compaction test, as the compaction effort is increased, the optimum moisture content_____.

  4. In a proctor test, 1.8 kg of moist soil was filled in the mould (volume = 944 cc) after compaction. A soil sample weighting 23 g was taken from the mould and oven dried for 24 hours at a temperature of 110°C. The weight of the dry sample was found to be 20 g. The specific gravity of soil solids is G = 2.7. The theoretical maximum value of the dry unit weight of the soil at that water content is equal to _____

  5. If relative compaction is 75% and maximum dry unit weight is 21 kN/m 3, then field dry unit weight is ______.
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App