All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

The effective length of a compression member whose both ends are fixed in position only is _____.

The correct answer is

1L

Effective Length of a Compression Member

When designing compression members like columns, it's important to consider how they might buckle under load. The critical buckling load depends not just on the material and cross-section, but also on the length of the member and how its ends are supported. The 'effective length' is a concept used to account for these end support conditions.

Understanding Effective Length (Le)

The effective length ($L_e$) of a compression member is the length of an equivalent column with pinned ends that would have the same buckling load as the actual column with its specific end conditions. It is calculated using the formula:

$$L_e = K \times L$$

Where:

  • $L_e$ is the effective length
  • $K$ is the effective length factor, which depends on the end conditions
  • $L$ is the actual length of the compression member

Effective Length Factor (K) for Different End Conditions

The value of the effective length factor ($K$) varies significantly based on whether the ends of the compression member are free to rotate, fixed against rotation, fixed in position, or free to move laterally.

Commonly assumed idealised end conditions and their corresponding effective length factors are often represented in tables like the one below:

End Conditions Sketch Theoretical K Value Recommended Design K Value
Both ends pinned

—O—
|
|
O—

1.0 1.0
One end fixed, other end free

—█—
|
|
O—

2.0 2.0
One end fixed, other end pinned

—█—
|
|
O—

0.7 0.8
Both ends fixed

—█—
|
|
█—

0.5 0.65

Effective Length for Both Ends Fixed in Position Only

The question asks for the effective length when both ends are fixed in position only. This specific wording means that the ends cannot move horizontally or vertically (their position is fixed), but they are free to rotate. This condition is equivalent to having both ends pinned.

When both ends are pinned (or fixed in position only but free to rotate), the effective length factor $K$ is 1.0.

Using the formula $L_e = K \times L$:

$$L_e = 1.0 \times L = L$$

Therefore, the effective length of a compression member whose both ends are fixed in position only (and free to rotate) is equal to its actual length, $L$.

Looking at the options provided:

  • Option 1: 0.8L
  • Option 2: 1L
  • Option 3: 2L
  • Option 4: 0.65L

The effective length corresponding to both ends fixed in position only (equivalent to pinned-pinned for buckling) is 1L.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Compression Member

  1. What will be the effective length of a column of length L (compression member) fixed at one end and hinged at other end i.e. restrained in position but not in rotation?

  2. What will be the effective length of a column of length L (compression member) fixed at both ends i.e. restrained in position and rotation?

  3. What is the recommended value of effective length for a column held in position and restrained against rotation at one end, and at the other end restrained against rotation but not held in position?

  4. A steel column (f y= 250 N/mm 2, and f cd = 200 N/mm 2) of effective sectional area 6000 mm 2 will have strength equal to _____.

  5. If the depth of two column sections are equal, then the column splice is provided _____
Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App