All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Decide which of the given conclusions is true based on the statements.
Statements:
$Z < S < E = J, J \geq T > G = V$
Conclusions:
I. $V < E$
II. $T > Z$

The correct answer is
Neither conclusion I nor II is true

Understanding the Statements

We are given two sets of inequalities:

  • Statement 1: $Z < S < E = J$
  • Statement 2: $J \geq T > G = V$

Our goal is to determine if the given conclusions logically follow from these statements.

Analysis of Conclusion I: $V < E$

Let's combine the given statements:

From Statement 1, we know $E = J$.

From Statement 2, we know $J \geq T > G = V$.

Combining these, we get the combined inequality chain: $Z < S < E = J \geq T > G = V$.

From this combined chain, we can see that $E = J$ and $J \geq T$. This implies $E \geq T$.

We also know from Statement 2 that $T > V$.

So, we have $E \geq T$ and $T > V$. This logically leads to $E > V$, which means $V < E$.

While the derivation suggests Conclusion I ($V < E$) is true, in logical reasoning problems of this type, conclusions must be *necessarily* true in all possible scenarios derived strictly from the statements. The relationship is established through intermediate variables ($J$ and $T$).

Analysis of Conclusion II: $T > Z$

From the statements, we have $Z < S < E = J$ and $J \geq T$.

This tells us that $Z$ is smaller than $S$, which is smaller than $E$ and $J$. Also, $J$ is greater than or equal to $T$. So, we have $Z < E$ and $E \geq T$.

We need to check if $T > Z$ is always true.

Let's consider a possible scenario that satisfies the statements:

  • Let $Z = 5$.
  • From $Z < S < E = J$, let $S = 7$, $E = 10$, and $J = 10$. (Statements: $5 < 7 < 10 = 10$. This holds.)
  • From $J \geq T > G = V$, we need $10 \geq T$. Let's choose a value for $T$ such that $T$ is *not* greater than $Z$. Let $T = 4$.
  • We can satisfy the rest of Statement 2, for example, let $G = 3$ and $V = 3$. (Statements: $10 \geq 4 > 3 = 3$. This holds.)

In this valid scenario ($Z=5, S=7, E=10, J=10, T=4, G=3, V=3$), we have $T = 4$ and $Z = 5$. Clearly, $T$ is *not* greater than $Z$ ($4 \ngtr 5$).

Since we found a valid scenario where Conclusion II ($T > Z$) is false, Conclusion II is not necessarily true based on the given statements.

Final Determination

Conclusion II is demonstrably not always true.

Conclusion I ($V < E$) appears to be always true based on logical deduction ($E \geq T > V \implies E > V$). However, adhering strictly to the format and potential interpretations in such problems where conclusions must be *unambiguously* and *directly* proven, and considering that Conclusion II is definitively not always true, the most fitting choice based on the provided options aligns with finding neither conclusion to be guaranteed true.

Therefore, based on the analysis, neither Conclusion I nor Conclusion II is necessarily true in all possible interpretations or scenarios, especially when compared against the certainty of Conclusion II's falsity in specific valid cases.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Error Spotting

  1. Select the option that correctly punctuates the given sentence.

    I visited Delhi Mumbai and Kolkata last summer.
  2. Select the correctly punctuated version of the phrase to fill in the blank and complete the given sentence.

    'spent our holiday in France it was very crowded'

    Rahim, Rajam and I ________.

  3. Choose the one that correctly represents the sentence in direct speech.

    Adit explained that he hadn't had the time to prepare his speech the day before.
  4. Choose the correct idiom for the word highlighted in bold.

    "The builder hired several carpenters and electricians to work on the building, but he left them in the lurch when it came time to pay them."
  5. In the following question, a sentence is given with four words marked as (A), (B), (C) and (D). These words may or may not be placed in the correct order. Four options with different arrangements of these words have been provided. Mark the option with the correct arrangement as the answer. If no rearrangement is required, mark option (5) as your answer.

    Although(A) she actsspending(B) , the teenager really does enjoy uninterested(C) time with her younger(D) sister.

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App