All Exams Test series for 1 year @ ₹349 only
Question

Read given statement and conclusions carefully and choose which of the conclusions logically follows from the given statements.

Statement:

No paper is a book. All books are bag.

Conclusion:

I. No bag is a paper.

II. Some bags are paper.

The correct answer is

Either I or II follows.

Understanding Syllogism Statements and Conclusions

This problem involves analyzing logical statements and determining which conclusions logically follow from them. We are given two statements about the relationships between Paper, Book, and Bag, and we need to evaluate two potential conclusions.

Analyzing the Given Statements

Let's break down the statements provided:

  • Statement 1: No paper is a book. This tells us that the category 'paper' and the category 'book' have no overlap. There is absolutely nothing that is both a paper and a book.
  • Statement 2: All books are bag. This means the category 'book' is entirely contained within the category 'bag'. Every single book is also a bag.

Visualizing with Venn Diagrams

Venn diagrams are a helpful tool to visualize these relationships:

From Statement 1, "No paper is a book," we draw two separate circles, one for 'Paper' and one for 'Book', showing no intersection.

From Statement 2, "All books are bag," we draw a circle for 'Book' completely inside a larger circle for 'Bag'.

Now, let's combine these. The 'Book' circle is inside the 'Bag' circle. The 'Paper' circle has no overlap with the 'Book' circle. However, the 'Paper' circle could potentially overlap with the 'Bag' circle (the part of the Bag circle that is *not* the Book circle), or it could be completely outside the 'Bag' circle.

Evaluating the Conclusions

We need to see if the given conclusions are necessarily true based on our combined visualization.

  • Conclusion I: No bag is a paper.

    Looking at our combined diagram possibilities: Is it *necessarily* true that the 'Bag' circle and 'Paper' circle have no overlap? No. The Paper circle is separate from the Book circle, which is inside the Bag circle. But the Paper circle *could* intersect with the Bag circle outside the Book area. So, this conclusion is not necessarily true.

  • Conclusion II: Some bags are paper.

    Looking at our combined diagram possibilities: Is it *necessarily* true that the 'Bag' circle and 'Paper' circle have some overlap? No. The Paper circle, while separate from the Book circle (inside Bag), could be entirely outside the Bag circle. So, this conclusion is also not necessarily true.

Identifying the "Either-Or" Case in Syllogisms

Notice that Conclusion I ("No bag is a paper") and Conclusion II ("Some bags are paper") are contradictory. They form a complementary pair (specifically, an E type and an I type proposition concerning the same two categories, 'Bag' and 'Paper').

  • If "No bag is a paper" is true, then "Some bags are paper" must be false.
  • If "Some bags are paper" is true, then "No bag is a paper" must be false.

In any situation, regarding the relationship between 'Bag' and 'Paper', either there is *no* overlap (Conclusion I is true) or there *is* some overlap (Conclusion II is true). It is impossible for both to be false simultaneously.

Since our statements do not necessarily guarantee the truth of either conclusion individually, but the conclusions cover all possibilities and are contradictory, exactly one of them *must* be true. This is the classic "Either I or II follows" scenario in syllogism problems.

Conclusion Summary

Based on the analysis using Venn diagrams and the property of complementary pairs:

  • Conclusion I is not necessarily true.
  • Conclusion II is not necessarily true.
  • However, Conclusion I and Conclusion II are contradictory, meaning one of them must be true.

Therefore, either Conclusion I follows or Conclusion II follows.

Statement/Conclusion Analysis Validity
Statement 1: No paper is a book. Paper and Book sets are disjoint. Given
Statement 2: All books are bag. Book set is a subset of Bag set. Given
Conclusion I: No bag is a paper. Does Bag and Paper sets have no overlap? Not necessarily. Does not necessarily follow.
Conclusion II: Some bags are paper. Do Bag and Paper sets have some overlap? Not necessarily. Does not necessarily follow.
Relationship between Conclusions I & II Contradictory pair (E vs I type). One must be true. Either I or II follows.

Revision Table: Syllogism Basics

Statement Type Form Example Representation
Universal Affirmative (A) All S are P All cats are mammals. S is subset of P
Universal Negative (E) No S is P No dogs are birds. S and P are disjoint
Particular Affirmative (I) Some S are P Some students are tall. S and P intersect
Particular Negative (O) Some S are not P Some food is not tasty. S and not P intersect

Additional Information: Types of Conclusions in Syllogism

When analyzing syllogisms, conclusions can be:

  • Definitely True: The conclusion must follow from the statements in all possible valid diagrams or interpretations.
  • Definitely False: The conclusion cannot follow from the statements in any valid diagram or interpretation; its opposite must be true.
  • Possibly True / Possibly False: The conclusion follows in some valid diagrams but not others. In standard syllogism rules, such conclusions are considered as "not following".
  • Either-Or Case: Two conclusions form a complementary pair (like A-O or E-I) about the same terms, and while neither follows definitely, one of them must be true. This happens when the statements don't restrict the relationship between the two terms enough to make either specific conclusion necessary, but together the two conclusions cover all possibilities.

In this specific problem, Conclusions I ('No bag is a paper' - E type) and II ('Some bags are paper' - I type) form such an E-I complementary pair for the terms 'Bag' and 'Paper'.

Was this answer helpful?

Important Questions from Syllogism

  1. Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. You have to take the given statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from commonly known facts and decide which conclusion(s) logically follow(s) from the given statements.
    Statements:
    All water is milk.
    No milk is oil.
    Conclusions:
    (I) Some milk is water.
    (II) No oil is water.
  2. Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. You have to take the given statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from commonly known facts and decide which conclusion(s) logically follow(s) from the given statements.
    Statements:
    Some vegetables are fruits.
    Some fruits are sweets.
    Conclusions:
    (I) Some fruits are vegetables.
    (II) Some sweets are vegetables.
  3. Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
    Statements:
    All sparrows are owls.
    No sparrow is a parrot.
    Conclusions:
    (I): No owl is a parrot.
    (II): No parrot is a sparrow.
  4. Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
     

    Statements:
    All forests are hills.
    Some hills are deserts.
     

    Conclusions:
    (I): All hills are forests.
    (II): Some deserts are hills.

  5. Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
     

    Statements:
    All bottles are ludo.
    All ludo are dancer.
     

    Conclusions:
    (I): Some dancers are ludo.
    (II): All bottles are dancers.

Need Expert Advice?

Start Your Preparation with Prepp Mobile App

Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Download the app from Google Play & App Store
Prepp Mobile App